Question

In: Physics

How conservation laws are tested experimentally independently from each other? what do I mean by that...

How conservation laws are tested experimentally independently from each other? what do I mean by that question?

It seems that to test one conservation law experimentally, such as conservation of energy, we will have to assume other conservation laws are correct such as conservation of charge and conservation of momentum and angular momentum...etc.

But to really test any conservation law one has to check if one of them is valid independent from any other one. Is this possible experimentally? if not then how scientists check conservation laws?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Suppose I collide two billiard balls then I can measure the velocities before and after and check that momentum is conserved. I don't need to assume that energy is conserved. I just measure the velocities before and after.

Alternatively I can use the same system to check for conservation of energy, but again I don't have to assume conservation of momentum.

It would be possible for this experiment to conserve momentum but not energy. For example suppose I'm working in the centre of mass frame, so the net momentum is zero, and the two billard balls collide and stop dead. That would conserve momentum but not energy. Likewise suppose the billiard balls meet but then both move off together at a right angle. That would conserve energy but not momentum.

So it's hard to think of an experiment that doesn't simultaneously test more than one conservation law, but you don't need to assume other conservation laws hold when testing your selected conservation law.


Related Solutions

What are the different types of diabetes and how do they differ from each other?
What are the different types of diabetes and how do they differ from each other?
In what ways do the two sources of debt financing differ from each other? How do...
In what ways do the two sources of debt financing differ from each other? How do they differ from the two sources of equity financing? How would you choose between the two (debt financing and equity financing) as a financial manager?
2) (i)What does KM mean experimentally in terms of what you add in an Eppendorf tube?...
2) (i)What does KM mean experimentally in terms of what you add in an Eppendorf tube? (ii) How does it differ from KD?
Describe how the concepts of leadership and management differ from each other. In what areas do...
Describe how the concepts of leadership and management differ from each other. In what areas do they overlap? Explain how the goals of management and leadership may sometimes overlap. As a nurse leader, do you believe you can expand your influence to create change by taking advantage of this overlap? Explain your answer.
Describe how the concepts of leadership and management differ from each other. In what areas do...
Describe how the concepts of leadership and management differ from each other. In what areas do they overlap? Explain how the goals of management and leadership may sometimes overlap. As a nurse leader, do you believe you can expand your influence to create change by taking advantage of this overlap? Explain your answer.
What are the two conservation laws relevant to particle interactions in the standard model?
What are the two conservation laws relevant to particle interactions in the standard model?
What is Libor and what are Eurodollars? How do they relate to each other and what...
What is Libor and what are Eurodollars? How do they relate to each other and what role do they play in the global markets for liquidity?
How do the spectra of the metal salts differ from each other and from the spectrum...
How do the spectra of the metal salts differ from each other and from the spectrum of the hydrogen atom?  Be specific, referring to observations made on your spectra. Include the shapes and numbers of the lines you observe.    Why do the spectra of the metal salts differ from the spectrum of the hydrogen atom?  Be specific, connecting your observations made on your spectra from the different salts and the hydrogen atoms as they relate to the theory. I understand you...
4. Other things equal, what effect will each of the following changes independently have on the...
4. Other things equal, what effect will each of the following changes independently have on the equilibrium level of real GDP in the private closed economy? 1. A decline in the real interest rate. 2. An overall decrease in the expected rate of return on investment. 3. A sizable, sustained increase in stock prices. (answer in your own words)
structuralism and neoliberalism and how do they defer from each other in regards to the role...
structuralism and neoliberalism and how do they defer from each other in regards to the role of the state in economic growth?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT