Question

In: Physics

I was reading the Feynman lectures in physics and after thinking about it for a while...

I was reading the Feynman lectures in physics and after thinking about it for a while it seems particularly unreasonable to talk about hidden variables. Let us say that the electron has some internal variables as yet unknown which determine its trajectory given a set of initial conditions just like in classical mechanics. But since these hidden variables are unobserved, coupling it with a classical system should make their effect unchanged. This is what Feynman says, I think, in the last paragraph of Ch1 Vol 3, that if in the double slit experiment, if these inner variables dictate that the electron goes through the upper slit and land at a particular place on the opposite screen, and some other place for the lower screen, then the probability must neccesarily be the sum of two Gaussian like peaks, which does not agree with experiment.

So if I concluded that inner workings of an electron had some additional hidden variables, then it should yield, as they should be independent of the classical apparatus, mutually exclusive probabilities that do not quiet add up the way as observed. But then I do a hidden variables search on the archive and a lot of smart guys still write about it, as late as Feb 2011.

So the argument I have used might be somehow incomplete, can anyone explain how?

EDIT: Sorry for editing this question almost three years later. I tried to locate the exact reference from the Feynman lectures I was referring to and this is the updated source, Sec 7 Ch 1 Vol 3

We make now a few remarks on a suggestion that has sometimes been made to try to avoid the description we have given:

Solutions

Expert Solution

I am afraid that this question of yours, while excellent, could belong to a psychology forum.

Feynman's perspective was already totally sensible; however, since his death, an amazing sequence of ever more straightforward proofs that hidden variables can't exist has been found.

Let me mention the GHZM state, Hardy's "paradox",

Weak measurement and Hardy's paradox.

and various experimentally realized thought experiments disproving various theories of "nonlocal realism" as well, see e.g.

http://arxiv.org/abs/0704.2529

The idea that the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics is due to the hidden variables was indefensible when Feynman was writing his lectures in the 1960s, and maybe even in the late 1920s when quantum mechanics became settled. But it is much more indefensible today.

I am not sure whether I fully understand your proof but it is possible to describe the experimentally validated proof in similarly simple terms. Quantum mechanics remains unacceptable for many people, for quasi-religious reasons. But as Sidney Coleman said at the end of his excellent lecture,

http://motls.blogspot.com/2010/11/sidney-coleman-quantum-mechanics-in.html
Quantum mechanics in your face

in which he described the conceptual issues of QM very clearly, it's time for those people to seriously consider the hypothesis that quantum mechanics is really how the world works. Well, the lecture is 17 years old by now, too, indicating that the opposition to quantum mechanics will never disappear


Related Solutions

After reading the texts and mini-lectures in this module write a paper that completes the tasks...
After reading the texts and mini-lectures in this module write a paper that completes the tasks below. Read the following excerpts as if these characters were clients that you work with. Write an example of the skills as if you were therapist/counselor. You may copy the excerpts and format (below) and paste into your own Word document to complete and submit. EXCERPT 1 I have no place to turn. I am always alone ..I mean I have a lot of...
Hello to anyone reading this! I will start taking physics 6 (general physics at my college)...
Hello to anyone reading this! I will start taking physics 6 (general physics at my college) my upcoming semester and I would like to start studying a bit on the subject before summer is over. Does anyone have any tips, or would like to share their experience in this class that I should know about to better prepare? Im a lil worried on this class since I'm not entirely great at math even though I just passed Trig with an...
Fair-Minded Qualities After reading this week’s lectures on the qualities of a Fair-Minded Thinker, select one...
Fair-Minded Qualities After reading this week’s lectures on the qualities of a Fair-Minded Thinker, select one quality you feel you possess and describe how you embody this quality. Next, select two qualities you feel you need to improve upon. Using the five step decision making process outlined below, create a plan of action to improve in those areas. Please be sure to outline the specific steps you’ll take to overcome any obstacles you face. Your completed assignment should be written...
To prepare for this discussion review the chapter reading assignments. While doing the reading think about...
To prepare for this discussion review the chapter reading assignments. While doing the reading think about your responses to the identified questions, AND respond to your colleagues’ postings in one or more of the following ways: Ask a probing question. Share an insight from having read your colleague’s posting. Offer and support an opinion. Validate an idea with your own experience. Make a suggestion. Expand on your colleague’s posting. Tammy Potter, a new partner with the regional CPA firm of...
Based on the reading in Chapter 12 and thinking about how the media and the vitamin...
Based on the reading in Chapter 12 and thinking about how the media and the vitamin sales industry pushed the health benefits of vitamins; compare and contrast two positive benefits and two negative (adverse effects ) vitamins can have on the body and total health.
After reading about Middle Adulthood I truly believe that midlife crisis can exist in middle aged...
After reading about Middle Adulthood I truly believe that midlife crisis can exist in middle aged adults. Midlife crisis may begin to occur when major changes happen during this period of time. What I mean by this is major physical changes in both men and women that show their aging more and more. Or a divorce happens where our textbook uses the example of, “A 40-year old man who divorces his wife, trades in his Ford Taurus station wagon for...
For physics discussion post. Please TYPE the response as I struggle with reading written information. Explain...
For physics discussion post. Please TYPE the response as I struggle with reading written information. Explain Boyle's law, Charles law, and the Ideal Gas equation. Explain Kinetic Molecular Theory of Ideal Gas. In your own words, explain the First Law of Thermodynamics and give examples. In your own words, explain adiabatic process and isothermal process, and give examples.
Here is a typical question which I have been asked many times while giving public lectures...
Here is a typical question which I have been asked many times while giving public lectures in various places. While I know one of the paths like Diploma, Masters and PhD but sometimes this is not so obvious for that eager young person who thinks to go on that path. So what that would be?
After reading about the three main financial statements in your textbook, consider how reading these statements...
After reading about the three main financial statements in your textbook, consider how reading these statements could help you in your job. No matter what your position in the company is, you should be able to find some relevance between the information you can glean from the statements and information that would be useful to you in your work. Give at least three examples and explain how you can use the information to improve your effectiveness and/or efficiency in your...
A role is a set of social expectations. After reading about the different responsibilities of a...
A role is a set of social expectations. After reading about the different responsibilities of a nonprofit manager, consider what might happen if a manager mixes roles and finds herself or himself torn in several directions by conflicting expectations? For your initial post, write a short story that describes a realistic example of a role conflict that a nonprofit manager might encounter. Comment on two of your peers’ posts, offering a solution to the conflict, and comment on others' solutions,...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT