Question

In: Physics

In the past few days I've become increasingly intrigued by the QHE, mainly thanks to very...

In the past few days I've become increasingly intrigued by the QHE, mainly thanks to very interesting questions and answers that have appeared here. Unfortunately, I am as of yet very confused by all the (seemingly disparate) stuff I learned.

First, here are some random points that I've been able to gather

I(nteger)QHE occurs due to the presence of Landau levels
IQHE is an embodiment of topological order and the states are characterized by the Chern number that tells us about topologically inequivalent Hamiltonians defined on the Brillouin zone
IQHE requires negligible electron-electron interations and so is dependent on the presence of impurities that shield from Coulomb force
F(ractional)QHE occurs because of formation of anyons. In this case Coulomb interaction can't be neglected but it turns out an effective non-interacting description emerges with particles obeying parastatistics and having fractional charge
FQHE has again something to do with topology, TQFT, Chern-Simons theory, braiding groups and lots of other stuff
FQHE has something to do with hierarchy states

So, here are the questions

Most importantly, do these points make sense? Please correct any mistakes I made and/or fill in other important observations
How do explanations 1. and 2. of IQHE come together? Landau quantization only talks about electron states while topological picture doesn't mention them at all (they should be replaced by global topological states that are stable w.r.t. perturbations)
How do explanations 4., 5. and 6. relate together
Is there any accessible introductory literature into these matters?
Do IQHE and FQHE have anything (besides last three letters) in common so that e.g. IQHE can be treated as a special case? My understanding (based on 3.) is that this is not the case but several points hint into opposite direction. That's also why I ask about both QHE in a single question

Solutions

Expert Solution

Here are some comments on the points:

1) I(nteger)QHE occurs due to the presence of Landau levels

Yes

2) IQHE is an embodiment of topological order and the states are characterized by the Chern number that tells us about topologically inequivalent Hamiltonians defined on the Brillouin zone

IQHE is an example of topological order, although topological order is introduced to mainly describe FQHE. The characterization of IQHE by Chern number of energy band only works for non-interacting fermion with no impurity, while IQHE exists even for interacting fermions. So IQHE is more than the Chern number of energy band. The quasiparticles excitations in IQH states are always fermions.

3) IQHE requires negligible electron-electron interactions and so is dependent on the presence of impurities that shield from Coulomb force.

IQHE does not require negligible electron-electron interactions. IQHE exist even in the clean system with Coulomb force, if you control the electron density by gates.

4) F(ractional)QHE occurs because of formation of anyons. In this case Coulomb interaction can't be neglected but it turns out an effective non-interacting description emerges with particles obeying parastatistics and having fractional charge

FQHE occures not because formation of anyons. Fermion alway carry Fermi statistics by definition, and they are never anyons. FQHE occures because of strong interacting effects. The effective non-interacting description does not really work (for example, it fails to describe the edge states and non-Abelian states).

5) FQHE has again something to do with topology, TQFT, Chern-Simons theory, braiding groups and lots of other stuff

FQH states contain a new kind of order: topological order. The low energy effective theories of FQH states are TQFTs (such as Chern-Simons theories). The quasiparticles excitations in FQH states are anyons.

6) Hierarchy states are examples of FQH states.


Related Solutions

How could I answer the following discussion question? Thanks! Higher education has become increasingly expensive and...
How could I answer the following discussion question? Thanks! Higher education has become increasingly expensive and hence education now costs much more than it did before. One of the ways the government controls prices is by setting a floor or a ceiling on the market. Explain what might happen in the market for higher education if the government placed a price ceiling on the cost of one undergraduate credit hour. Explain your answers using economic theory on impacts of price...
Whole Foods and Amazon Over the past decade, Whole Foods Market, Inc., has become an increasingly...
Whole Foods and Amazon Over the past decade, Whole Foods Market, Inc., has become an increasingly familiar part of the urban landscape. As of November 5, 2014, the company had 401 stores in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom. Using financial websites such as finance.yahoo.com and money.msn.com, you can access a wealth of financial information for companies such as Whole Foods. By entering the company’s ticker symbol, WFM, you will be able to access a great deal of...
In the bad old days, or even today for the few people who are doing very...
In the bad old days, or even today for the few people who are doing very precise work, users had to calibrate volumetric flasks. Write down the required steps for a 100-mL volumetric flask, considering such things as temperature, atmospheric pressure, and buoyancy corrections About how bad an error, by percent, would you make if you skipped the buoyancy correction (assume standard temperature and pressure
Look at the newspapers of Pakistan for the past few days. What new economic statistics have...
Look at the newspapers of Pakistan for the past few days. What new economic statistics have been released? How do you interpret these statistics?
CompU has become a success over the past few years, and Bill and Melinda Jobs decide...
CompU has become a success over the past few years, and Bill and Melinda Jobs decide it is time to meet with a financial planner to make certain his personal finances are in order. Bill has the following questions he needs help in answering regarding his current and future financial goals. If they deposit $1,000 today in a savings account earning 4% compounded annually, how much will they have in 10 years? If they have an opportunity cost of 10%,...
Over the past few weeks, you have become more familiar with your staff and are beginning...
Over the past few weeks, you have become more familiar with your staff and are beginning to feel like part of their family. To that end, you have recently accepted some "friend requests" on Facebook from some of the staff. You were at home last night, getting caught up on Facebook when you came across a post from one of the employees that said: " I hate my new boss at the clinic. A power hungry jerk making too many...
Reflect on your experiences over the past few days and determine at least two instances when...
Reflect on your experiences over the past few days and determine at least two instances when you observed conservation of energy and/or the first law of thermodynamics in “action.” Write in complete sentences and be specific. Include what types of energy were involved , any physical or chemical changes observed, any work done, is this an example of an endothermic or exothermic process?
When would estrogen and progesterone levels be very high in women? during pregnancy a few days...
When would estrogen and progesterone levels be very high in women? during pregnancy a few days after childbirth they will remain the same both during pregnancy and after childbirth
I've always been fascinated by logical fallacies; the text lists only a few, but there are...
I've always been fascinated by logical fallacies; the text lists only a few, but there are actually hundreds of logical fallacies that people employ every day (usually in advertisements and politics). Choose one of the five fallacies that are listed in this week's reading, and then describe a true incident in your life where you have actually encountered one of them.
Mainly confused on part C for the "interval for smaller samples" thanks! Never forget that even...
Mainly confused on part C for the "interval for smaller samples" thanks! Never forget that even small effects can be statistically significant if the samples are large. To illustrate this fact, consider a sample of 94 small businesses. During a three-year period, 10 of the 72 headed by men and 4 of the 22 headed by women failed. (a) Find the proportions of failures for businesses headed by women and businesses headed by men. These sample proportions are quite close...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT