Question

In: Nursing

Using a specific example, explain the meaning of ecological fallacy?

Using a specific example, explain the meaning of ecological fallacy?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Ans. An ecological fallacy (also ecological inference fallacy or population fallacy) is a formal fallacy in the interpretation of statistical data that occurs when inferences about the nature of individuals are deduced from inferences about the group to which those individuals belong. 'Ecological fallacy' is a term that is sometimes used to describe the fallacy of division, which is not a statistical fallacy. The four common statistical ecological fallacies are: confusion between ecological correlations and individual correlations, confusion between group average and total average, Simpson's paradox, and confusion between higher average and higher likelihood.

An example of ecological fallacy is the assumption that a population mean has a simple interpretation when considering likelihoods for an individual. For instance, if the mean score of a group is larger than zero, this does not imply that a random individual of that group is more likely to have a positive score than a negative one (as long as there are more negative scores than positive scores an individual is more likely to have a negative score). Similarly, if a particular group of people is measured to have a lower mean IQ than the general population, it is an error to conclude that a randomly-selected member of the group is more likely than not to have a lower IQ than the mean IQ of the general population; it is also not necessarily the case that a randomly selected member of the group is more likely than not to have a lower IQ than a randomly-selected member of the general population. Mathematically, this comes from the fact that a distribution can have a positive mean but a negative median. Mathematically, this comes from the fact that a distribution can have a positive mean but a negative median. This property is linked to the skewness of the distribution.


Related Solutions

Explain the terms ecological fallacy and reductionism and provide examples of each.
Explain the terms ecological fallacy and reductionism and provide examples of each.
Explain meaning of integration by using the information and example given Integration • In the context...
Explain meaning of integration by using the information and example given Integration • In the context of integration, explain the difference, and illustrate with an example, between after tax cash of $10,000 earned as interest income and as eligible dividend income. Use the combined 38.29% Federal and BC marginal tax rate and the 2020 rates for general corporate tax and eligible dividend tax credit (hint 27%, 38%, 15.02%, 12%) Post in relation to your topic o An explanation; o An...
Common logical fallacies: ● Explain and give an example of the causal slippery slope fallacy that...
Common logical fallacies: ● Explain and give an example of the causal slippery slope fallacy that Hamilton makes ● Which fallacy do you believe is used the most in everyday life, and what is the reasoning for its usage? ● Suppose that a football quarterback has been throwing 5 touchdowns a game. All of a sudden, he starts playing average. What explains his fall? ● How do common everyday fallacies effect our everyday communications ● How will a small sample...
Give an example of a logical fallacy that you've seen in the news today. Explain why...
Give an example of a logical fallacy that you've seen in the news today. Explain why it is a fallacy and how would you systematically argue it. Please at least 250 words. Thank you.
Which of the following is an example of the ad hominem fallacy?
Which of the following is an example of the ad hominem fallacy?a.John assures his wife that it’s ethically acceptable for him to cheat on her because history is filled with spouses cheating on each other; it’s “natural,” says Johnb.Paul lost his job one month after President Obama was sworn into office. He concludes, therefore, that President Obama's policies caused his job lossc.George rejects Elvis's argument that America is a good country to live in; George reasons that Elvis's argument about...
Using a specific numerical example explain the statement that "given the return on assets, the lower...
Using a specific numerical example explain the statement that "given the return on assets, the lower the bank capital, the higher the return for the owners of the bank."
Explain the give back fallacy
Explain the give back fallacy
Explain what synergy means at the strategic level of an organization, using an original, specific example.
Explain what synergy means at the strategic level of an organization, using an original, specific example.
Explain the difference between nonspecific binding and specific binding using an indirect ELISA as an example....
Explain the difference between nonspecific binding and specific binding using an indirect ELISA as an example. For this assay, assume that you are determining the titer of antibody against BSA. You bind BSA to wells of a microtiter plate, add a dilution series of the antibody in question across the wells of the plate, then detect that antibody with an enzyme-conjugated antibody/chromogenic substrate pair.
What is the formula of CAPM?  ​ Explain the meaning of the formula. give an example
What is the formula of CAPM?  ​ Explain the meaning of the formula. give an example
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT