Question

In: Physics

One of the curses of 2-liter bottles is that when carbonated beverages are stored in them...

One of the curses of 2-liter bottles is that when carbonated beverages are stored in them for long periods (i.e. days between drinks) at least the last liter ends up being flat. However, if after every pour the bottle itself is crushed such that the remaining volume of air above the liquid is as small as possible, and such that the structure of the bottle will prevent it from deforming back to its original shape (easily done by crushing the dome first and then working your way down), then the soda will stay nice and fizzy down to pretty much the bitter end, when it becomes impossible to crush the bottle any more but a significant air volume remains.

I know the answer has to do with vapor pressures and equilibrium, but when I try and articulate my thoughts to others their eyes glaze over. Can anyone come up with a broadly accessible, fairly pithy, and yet technically correct explanation?

I realize this is perhaps slightly more on the chemistry side of things than physics, but (1) there's no chemistry Stack Exchange site, and (2) this post seemed reasonable precedence.

Solutions

Expert Solution

I started writing a catchy but long explanation, but since you understand it and want something short for others, let's try this...

If you put too much salt in a glass of water, you saturate the water and end up with salt sitting at the bottom of the glass. If the temperature changes, the amount of salt that can dissolve changes (more for higher temperature, but you can leave that out). (For extra pithy-ness, leave this paragraph out entirely.)

For gases, besides liquid temperature, gas pressure matters. More pressure means more dissolves. When you open the soda and lose the factory-provided pressure, the gas pressure above the soda is suddenly lower, so carbon dioxide starts leaving the soda. It keeps doing this until "enough" CO2 is in the space above the soda. More space means you need more CO2 to fill it up. So, if you crush the bottle to leave less space, less CO2 escapes from the soda, and it stays fizzy.

Of course, this glosses over a lot of usefully clarifying stuff, such as the concepts you mentioned in your post, but it keeps it short. If you can hold their attention long enough, I would throw in a comment about how only the CO2 pressure matters, not the general gas pressure, just so they don't buy those worthless "pump air into your soda bottle" devices.


Related Solutions

2. We are interested in answering the question: Is the average price of Pepsi 2-Liter bottles...
2. We are interested in answering the question: Is the average price of Pepsi 2-Liter bottles in Kentucky less than 99 cents? A sample of 75 stores selling Pepsi 2-liters found an average price of 96 cents. The test was performed at the 1% significance level and the resulting p-value was 0.0065. 3. A researcher believes that if patients with arthritis go to physical therapy twice a week their pain levels will be lower than usual pain levels. Patients with...
Carbonated beverages must be kept acidic in order to generate the levels of CO2 (g) desired....
Carbonated beverages must be kept acidic in order to generate the levels of CO2 (g) desired. The acidity if provided by 0.0070 M H3PO4. Calculate the [H+], [OH-], [H3PO4], [H2PO4-], [HPO42-], and [PO43-], as well as pH, in a can of cola.
The fill amount in 2-liter soft drink bottles is normally distributed, with a mean of 2.0...
The fill amount in 2-liter soft drink bottles is normally distributed, with a mean of 2.0 liters and a standard deviation of 0.05 liter. If bottles contain less than 95% of the listed net content (1.90 liters, in this case), the manufacturer may be subject to penalty by the state office of consumer affairs. Bottles that have a net content above 2.10 liters may cause excess spillage upon opening. What proportion of the bottles will contain a. between 1.90 and...
The company has two machines which are used to fill bottles with the carbonated beverage. The...
The company has two machines which are used to fill bottles with the carbonated beverage. The actual amount filled in each bottle is assumed to have a normal distribution. For Machine 1, the standard deviation is known to be s1=0.015 and for Machine 2 it is known to be s2=0.018. The quality control department wants to check if the two machines fill the same net volume on average. They randomly collect 10 bottles which were filled by Machine 1, and...
A supermarket has determined that daily demand for one-liter milk bottles has an approximate bell shaped...
A supermarket has determined that daily demand for one-liter milk bottles has an approximate bell shaped distribution, with a mean of 55 bottles and a variance of 36 a) How often can we expect between 43 and 67 bottles to be sold in a day? (Give a percentage.) b) What percentage of the time will the number of bottles sold more than 61 bottles c) If the supermarket begins each morning with a supply of 73 bottles how often will...
Two companies, X-Cola and Y-Cola are competing in selling carbonated beverages. Assume that the total market...
Two companies, X-Cola and Y-Cola are competing in selling carbonated beverages. Assume that the total market for their combined beverages is 1,000 bottles per day, and that each bottle sells for $1 (regardless of the brand or anything else). The companies can choose to advertise or not to advertise their products. Advertising costs $200 per day. If neither X-Cola nor Y-Cola choose to advertise or if both choose to advertise, they split the market equally, so each company sells 500...
The following data represent the amount of soft drink filled in a sample of 50 consecutive 2- liter bottles.
  The following data represent the amount of soft drink filled in a sample of 50 consecutive 2- liter bottles. The results, listed horizontally in the order of being filled, were: 2.109 2.086 2.066 2.075 2.065 2.057 2.052 2.044 2.036 2.038 2.031 2.029 2.025 2.029 2.023 2.02 2.015 2.014 2.013 2.014 2.012 2.012 2.012 2.01 2.005 2.003 1.999 1.996 1.997 1.992 1.994 1.986 1.984 1.981 1.973 1.975 1.971 1.969 1.966 1.967 1.963 1.957 1.951 1.951 1.947 1.941 1.941 1.938 1.908...
An automatic bottling machine fills oil into 2-liter (2,000 cm3) bottles. A consumer advocate wants to...
An automatic bottling machine fills oil into 2-liter (2,000 cm3) bottles. A consumer advocate wants to test the null hypothesis that the average amount filled by the machine into a bottle is at least 2,000 cm3. A random sample of 40 bottles coming out of the machine was selected and the exact contents of the selected bottles are recorded. The sample mean was 1,999.6 cm 3. The population standard deviation is known from past experience to be 1.30 cm3. Test...
Bottles that carry carbonated soda underwent a makeover. Suppose researchers want to test the bursting strength of these designs to make sure no one loses a hand or something.
 Bottles that carry carbonated soda underwent a makeover. Suppose researchers want to test the bursting strength of these designs to make sure no one loses a hand or something. 10 random samples from the old design and 10 random samples from the new design were taken. The strengths of the bottles are given in the table below. Note that these designs are independent of each other Old design 210 212 211 211 190 213 212 211 164 209  New design 216 217 162...
The fill amount in 11​-liter soft drink bottles is normally​ distributed, with a mean of 1.01.0...
The fill amount in 11​-liter soft drink bottles is normally​ distributed, with a mean of 1.01.0 literliter and a standard deviation of 0.040.04 liter. If bottles contain less than 9494​% of the listed net content ​(0.940.94 ​liters, in this​ case), the manufacturer may be subject to penalty by the state office of consumer affairs. Bottles that have a net content above 1.051.05 liters may cause excess spillage upon opening. In an effort to reduce the number of bottles that contain...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT