Question

In: Physics

It is well known that the Lagrangian of a classical free particle equal to kinetic energy....

It is well known that the Lagrangian of a classical free particle equal to kinetic energy. This statement can be derived from some basic assumptions about the symmetries of the space-time. Is there any similar reasoning (eg. symmetry based or geometrical) why the Lagrangian of a classical system is equal kinetic energy minus the potential energy? Or it is just because we can compare the Newton's equations with the Euler-Lagrange equation and realize how they can match?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Well, Lagrangian is what one usually starts with, even in the modern physics, and everything else is derived. So I don't believe you can explain it any better than it is the way it is because it matches observation.

But there are two points about the above worth taking.

First symmetries can give you a nudge into the right direction of constructing Lagrangian. E.g. in classical mechanics in free space you want to have laws that are translation and rotation invariant, etc., so that excludes lots of strange Lagrangians first-hand. Nevertheless, you could also ask what is the symmetry derived from and for that there is no good answer. At some point you have to stop with the chain of deductions and realize that physics can't really be derived mathematically but has to be observed. It's actually fascinating that the world can be reduced into few simple laws that appear to be purely mathematical.

Second, there can sometimes be a microscopic model of the given system which kind of "explains" why the macroscopic description takes the given form in a limit. One can e.g. derive the principle of least action from quantum mechanics. So you can explain some things. But I don't believe you can really explain Lagrangian.


Related Solutions

The kinetic energy of a particle is equal to the energy of a photon. The particle...
The kinetic energy of a particle is equal to the energy of a photon. The particle moves at 6.1% of the speed of light. Find the ratio of the photon wavelength to the de Broglie wavelength of the particle. Take the speed to be non-relativistic.
1) An electron has a kinetic energy that is 50% larger than its classical kinetic energy....
1) An electron has a kinetic energy that is 50% larger than its classical kinetic energy. Electron mass is 0.511 MeV/c^2. a. What is the speed of the electron expressed in the unit of speed of light c? b. What is the total energy of the electron expressed in the unit of MeV? c. What is the kinetic energy of the electron expressed in the unit of MeV?
What is the expectation value of kinetic energy for a particle in a box of length...
What is the expectation value of kinetic energy for a particle in a box of length ( L/2 ) in the ground eigenstate (n=1)? What about for the third excited eignestate (n=3). Explain the difference.
Compare and contrast the relativistic and classical expressions for the kinetic energy of an object. How...
Compare and contrast the relativistic and classical expressions for the kinetic energy of an object. How does the relativistic expression explain the impossibility of an object to reach the speed of light?
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 15.0MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it is...
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 15.0MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it is not "aimed" at the center of the lead nucleus, and has an initial nonzero angular momentum (with respect to the stationary lead nucleus) of magnitude L=p0b, where p0 is the magnitude of the initial momentum of the alpha particle and b=1.30
1. In a simple harmonic motion, the kinetic energy is equal to the elastic potential energy...
1. In a simple harmonic motion, the kinetic energy is equal to the elastic potential energy in the position: a) X = A / 2 b) X = A c) X = A / (2) 1/2 d) X = (2 ) 1/2 A e) X = 0 1.2 The displacement of a particle in a simple harmonic motion is given by: X = 10 cos (20t - π / 3), which of the following. expressions is equivalent: a) X =...
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 13.0 MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it...
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 13.0 MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it is not "aimed" at the center of the lead nucleus, and has an initial nonzero angular momentum (with respect to the stationary lead nucleus) of magnitude L=p0b, where p0 is the magnitude of the initial momentum of the alpha particle and b=1.20×10?12 m . (Assume that the lead nucleus remains stationary and that it may be treated as a point charge. The atomic number...
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 10.5 MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it...
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 10.5 MeV makes a collision with lead nucleus, but it is not "aimed" at the center of the lead nucleus, and has an initial nonzero angular momentum (with respect to the stationary lead nucleus) of magnitude L=p0b, where p0 is the magnitude of the initial momentum of the alpha particle and b=1.20×10−12 m . (Assume that the lead nucleus remains stationary and that it may be treated as a point charge. The atomic number...
8. Refer to the previous problem. The parent particle moves in the lab with kinetic energy...
8. Refer to the previous problem. The parent particle moves in the lab with kinetic energy 800 MeV, and one daughter particle is emitted along the parent’s direction of motion. Find the lab kinetic energy (in MeV) for the daughter emitted backwards in the parent’s rest frame. Previous Problem: 7. A particle of rest energy 800 MeV decays in its rest frame into two identical particles of rest energy 250 MeV. What are the kinetic energies (in MeV), momenta (in...
Use the quantum particle wavefunctions for the kinetic energy levels in a one dimensional box to...
Use the quantum particle wavefunctions for the kinetic energy levels in a one dimensional box to qualitatively demonstrate that the classical probability distribution (any value of x is equally allowed) is obtained for particles at high temperatures.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT