What is the need for hospital and physician professional liability coverage (malpractice insurance) in American health...

What is the need for hospital and physician professional liability coverage (malpractice insurance) in American health care today. Why is malpractice coverage so extremely expensive today? Do you think the need for liability insurance adds to or detracts from the patient care that is provided?

Expert Solution

There have been several crises in the medical malpractice insurance market over recent decades. These have translated to dramatic increases in malpractice premiums, anywhere from 30% to 300%, which patients typically make up for through increased hospitalization fees (Feldstein, 2015). Why have there been such extreme jumps in premiums? Is this due to more medical negligence? More lawsuits? Or is it something else?

With nearly 37 million hospitalizations in the US every year, there are about 1 million malpractice incidents. Of those 1 million incidents, less than 2% of patients file a claim for malpractice, and less than half of that 2% receives compensation. One explanation for this very low rate is that patients lack the medical knowledge to recognize when malpractice has occurred. Another is that they lack any incentive to file actual lawsuits, due to high lawyer fees and slow court procedures (Feldstein, 2015). Because such a small proportion of patients receive malpractice payouts each year, it seems that claims payments alone do not explain recent crises in the medical malpractice insurance market.

These crises are, in fact, mostly attributable to the structure of that market, combined with changes in general financial conditions. Since there are so few medical malpractice payouts each year, insurers tend to invest a considerable portion of premiums into the bond and stock market. When the return on these investments increases, more firms join the market, and the increased competition drives down premiums. However, economic recessions can cause sharp declines in investment returns, causing some insurers to leave the market and the remaining firms to increase their premiums. The result of this fluctuation is a malpractice insurance crisis.

There are two proposed solutions to this: set damage caps on the amount of malpractice payouts, and regulate the amount diverted to attorneys (Thorpe, 2004). Unfortunately, these strategies focus too much on deterring patients from filing lawsuits, and they neglect the problem post by insurers’ risky investments. Other proposals, such as no-fault malpractice systems, take aim at the insurance market itself (Mello and Kachalia, 2010). For instance, by foregoing lengthy lawsuits and allowing patients to be compensated at the time of their injury, the demand for malpractice insurance will decrease. Fewer firms will have an incentive to join the market, and the market can stabilize.

There are no perfect solutions yet, and no consensus on what approach to take. But perhaps the next malpractice insurance crisis – which may be inevitable given the current market structure – will lead to more conclusive policy decisions.

jeff jeffy answered 2 years ago

Liability policies, such as personal liability, professional malpractice, or business liability insurance, do NOT protect the...

Liability policies, such as personal liability, professional malpractice, or business liability insurance, do NOT protect the insured against a. a personal injury on the insured's property, such as the mail carrier who slips and falls on the owner's sidewalk. b. someone injured by the insured away from home or business. c. claims for property damaged by the insured. d. intentional harm caused by the insured.

If a physician is fully insured by malpractice insurance against payment to a victim of malpractice,...

If a physician is fully insured by malpractice insurance against payment to a victim of malpractice, is there any consequence to the physician for delivering care that was below the prevailing standard of care? Discuss this in the context of accountability.

talk about a pharmacist professional liability and malpractice issues?, provide examples

3. Suppose a disgruntled patient sues her physician for negligence. The physician has malpractice insurance. How...

3. Suppose a disgruntled patient sues her physician for negligence. The physician has malpractice insurance. How would insurers incentivize physicians to use reasonable care in surgery? What are provisions of malpractice insurance. 4. Group practices are simply cartels. a. True b. False

Using the Stark Insurance Group data on closed claims for medical malpractice liability insurance (presented in...

Using the Stark Insurance Group data on closed claims for medical malpractice liability insurance (presented in the previous tables), determine if medical malpractice was more risky during the 2010-2013 period than it was in the 2014-2017 period. Injury year Estimated # of claims Estimated $ per claim 2010 1021 $415,326.26 2011 1087 $448,871.57 2012 1184 $477,333.66 2013 1291 $490,215.19 2014 1191 $516,696.63 2015 1098 $587,233.93 2016 1055 $536,983.82 2017 1110 $403,504.39 Calculate the standard deviation in the estimated payment per...

From the same Texas Department of Insurance data on closed claims for medical malpractice liability insurance...

From the same Texas Department of Insurance data on closed claims for medical malpractice liability insurance referred to in Problem 1, we can estimate the number of claims in each year of injury that will be closed in the next 16 years. We obtain the following data. Here the estimated dollars per claim for each year have been adjusted to 2007 dollars to account for inflation, so the values are all compatible. Texas was said to have had a “medical...

What is the liability of MCO when it makes decisions about insurance coverage for hospitals stays?

iscussion Question 1: Types of Health Insurance Health insurance is a type of insurance coverage that...

iscussion Question 1: Types of Health Insurance Health insurance is a type of insurance coverage that covers the cost of an insured individual's medical and surgical expenses. Depending on the type of health insurance coverage, either the insured pays costs out-of-pocket and is then reimbursed, or the insurer makes payments directly to the provider. Research and describe the four major types of health insurance both the most preferred and least preferred, then identify which population groups are commonly covered by...

Insurance (explain the different types of insurance coverage you need including health, life, auto, homeowners, etc....

Insurance (explain the different types of insurance coverage you need including health, life, auto, homeowners, etc. With each type of insurance coverage explain how to select the appropriate amount of insurance and the benefits/costs of such coverage) (for the last part of explaining how to select the appropriate amount of insurance and the benefits/costs of such coverage, please explain about Health insurance only )

The Kelleher family has health insurance coverage that pays 75 percent of out-of-hospital expenses after a...

The Kelleher family has health insurance coverage that pays 75 percent of out-of-hospital expenses after a $500 deductible per person. If one family member has doctor and prescription medication expenses of $1,420, what amount would the insurance company pay? (Do not round intermediate calculations.) Insurance payment:

Question