Question

In: Economics

8. Both Ricardo and Marx developed labor theories of value. How does Marx’s theory differ from...

8. Both Ricardo and Marx developed labor theories of value. How does Marx’s theory differ from Ricardo’s?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Ricardo's Labor Theory of Value

Marx's Labor Theory of Value

He stated that prices = wages + profit (rent zero) because wages and profits determined prices while prices determined rent.

He stated the prices of production (i.e. c + v + s) were equal to dead labor or fixed capital plus living labor or variable capital plus surplus value or labor.

Labor embodied in commodities was the primary determinant of prices, and prices were equal to labor embodied (value) only when capital to labor ratios were the same across industries

Marx used "abstract" labor or socially average necessary labor and reduced all skilled labor down to a simple multiple of unskilled labor (homogeneous labor)

Ricardo's theory of profit was based on his corn models where the profit rate was equal to net product (NP) or total profit or r = f(x)/X (marginal production function divided by subsistence wage or the total capital advanced).

Marx "stated that profit rate could be expressed by the equation: r = s/v/(c/v + 1).


Related Solutions

How does Marx use the labor theory of value to critique capitalism?
How does Marx use the labor theory of value to critique capitalism?
1) (Labor Theory of Value): Describe Marx’s labor theory of value. Explain how he argues that...
1) (Labor Theory of Value): Describe Marx’s labor theory of value. Explain how he argues that capitalism is unsustainable. In explaining his argument, use the system of equations (logic). 2) (Material Balances): Describe the concept of material balances as used by centrally planned economies. Explain what it means, how it is used, and how it was done in practice. Finally, what are some critiques of the material balances approach? How is input-output analysis relevant for planning in a centrally planned...
According to Marx, Class is structurally determined – what does this mean? How does Marx’s theory...
According to Marx, Class is structurally determined – what does this mean? How does Marx’s theory of class relate to history and the present - in your answers explain and discuss class consciousness, false consciousness, and ideology.
Answer all parts of this question in terms of Marx’s labor theory of value. The labor...
Answer all parts of this question in terms of Marx’s labor theory of value. The labor value of the wages necessary to produce a ton of bricks is 5 hours. The labor value of the constant capital necessary to produce a ton of bricks is 4 hours. The labor value of the surplus which goes to the capitalist owner of the brick factory is 3 hours for every ton of bricks.   a. What is the labor value of a ton...
How does Schumpeter’s vision of the capitalist process overlap with and differ from Marx’s? Why did...
How does Schumpeter’s vision of the capitalist process overlap with and differ from Marx’s? Why did Schumpeter believe that capitalism could not survive? How does his vision here compare to those of Veblen and Keynes?
What is the new growth theory? how does the new growth theory differ from the growth...
What is the new growth theory? how does the new growth theory differ from the growth theory developed by Robert Solow?
How does Islam differ from Christianity both politically and spiritually?
How does Islam differ from Christianity both politically and spiritually?
What is the essence of the theory of surplus value according to Karl Marx and how...
What is the essence of the theory of surplus value according to Karl Marx and how does it grow?
How does Fisher’s quantity theory of money differ from the Keynes quantity theory of money? (Answers...
How does Fisher’s quantity theory of money differ from the Keynes quantity theory of money? (Answers should be accurate, insightful, thorough, and clearly expressed. They should also demonstrate strong command of key ideas, theories, research findings, and policy debates)
Q 5 (A): How does Fishers Quantity Theory of money differ from Keynes Quantity Theory of...
Q 5 (A): How does Fishers Quantity Theory of money differ from Keynes Quantity Theory of money? Explain with diagrams. (B): Explain with reference to Expectation Theory that how interest rates vary across maturities. explain each parts separately and briefly
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT