Question

In: Civil Engineering

Discussion Topic: Now that you have learned about welding and bolting; how do you compare them...

Discussion Topic: Now that you have learned about welding and bolting; how do you compare them in terms of economy (price), speed of construction, quality control, and so on; please write pros and cons for them.

Solutions

Expert Solution

ADVANTAGES OF WELDING :

1. Weldings are more economical and is much faster process as compared to other processes (riveting, bolting, casting etc.)

2. welding if properly controlled results permanent joints having strength equal or sometimes more than base metal.

3. Large number of metals and alloys both similar and dissimilar can be joined by welding.

4. General welding equipment is not very costly.

5. Portable welding equipment can be easily made available.

6. Welding permits considerable freedom in design.

7.Welding can join welding jobs through spots, as continuous pressure tight seams, end-to-end and in a number of other configurations.

8.Welding can also be mechanized.

DISADVANTAGES OF WELDING :

1. It results in residual stresses and distortion of the work pieces.

2. Welded joints needs stress relieving and heat treatment.

3. Welding gives out harmful radiations (light), fumes and spatter.

4. Jigs, and fixtures may also be needed to hold and position the parts to be welded

5. Edges preparation of the welding jobs are required before welding.

6. Skilled welder is required for production of good welding.

7. Heat during welding produces metallurgical changes as the structure of the welded joint is not same as that of the parent metal.

ADVANTAGES OF BOLTING :

1. They are easily disassembled, as opposed to something like riveting or welding, which requires cutting.

2. Bolted joints aren't particularly sensitive to the condition of the parent material. With welds and adhesive joints, the parent material needs to be clean, free of oils, etc (and obviously, it has to be metal to weld).

3. Bolts are easy. Welding takes a lot of skill and a lot of time, particularly if you're going to inspect the weld for flaws after it's completed. But just about everybody has used a wrench.

DISADVANTAGES :

1. They can become loose over time as the nut backs off (this can be addressed to some extent by using the proper preload and thread-locking features) or as the material creeps.

2. Complexity in bolting action as a bolted joint adds to a part count - a bolt, a nut, washers, thread lubricant, thread locking compound. And the bolts, nuts, and washers come in specific sizes with specific threads, with specific hole sizes and tolerances, for specific applications - if you need a high quality joint, you've got to keep track of all that and make sure the right bolt is used in the right place and in the right way.

3. Corrosion between a bolt and the parent material.


Related Solutions

Discussion Topic: You've learned a bit about credit cards, but many of us learn about them...
Discussion Topic: You've learned a bit about credit cards, but many of us learn about them the hard way. While sometimes people are forced into misusing credit cards due to circumstances beyond their control , sometimes the new availability of credit causes us to be less than prudent. Without divulging any personal information about anyone, share a story you've heard, know about, or researched (a search on credit card horror stories is usually very fruitful) about someone misusing credit cards...
Now that you have learned about the Keynesian perspective, what do you think about it? In...
Now that you have learned about the Keynesian perspective, what do you think about it? In your post, be sure to describe they Keynesian viewpoint and how they would use both fiscal and monetary policy to achieve their goals. Do you think Keyes was right? Why or why not?
Now that you have learned a bit about how Amazon uses A/B tests, what do you...
Now that you have learned a bit about how Amazon uses A/B tests, what do you think are some of the risks and challenges associated with performing so many hypothesis tests? What would you do to mitigate those risks? Think about the results of the tests. What were the effects? Look at the size of the effects. Were they small or large? Why were the sample sizes so large?
Now that you have learned how to respond to different types of emergencies, how do you...
Now that you have learned how to respond to different types of emergencies, how do you think you would react in an emergency situation? Explain your answer
You have now read and learned about fiscal policy and the impact that it may have...
You have now read and learned about fiscal policy and the impact that it may have on our debt. With everything you have learned thus far, do you believe that fiscal policy is a good thing for the economy? In what ways may it be bad and/or good for the economy? If you could choose between Keynsian Fiscal Policy or letting the economy self-correct what would you choose?
Select a discussion about a difficult topic you have heard about. Begin with a statement. Write...
Select a discussion about a difficult topic you have heard about. Begin with a statement. Write out a comment for each of the 8 elements from the circle of elements: Purpose, Question, assumptions, Implications, information, concepts, conclusions and point of view.Select a discussion about a difficult topic you have heard about. Begin with a statement. Write out a comment for each of the 8 elements from the circle of elements: Purpose, Question, assumptions, Implications, information, concepts, conclusions and point of...
Now that you have learned how to diversify an investment portfolio and compute the statistics in...
Now that you have learned how to diversify an investment portfolio and compute the statistics in Excel. Discuss why we need to use risk free rate to compute CML and what excel functions/ shortcuts you liked in this module and want to share with your peers.
5D1. Now that you have learned about various industry structures, think about a pure monopoly, monopolistic...
5D1. Now that you have learned about various industry structures, think about a pure monopoly, monopolistic competition, and oligopoly from the economic and then from a consumer perspective. Then, post a response to the following: As a consumer, what are the advantages and disadvantages of each of these industry structures? To an economy, what are the advantages and disadvantages of each of these industry structures? Do private and social interests coincide under these industry structures? Give examples to support your...
Now that you have a better idea about how markets work, you can do a little...
Now that you have a better idea about how markets work, you can do a little mental forecasting. You can ask yourself “how do I expect prices to change in this situation?”   Take the market for housing and the current situation we are in with the pandemic.   What do you expect to happen to home prices over the upcoming months: rise, fall, not change? In real estate lingo do you think this will be a buyer’s market or a seller’s...
Now that you have almost completed Basic Accounting, consider how what you have learned will impact...
Now that you have almost completed Basic Accounting, consider how what you have learned will impact your career in health care administration, as well as how this information can be applied to your household. In your first post: Share the concept from this course that you found to be the most valuable to both your future career as well as in managing your household finances. Do you feel differently about the field of accounting now that you have further studied...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT