Question

In: Physics

There is well known gravitational redshift of real photons. What about gravitational redshift of virtual photons...

There is well known gravitational redshift of real photons. What about gravitational redshift of virtual photons of charged neutron star? Is electrostatic force become weaker while mass of charged neutron star is growing?

How can electrostatic field of a charged particle swallowed by a black hole escape from the event horizon? How can charged black holes exist at all?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There is a difference between the value of a field, and the excitations of that field. If you have a speherically symmetric charge distribution collapse to a black hole (while maintaining the spherical symmetry), there is no electric nor gravitational radiation--Gauss's Law and Birkhoff's Theorem work in tandem to keep the gravitational and electric forces constant far from the object, and since there is nothing to propogate, nothing needs to propogate. The field already lives out in the place where information about where the charge distribution needs to go.

What is a photon, then? A photon is a propogating disturbance in the electromagnetic field. You need to have an accelerating charge in order to produce such a disturbance, and there's no need to violate causality at the black hole horizon in order for a particle to feel force from a field that already exists locally--if, say, an electron were coming close to a charged black hole, it would see the field that existed there, scatter off of the field, and emit a photon. (and of course, it's new field would be set up and propogate to the black hole, and scatter the black hole--but there's no problem with information falling IN to a black hole, which is allowed to externally display it's mass, charge, angular momentum and linear momentum, all of which get inprinted on the horizon as matter falls in).

So, in summary, it's not necessary for a photon to be emitted in order for a second particle to feel a force--electrostatic forces in fact don't involve photons at all (at least, until the scattering event begins).


Related Solutions

How much of a gravitational redshift should you expect for a spectral line of the Sun...
How much of a gravitational redshift should you expect for a spectral line of the Sun observed in deep space if it has a rest wavelength of 121.6nm?
What is a "virtual image"? Give a real life example.
What is a "virtual image"? Give a real life example.
In 1803, the U.S. doubled in size with the Louisiana Purchase. That well-known real estate mogul...
In 1803, the U.S. doubled in size with the Louisiana Purchase. That well-known real estate mogul Napoleon Bonaparte sold us 827,000 square miles (529,280,000 acres–there are 640 acres in a square mile). We paid $15 million. Assume that part of the US is worth an average of $6,500 per acre in 2019. What is the annual rate of return of this purchase for the U.S.?
Bluesteel is a SME that manufactures luxury goods for several well-known chain stores. In real terms,...
Bluesteel is a SME that manufactures luxury goods for several well-known chain stores. In real terms, the company has experienced only a small growth in turnover in recent years, but it has managed to maintain a constant, if low, level of reported profits by careful control of costs. It has paid a constant nominal dividend for several years and its director has publicly stated that the primary objective of the company is to increase the wealth of shareholders. The capital...
A well-known real option is the annual decision that some people make during the benefits period...
A well-known real option is the annual decision that some people make during the benefits period called open enrollment to augment their health insurance for a year. Suppose you typically don’t get dental insurance as a regular benefit but you can add it in any year for an additional cost. Using the basic tenets of options, is this dental insurance likely to be inexpensive and cover lots of procedures? Explain.
Does a flat mirror produce a real or virtual image? What is its magnification?
Does a flat mirror produce a real or virtual image? What is its magnification?
What is gravitational force ...
What is gravitational force ...
Choose a well known merger or acquisition what went well what went badly how did the...
Choose a well known merger or acquisition what went well what went badly how did the merger create erode value
How to calculate number of exchanged virtual photons per unit of time between two electromagnetically interacting...
How to calculate number of exchanged virtual photons per unit of time between two electromagnetically interacting objects?
Bob Arnold is a well-known real estate developer in Santa Fe, New Mexico. He wants to...
Bob Arnold is a well-known real estate developer in Santa Fe, New Mexico. He wants to remodel a building and convinces George Mitchell, a local businessperson, to contribute the capital to form a partnership. On January 1, 2020, Mitchell invests a building worth $162,000 and equipment valued at $32,000 as well as $25,000 in cash. Although Arnold makes no tangible contribution to the partnership, he will operate the business and be an equal partner in the beginning capital balances. Required:...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT