Question

In: Physics

I would like to expand on what I mean by the title of this question to...

I would like to expand on what I mean by the title of this question to focus the answers.

Normally whenever a theory (e.g. General Relativity) replaces another (e.g. Newtonian Gravity) there is a correspondence requirement in some limit. However there is also normally some experimental area where the new larger theory makes predictions which are different from the older theory which made predictions of the same phenomena. This is ultimately because the newer theory has a deeper view of physics with its own structures which come into play in certain situations that the old theory didn't cover well. Additionally the newer theory will make predictions based on its novel aspects which the older theory did not consider. I know that String Theory is quite rich in this regard, but am not interested in that here. Nor am I concerned as to whether experiment has caught up, as I know that ST (and Quantum Gravity in general) is not easy to test.

So for the GR to Newtonian example an answer to this question would be: bending of light rays; Mercury perihelion movement - GR had a different results to Newton. What would not count as an answer would be new structures which GR introduces like Black Holes or even gravitational curvature per se.

So does ST have anything like Mercury perihelion movement waiting to be experimentally verified, and thus "improving" on GR within GR's own back yard?

Solutions

Expert Solution

String theory implies new physics in - and only in - the quantum regime. In particular, at distances that are very short - comparable to the string scale or Planck scale - there are new effects. The black holes decay (while they preserve the information), effective actions have higher-derivative terms, e.g. R2, there are strings, branes, fluxes, extra dimensions, and so on.

The new physics at the Planck scale - which is very far - is almost certainly not testable by the naive 19th century observations such as the Mercury perihelion's precession. This is not a problem of string theory in any sense: it is a tautological consequence of the questions that string theory addresses - namely the behavior of the Universe at the most fundamental scale - and any other theory that addresses the same questions inevitably shares the inaccessibility of the phenomena by direct tests.

When you only look at the classical limit or classical physics, string theory exactly agrees with general relativity. In some sense, this is true even in the quantum regime: string theory is the only consistent quantum completion of general relativity.


Related Solutions

given the following questions, i would like to ... Question Given the following questions, I would...
given the following questions, i would like to ... Question Given the following questions, I would like to know the answers to c, d, and e. located at the bottom (due to 4 answers per post limit). Thanks! Platinum (Pt) is used in part of your car's catalytic converter to reduce carbon monoxide emissions by the following chemical reaction: 2CO(g) + O2(g) Pt 2CO2(g) ---> 1) A matrix contains 7.1mg Pt/g of matrix. What is the %Pt in the matrix...
You would like to expand overseas into a country like India. What issues do you have...
You would like to expand overseas into a country like India. What issues do you have to be concerned about in marketing your product in a foreign county?   What avenues or services are available to you if you wanted to market your product overseas? Describe each of the ways.
I would like to solve the question that is: There are 190 letters and place to...
I would like to solve the question that is: There are 190 letters and place to 10 envelopes (one letter per envelope). What is the prob that exactly 3 envelopes will contain which they should contain? Could you explain why you used the formula as well? Thanks
I have a question that I would like an explanation on how an ethical hacker uses...
I have a question that I would like an explanation on how an ethical hacker uses the information derived by use of Nslookup and Whois to mitigate network connectivity issues. If you could explain in a paragraph it would help me tremendously.
I would like to get the step by step solution for the below question Question 11...
I would like to get the step by step solution for the below question Question 11 pts What is the difference between positive economics and normative economics? Group of answer choices Positive economics deals with dynamic systems, while normative economics focuses on static systems. Normative economics deals with how the world actually works, whereas positive economics focuses on what people ought to do. Positive economics requires making value judgments, while normative economics relies solely on factual statements. Normative economics applies...
What is a virtual ground? I would like to know what it is
What is a virtual ground? I would like to know what it is
I would like to get som survey question for dry cleaning service , I want to...
I would like to get som survey question for dry cleaning service , I want to attract new people who live in the area like new homewoners.
Answer the following question and I would like you to provide me with references that is...
Answer the following question and I would like you to provide me with references that is not older than 5 years old please for each please Question 1 A pediatric patient has just been diagnosed with otitis externa. Which of the following should the patient be instructed to do? Use alcohol drops before swimming Wear earplugs at all times with swimming Limit swimming for the remainder of summer Keep ear dry until symptoms improve Question 2 The nurse practitioner is...
There is an IT software company (Facility relevant ) which would like to expand they already...
There is an IT software company (Facility relevant ) which would like to expand they already in the maturity stage and they don’t want to sale Sensitive directive to the cost which means they don’t want to pay high-interest rate if they manage to find an investor, what’s the best 5 financing options and discuses about them advantages and disadvantage they can borrowing and liquidity or crowdsourcing and lease and venture capital for the company and choose the best financing...
I would like a paragraph on what exactly is WordPress? What is it used for? What...
I would like a paragraph on what exactly is WordPress? What is it used for? What are some of its functions? How does work in software engineering? I would like a detailed paragraph based on this.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT