Question

In: Physics

What happens if you perform a double slit experiment near an event horizon, if one of...

What happens if you perform a double slit experiment near an event horizon, if one of the slits is outside, one is inside the event horizon?

Solutions

Expert Solution

This is just a little bit subtle, because at first it looks like nobody has causal access to both light rays, which is required for the existence of interference pattern. On the other hand the principle of equivalence seems to assure us that local experiments done by a freely falling observer would not be affected by the presence of the horizon. There is a sense in which this is true, as follows.

For an observer freely falling into the horizon of a large black hole while conducting the double slit experiment, there will not be any change in the results of the experiment. Gravity is weak and nothing special happens when they cross the horizon, they will only discover they fell into a black hole sometime in the future when tidal forces will make life very uncomfortable. Any experiment localized within space and time will be the same up to tiny corrections due to weak gravity. This is true also if one of the slits (and therefore necessarily the light source) happens to be outside the horizon at the time of the experiment. Of course, for the freely falling observer that statement does not mean much, only the outside observer will be able to make meaningful distinction between inside and outside the horizon.

On the other hand, for an observer staying outside the horizon, one of the slits is invisible, they don't have access to all the light rays, and they will not see any interference. In fact they will not even be aware that there is a double slit experiment going on. There is no problem there because they are not freely falling observers, and there is nothing that states that the result of their experiment is identical to the same experiment made in flat space.

The fact that infalling and outside observers describe the same phenomena so differently lead to many black hole paradoxes, where quantum mechanics and GR (or the principle of equivalence) just barely co-exist without contradiction. Lenny Susskind's popular book on black holes has a good discussion, I think.

Edit: If you jump into the black hole you can have access to the interference pattern after the fact. So, it looks like you can generate another paradox, in addition to the original one. Look at arxiv.org/abs/0808.2096 for the resolution of that one. Roughly speaking, after you jump into the black hole you have only finite time to make measurements before you encounter the singularity. This time is insufficient to get more information than you are entitled to by the rules of quantum mechanics. This statement requires a detailed calculation which is in that paper.


Related Solutions

In Young's double-slit experiment, what happens to the spacing between the fringes if (a) the slit...
In Young's double-slit experiment, what happens to the spacing between the fringes if (a) the slit separation is increased? (b) the wavelength of the incident light is decreased? (c) if the distance between the slits and the viewing screen is increased?
What happens to the pattern when you: A. Increase the wavelength? (What happens for double slit...
What happens to the pattern when you: A. Increase the wavelength? (What happens for double slit pattern and single slit pattern?) B. Slits are moved closer (what happens for double-slit patterm?) C. Each slit is widened (what happens to single-slit pattern?)
As an admirer of Thomas Young, you perform a double-slit experiment in his honor. You set...
As an admirer of Thomas Young, you perform a double-slit experiment in his honor. You set your slits 1.15 mm apart and position your screen 3.67 m from the slits. Although Young had to struggle to achieve a monochromatic light beam of sufficient intensity, you simply turn on a laser with a wavelength of 641 nm . How far on the screen are the first bright fringe and the second dark fringe from the central bright fringe? Express your answers...
what is the importance of Young's double-slit experiment?
what is the importance of Young's double-slit experiment?
In a double-slit experiment, if the slit separation is increased by a factor of two, what...
In a double-slit experiment, if the slit separation is increased by a factor of two, what happens to the interference pattern shown on the screen? What happens if the wavelength is halved? What happens if the distance to the screen is double? Two small forward-facing speakers are 2.50 m apart. They are both emitting, in phase with each other, a sound of frequency 1100 Hz in a room where the speed of sound is 344 m/s. A woman is standing...
Suppose we perform a double-slit experiment with a detector placed at a position of minimum intensity...
Suppose we perform a double-slit experiment with a detector placed at a position of minimum intensity (maximum destructive interference), off-center where the path lengths differ by half a wavelength. The light source is alternately turned on and off (or blocked and unblocked near the source) and the intensity over time is recorded. I interpret the uncertainty principle to mean that there will be a peak in intensity at the times when the switch is flipped (whether on-to-off or off-to-on). i.e.,...
Explain Young's double slit experiment
Explain Young's double slit experiment
In a double-slit experiment, light with a wavelength λ passes through a double-slit and forms an...
In a double-slit experiment, light with a wavelength λ passes through a double-slit and forms an interference pattern on the screen at a distance L from the slits. What statement is true for the resulting interference pattern if the frequency of the light increases? OPTIONS: The distance between maxima stays the same.T he distance between maxima increases. The distance between maxima decreases. Not enough information given.
A physics professor wants to perform a lecture demonstration of Young's double-slit experiment for her class...
A physics professor wants to perform a lecture demonstration of Young's double-slit experiment for her class using the 633nm light from a He-Ne laser. Because the lecture hall is very large, the interference pattern will be projected on a wall that is 6.0m from the slits. For easy viewing by all students in the class, the professor wants the distance between the m=0 and m=1 maxima to be 30cm . What slit separation is required in order to produce the...
Describe Young's double slit experiment in detail. What is the purpose of the experiment? What kind...
Describe Young's double slit experiment in detail. What is the purpose of the experiment? What kind of result has been achieved with the experiment?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT