Question

In: Physics

If I throw a ball straight up, it deflects slightly to the west due to Coriolis...

If I throw a ball straight up, it deflects slightly to the west due to Coriolis forces. If instead I watch a bubble float up in water, is the bubble deflected west, east, or neither?

I think the bubble also moves west, but am not sure. My reasoning is that the air in the bubble must feel a Coriolis force to the west because it is rising. Further, as the bubble rises, the water around it moves, and the net motion of the water is down. Water moving down experiences a Coriolis deflection to the east. Bubbles move the opposite direction of water, so if the water is moving east, then the bubble should move west.

Edit: One reason I'm a unsure about this problem is that a bubble does not get thrown outward by a centrifugal force. Imagine a plastic ball filled with water and spinning fast. A bubble is sitting in the water in the equatorial place, half way to the edge of the ball. There's centrifugal force out towards the wall, but the bubble does not move that way. The bubble moves up the pressure gradient. The water gets thrown to the wall, and thus there is higher pressure at the wall than at the center. The bubble moves towards the center. If a bubble moves counter to the centrifugal force, I should be careful before claiming it moves with the Coriolis force.

Solutions

Expert Solution

It does.

To convince yourself, remember that rising hot air does experience a Coriolis force, so I am quite sure that your bubble does too.

Also, think of what the Coriolis acceleration is - it is an apparent acceleration due to the fact that you, the observer, are in a rotating reference frame, so your definition of "straight up" is actually a curve. When the bubble goes up you see it as having a curved trajectory - but this has to do with your rotating definition of straight up. Therefore this acceleration applies to it.

or

Here is one case in which a bubble will move against the Coriolis force, although it's not exactly the same case as addressed in the question.

This reference claims that Coriolis forces used to come into play in ship navigation by deflecting the bubble in a level, but doesn't say which way.

Consider the bubble in a level. If you are in the northern hemisphere and are moving further north, the Coriolis force is to the west. The Coriolis force acts on the air in the level's bubble, but also on the water in the level. The force is proportional to mass, so by the equivalence principle we can think of it as a small gravitational force pointing west. A bubble in water moves opposite gravity, so the bubble moves east, against the Coriolis force.

The difference between this scenario and a bubble simply floating up in water is that in the level, the bubble and water move in the same direction, but not so for a bubble floating up.


Related Solutions

You throw a ball straight up with an initial velocity of 17.0 m/s. It passes a...
You throw a ball straight up with an initial velocity of 17.0 m/s. It passes a tree branch on the way up at a height of 9.50 m. How much additional time will pass before the ball passes the tree branch on the way back down? Give your answer in seconds.
Part I A ball is thrown straight up from the top of a building that is...
Part I A ball is thrown straight up from the top of a building that is 185ft high with an initial velocity of 64ft/s. The height of the object can be modeled by the equation s(t) = -16t 2 + 64t + 185. In two or more complete sentences explain how to determine the time(s) the ball is higher than the building in interval notation. Part II In two or more complete sentences, describe the transformation(s) that take place on...
To find the height of an overhead power line, you throw a ball straight upward. The...
To find the height of an overhead power line, you throw a ball straight upward. The ball passes the line on the way up after 0.85 s , and passes it again on the way down 1.5 s after it was tossed. a) What is the height of the power line? b) What is the initial speed of the ball?
A ball is thrown straight up with an initial speed of 19 m/s. The ball was...
A ball is thrown straight up with an initial speed of 19 m/s. The ball was released 6.3 m above the ground, but when it returns back down, it falls into a hole d m deep. If the ball’s speed is 35.7 m/s at the bottom of the hole, how deep is the hole (in m)?
Consider a ball being fired straight up (purely in the y-direction). If the ball has a...
Consider a ball being fired straight up (purely in the y-direction). If the ball has a maximum height of H above the launcher, you should be able to calculate the initial velocity of the ball, v0 , as it leaves the launcher. Answering the questions below will help you accomplish this task. First draw a diagram of the situation. Clearly label H , v0 , and the point you select as your origin. What will the velocity of the ball...
A ball is thrown straight up from the edge of the roof of a building. A...
A ball is thrown straight up from the edge of the roof of a building. A second ball is dropped from the roof a time of 1.20 s later. You may ignore air resistance. A) If the height of the building is 20.7 m , what must the initial speed be of the first ball if both are to hit the ground at the same time? B) Consider the same situation, but now let the initial speed v0 of the...
1. When you throw a pebble straight up with initial speed V, it reaches a maximum...
1. When you throw a pebble straight up with initial speed V, it reaches a maximum height H with no air resistance. At what speed should you throw it up vertically so it will go twice as high? a. Insufficient information b. 18 V c. V sqrt(2) d. 4 V e. 8 V 2. A 60.0-kg man stands at one end of a 20.0-kg uniform 10.0-m long board. How far from the man is the center of mass (or center...
5. You throw a ball into the air. It takes 6.0 ? for the ball to...
5. You throw a ball into the air. It takes 6.0 ? for the ball to reach your hand. a. Determine the initial speed at which the ball was thrown. b. Determine the final velocity of the ball when it hits your hand.
A ball of mass m is shot straight up into the air by a spring-loaded launcher....
A ball of mass m is shot straight up into the air by a spring-loaded launcher. Initially, the spring is compressed by a distance D. After the spring is released, the ball has a velocity v out of the launcher and finally reaches a maximum height H. Ignoring air resistance, which of the following statements are true? True False  If the spring constant is doubled, the ball will max out at height 8H True False  The initial potential energy of the spring...
a baseball player bats a ball straight up with an initial speed of 109 miles. it...
a baseball player bats a ball straight up with an initial speed of 109 miles. it reaches a height of s = 0.03t-0.003t ^ 2 miles after t seconds. What is the speed of the ball when it is .0830 miles from the ground?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT