Question

In: Physics

Are there any massless (zero invariant mass) particles carrying electric charge? If not, why not? Do...

Are there any massless (zero invariant mass) particles carrying electric charge?

If not, why not? Do we expect to see any or are they a theoretical impossibility?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There's no problem in writing down a theory that contains massless charged particles. Simple for a complex field will do the job. You might run into problems with renormalization but I don't want to get into that here (mostly because there are better people here who can fill in the details if necessary).

Disregarding theory, those particles would be easy to observe assuming their high enough density. Also, as you probably know, particles in Standard Model compulsorily decay (sooner or later) into lighter particles as long as conservation laws (such as electric charge conservation law) are satisfied. So assuming massless charged particles exist would immediately make all the charged matter (in particular electrons) unstable unless those new particles differed in some other quantum numbers.

Now, if you didn't mention electric charge in particular, the answer would be simpler as we have massless (color-)charged gluons in our models. So it's definitely nothing strange to consider massless charged particles. It's up to you whether you consider electric charge more important than color charge.

Another take on this issue is that Standard Model particles (and in particular charged ones) were massless before electrosymmetric breaking (at least disregarding other mechanisms of mass generation). So at some point in the past, this was actually quite common.


Related Solutions

Describe the nature of colloidal precipitate particles. (describe the electric double layer) ,Why do they tend...
Describe the nature of colloidal precipitate particles. (describe the electric double layer) ,Why do they tend to not settle, and What factors control coagulation of a colloidal particles?
Two particles a and b with same charge q and same mass m move uniformly in...
Two particles a and b with same charge q and same mass m move uniformly in a circular orbit around a stationary particle with a charge Q. If a has a speed Va=4m/s and radius Ra=6m, what is the radius of the orbit Rb of b if its speed is Vb=8m/s?
a.) Two identical particles of charge 3 μμC and mass 6 μμg are initially at rest...
a.) Two identical particles of charge 3 μμC and mass 6 μμg are initially at rest and held 3 cm apart. How fast will the particles move when they are allowed to repel and separate to very large (essentially infinite) distance? b) Now suppose that the two particles have the same charges from the previous problem, but their masses are different. One particle has mass 6 μμg as before, but the other one is heavier, with a mass of 48...
At which pH would the net electric charge of tyrosine be zero, given that its -COOH...
At which pH would the net electric charge of tyrosine be zero, given that its -COOH group has a pKa of 2.20, its –NH3+ group has a pKa of 9.11, and its R group has a pKa of 10.07?
12) Two identical particles of charge 6 μC and mass 4 μg are initially at rest...
12) Two identical particles of charge 6 μC and mass 4 μg are initially at rest and held 4 cm apart. How fast will the particles move when they are allowed to repel and separate to very large (essentially infinite) distance? Answer: Last Answer Hint: The particles are identical, so you can assume that the scenario is symmetrical. Use energy conservation: What type of energy is stored in the system when the particles are near each other and at rest?...
What does it mean when we say that integer spin particles are force carrying? Why are...
What does it mean when we say that integer spin particles are force carrying? Why are photons an example of this?
1. Electric charge is A property of matter that is distinct from energy, momentum, mass, velocity,...
1. Electric charge is A property of matter that is distinct from energy, momentum, mass, velocity, and acceleration. A property of matter that is determined by the energy of an object. A property of matter that related directly to the momentum of an object. 2. After rubbing a plastic ruler with a felt cloth, the ruler becomes negatively charged because: The cloth destroyed positive charges in the ruler. The kinetic energy lost to friction was converted into positive charges. The...
How mass effects time, what is inertia and why time slows down for particles having mass...
How mass effects time, what is inertia and why time slows down for particles having mass when they approach to light speed?
The electric field at a point in space is a measure of (a) The total charge on an object at that point. (b) The electric force on any charged object at that point.
The electric field at a point in space is a measure of(a) The total charge on an object at that point.(b) The electric force on any charged object at that point.(c) The charge-to-mass ratio of an object at that point.(d) The electric force per unit mass on a point charge at that point.(e) The electric force per unit charge on a point charge at that point.
Kirchhoff’s Junction Rule is a consequence of the law of Conservation of Electric Charge. Explain why.
Kirchhoff’s Junction Rule is a consequence of the law of Conservation of Electric Charge. Explain why.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT