Question

In: Finance

Ellay steel corp. is evaluating two different steel bending machines using its WACC of 7.5%. Machine...

Ellay steel corp. is evaluating two different steel bending machines using its WACC of 7.5%. Machine A costs $320,000, has a three-year life, and has pre-tax operating costs of $83,000 per year. Machine B costs $495,000, has a five-year life, and has pre-tax operating costs of $42,000 per year. Both bending machines are in Class 8 (CCA rate of 20% per year). Recall that Ellay’s tax rate is 35%.

Assume that there is no salvage value for both machines and compute the EAC for each one.
Which one would be chosen by Ellay corp? Why?

Expert Solution

Ellay steel corp. is evaluating two different steel bending machines using its WACC of 7.5%. Machine A costs $320,000, has a three-year life, and has pre-tax operating costs of $83,000 per year. Machine B costs $495,000, has a five-year life, and has pre-tax operating costs of $42,000 per year. Both bending machines are in Class 8 (CCA rate of 20% per year). Recall that Ellay’s tax rate is 35%.

00001. Assume that there is no salvage value for both machines and compute the EAC for each one.

00002. Which one would be chosen by Ellay corp? Why?

EAC = Present value of cash flow / PV of annuity $1 factor discounted

So first calculate Present value of cash flow

Machine A costs $320,000,

Dep = 320000 / 3 = 106666.67

Tax shield = 106666.67 * 20% = 21333

year	Operating cost	Tax benefits	Add back depreciation tax shield	Net CF (outflow)	PV of cash flow @ 7.5%
1	83000	29050	21333	75283	75283*0.9302 =70030.69
2	83000	29050	21333	75283	75283*0.8653 =65145
3	83000	29050	21333	75283	75283*0.805 =60599.85

Total PV of cash flow = 70030.69 + 65145 + 60599.85 =195775.37 + 320000 = 515775.7

PV of annuity due $1 @ 7.5% for 3 period = (1/1+7.5%)3GT =2.6005

EAC = 515775.7 / 2.6005 = 198337

Machine B costs $495,000

Dep = 495000 / 5 = 99000

Tax shield = 99000 * 20% = 19800

Annual cash flow =

Pre tax cost = 42000

Tax benefit = 14700

Dep tax shield = 19800

Net cash flow = - 7500

PV of cash flow = 7500 * ( 1 / 1 + 7.5%)5GT

PV of cash flow = 7500 * 4.046 = 30344

EAC = 30344 + 495000 / 4.046 = 525344 / 4.046

EAC = 129843

Machine B are used for the project, because it has the lowest EAC

jeff jeffy answered 3 years ago

You are evaluating two different milling machines to replace your current aging machine. Machine A costs...

You are evaluating two different milling machines to replace your current aging machine. Machine A costs $266,735, has a three-year life, and has pretax operating costs of $64,279 per year. Machine B costs $395,418, has a five-year life, and has pretax operating costs of $32,757 per year. For both milling machines, use straight-line depreciation to zero over the project’s life and assume a salvage value of $40,798. Your tax rate is 34 % and your discount rate is 10 %....

You are evaluating two different machines. Machine A costs $210,000, has a three-year life and has...

You are evaluating two different machines. Machine A costs $210,000, has a three-year life and has pretax operating costs of $30,000 per year. Machine B costs $320,000, has a five-year life and has pretax operating costs of $23,000 per year. You will depreciate both machines using straight-line depreciation to a zero salvage value over the machine’s life. The expected salvage value for each machine is $20,000. If your tax rate is 40%, both machines are repeatable and your discount rate...

The John Deer Company is evaluating the replacement of one of its machines. The machine was...

The John Deer Company is evaluating the replacement of one of its machines. The machine was originally purchased ten years ago at a cost of $35,000 and has been depreciated to a book value of zero. If Pioneer replaces the machine, it will be able to bid on larger projects that require the capabilities of the new machine. The new machine will cost the firm $80,000, which will be depreciated over 4 years according to the following depreciation rates: 40%...

The Computer company is evaluating the replacement of one of its machines. The machine was originally...

The Computer company is evaluating the replacement of one of its machines. The machine was originally purchased ten years ago at a cost of $35,000 and has been depreciated to a book value of zero. If Pioneer replaces the machine, it will be able to bid on larger projects that require the capabilities of the new machine. The new machine will cost the firm $80,000, which will be depreciated over 4 years according to the following depreciation rates: 40% in...

You are evaluating two different silicon wafer milling machines. Machine I costs $120,000, has a 3-year...

You are evaluating two different silicon wafer milling machines. Machine I costs $120,000, has a 3-year life, and has pretax operating costs of $43,000 per year. Machine II costs $160,000, has a 5-year life, and has pretax operating costs of $20,000 per year. For both machines, use straight-line depreciation to zero over the project's life and assume a salvage value of $20,000. If your tax rate is 34 percent and your discount rate is 12 percent, which one do you...

UMB Co. is evaluating two machines. Both machines meet the firm’s quality standard. Machine X costs...

UMB Co. is evaluating two machines. Both machines meet the firm’s quality standard. Machine X costs $40 000 initially and $1000 per year to maintain. Machine Y costs $24 000 initially and $2000 per year to maintain. Machine X has a six-year useful life and Machine Y has a three-year useful life. Both machines have zero salvage value. Assume the firm will continue to replace worn-out machines with similar machines and that the discount rate is 25%. Which machine should...

The diameter of steel rods manufactured on two different extrusion machines is being investigated. Two random...

The diameter of steel rods manufactured on two different extrusion machines is being investigated. Two random samples of sizes ?1 = 20 and ?2 = 24 are selected, and the sample means and sample variances are ?̅̅1̅ = 9.22, ?1 = 0.55, ?̅̅2̅ = 9.43, and ?2 = 0.62, respectively. Assume that ?1 2 ≠ ?2 2 and that the data are drawn from a normal distribution. Is there evidence to support the claim that machine 1 produces rods with...

1. You are evaluating the purchase of either of two machines used in your brewery. Machine...

1. You are evaluating the purchase of either of two machines used in your brewery. Machine A will last two years, costs $8,000 initially, and then $1,250 per year in maintenance costs. Machine B costs $9,500 initially, has a life of three years, and requires $1,000 in annual maintenance costs. Either machine must be replaced at the end of its life with an equivalent machine. Your interest rate on current debt and the initial purchases is 9 percent and the...

Two different machines, A and B, used for torsion tests of steel wire were tested on...

Two different machines, A and B, used for torsion tests of steel wire were tested on 12 pairs of different types of wire, with one member of each pair tested on each machine. The results (break angle measurements) were as follows: Machine A: 32, 35, 38, 28, 40, 42, 36, 29, 33, 37, 22, 42 Machine B: 30, 34, 39, 26, 37, 42, 35, 30, 30, 32, 20, 41 [a] Construct a side-by-side boxplot to display the two data sets...

You are evaluating two machines. Machine I costs $240,000 and it has a three-year life. It...

You are evaluating two machines. Machine I costs $240,000 and it has a three-year life. It has pre-tax operating costs of $60,000 per year. Machine II costs $450,000 and it has a five-year life. It has pre-tax operating costs of $40,000 per year. For both machines, we use straight-line depreciation to zero over the machine’s life. The pre-tax salvage value of Machine I is $50,000 at the end of its life. The pre-tax salvage value of Machine II is $150,000...