Question

In: Physics

In a lot of laymen explanations of general relativity it is implied that the four dimensions...

In a lot of laymen explanations of general relativity it is implied that the four dimensions of the space-time are equivalent, and we perceive time as different only because it is embedded in our human perception to do so.

My question is: is that really how general relativity treats the 4 dimensions?

If so - what are the implications (if any) this has on causality?

If no - can the theory support more than one time dimension?

Solutions

Expert Solution

That statement, that space and time are equivalent, is not really correct. In special relativity there is a distinction between spacelike and timelike events, those are events that cannot or can (respectively) be causally connected. This replaces the notion of "simultaneous" and "before or after" to something all inertial observers can agree on. In general relativity, this distinction is made locally - causal influence propagates locally in speeds less than c, but that constraints changes from point to point according to the local metric (which encodes the force of gravity).

All of this is encoded in the statement that the metric is indefinite, with a specific signature that supports one time direction. While the mathematics of GR can be generalized to other signatures, the physics cannot - the Lorentzian signature is essential in correctly interpreting the theory. Anyone can play all kinds of mathematical games, but those are meaningless unless you are very clear on how the calculations you perform are related (at least in principle) to physically observable quantities.


Related Solutions

Explain General Relativity. Give examples.
Explain General Relativity. Give examples.
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory...
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory of general relativity includes gravity. b) The theory of general relativity describes the behavior of subatomic particles. c) The theory of special relativity applies only to very massive objects. d) Only the theory of special relativity includes gravity.
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory...
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory of general relativity includes gravity. b) The theory of general relativity describes the behavior of subatomic particles. c) The theory of special relativity applies only to very massive objects. d) Only the theory of special relativity includes gravity.
a) Explain Einstein’s theories of special relativity and general relativity. b) Include at least one piece...
a) Explain Einstein’s theories of special relativity and general relativity. b) Include at least one piece of evidence in support of each theory.
Show that the affine connection is not a true tensor (general relativity/cosmology)
Show that the affine connection is not a true tensor (general relativity/cosmology)
Article Why Are the Poor Poor? Explanations of poverty, like explanations of inequality in general, differ...
Article Why Are the Poor Poor? Explanations of poverty, like explanations of inequality in general, differ in several ways. They may focus on individuals or on social structures. They may interpret poverty as inevitable—perhaps even necessary—or as the product of the efforts of the powerful and wealthy to protect their own inter- ests. Let’s look at some of these explanations, keeping in mind that despite their differences, each may contain elements of validity and therefore may offer at least a...
Can general relativity be completely described as a field in a flat space? Can it be...
Can general relativity be completely described as a field in a flat space? Can it be done already now or requires advances in quantum gravity?
Question 9 One of the key early tests of Einstein's General Theory of Relativity was the...
Question 9 One of the key early tests of Einstein's General Theory of Relativity was the bending of the path of starlight and resulting apparent shift in the position of stars because of the Sun's mass. sending a twin in a spaceship to the nearest star and back at a high Lorentz factor. the Michelson-Morley experiment. measuring the time dilation effect from gas falling into a black hole. Question 10 According to General Relativity, Group of answer choices you can...
Einstein's general theory of relativity is conceptually quit different from Newtown's theory of gravity ...this is...
Einstein's general theory of relativity is conceptually quit different from Newtown's theory of gravity ...this is problem 2-4 of Fundmental Planetary Science
Einstein's Theory of General Relativity can be considered a "good theory." a) What did this theory...
Einstein's Theory of General Relativity can be considered a "good theory." a) What did this theory explain that other theories could also explain? b) What did this theory explain that other theories could not explain? c) What did this theory predict that nobody had expected, but which were found experimentally?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT