Question

In: Accounting

Financial Reporting Pressures Presented below is abbreviated testimony from Troy Normand in the WorldCom case. He...

Financial Reporting Pressures

Presented below is abbreviated testimony from Troy Normand in the WorldCom case. He was a manager in the corporate reporting department and is one of five individuals who pleaded guilty. He is testifying in hopes of receiving no prison time when he is ultimately sentenced.

Q. Mr. Normand, if you could just describe for the jury how the meeting started and what was said during the meeting?

A. I can't recall exactly who initiated the discussion, but right away Scott Sullivan acknowledged that he was aware we had problems with the entries, David Myers had informed him, and we were considering resigning.

He said that he respected our concerns but that we weren't being asked to do anything that he believed was wrong. He mentioned that he acknowledged that the company had lost focus quite a bit due to the preparations for the Sprint merger, and that he was putting plans in place and projects in place to try to determine where the problems were, why the costs were so high.

He did say he believed that the initial statements that we produced, that the line costs in those statements could not have been as high as they were, that he believed something was wrong and there was no way that the costs were that high.

I informed him that I didn't believe the entry we were being asked to do was right, that I was scared, and I didn't want to put myself in a position of going to jail for him or the company. He responded that he didn't believe anything was wrong, nobody was going to be going to jail, but that if it later was found to be wrong, that he would be the person going to jail, not me.

He asked that I stay, don't jump off the plane, let him land it softly, that's basically how he put it. And he mentioned that he had a discussion with Bernie Ebbers, asking Bernie to reduce projections going forward and that Bernie had refused.

Q. Mr. Normand, you said that Mr. Sullivan said something about don't jump out of the plane. What did you understand him to mean when he said that?

A. Not to quit.

Q. During this meeting, did Mr. Sullivan say anything about whether you would be asked to make entries like this in the future?

A. Yes, he made a comment that from that point going forward we wouldn't be asked to record any entries, high-level late adjustments, that the numbers would be the numbers.

Q. What did you understand that to be mean, the numbers would be the numbers?

A. That after the preliminary statements were issued, with the exception of any normal transaction, valid transaction, we wouldn't be asked to be recording any more late entries.

Q. I believe you testified that Mr. Sullivan said something about the line cost numbers not being accurate. Did he ask you to conduct any analysis to determine whether the line cost numbers were accurate?

A. No, he did not.

Q. Did anyone ever ask you to do that?

A. No.

Q. Did you ever conduct any such analysis?

A. No, I didn't.

Q. During this meeting, did Mr. Sullivan ever provide any accounting justification for the entry you were asked to make?

A. No, he did not.

Q. Did anything else happen during the meeting?

A. I don't recall anything else.

Q. How did you feel after this meeting?

A. Not much better actually. I left his office not convinced in any way that what we were asked to do was right. However, I did question myself to some degree after talking with him wondering whether I was making something more out of what was really there.

Instructions

Answer the following questions.

  1. What appears to be the ethical issue involved in this case?
  2. Is Troy Normand acting improperly or immorally?
  3. What would you do if you were Troy Normand?
  4. Who are the major stakeholders in this case?

Solutions

Expert Solution

SOLUTION

a.         The ethical issues that appear in this case are as follows:

•           Troy Normand proceeded to make an entry he felt did not reflect relevant and reliable financial information

•           He succumbed to management and job pressures although he had a moral obligation to ensure the financial statements reflected fairly the financial position of the company

•           He did not act with the best interest of the stakeholders in mind

•           Troy’s manager pressured Troy into ignoring his concerns and therefore ignoring his moral and ethical responsibilities to the shareholders

•           Troy’s manager is clearly acting with his best interests in mind

b.         Troy Normand acted unethically as stated above

c.         Troy should have implemented a further investigation of his concerns with full documentation of his findings.

•           It is evident that he was concerned about some of the costs on the income statement         and he was also questioning the adjusting entry he was being asked to record

•           As an accountant, he would need to follow codes of ethics where he is required to ensure competency i.e. he should have investigated the situation further to educate himself in all financial matters of the company.   

•           If there was doubt in any entries or accounting treatments, he was morally obligated         to ensure he was educated by further investigating the situation

•           He should have communicated his concerns to others (e.g. other members of management or outside authorities) rather than overlooking it

d.         The stakeholders in this case are investors, shareholders and employees


Related Solutions

Discuss the issues raised in Case C13-7 from financial reporting and ethical perspectives.
Discuss the issues raised in Case C13-7 from financial reporting and ethical perspectives.
Identify a role to assume in an analysis of a presented case Assess the financial reporting landscape, considering the user needs, constraints, and business environment
Identify a role to assume in an analysis of a presented caseAssess the financial reporting landscape, considering the user needs, constraints, and business environmentIdentify the issues contained in a presented caseAnalyze the issues (qualitatively and quantitatively) in a presented caseProvide a recommendation and conclusion based on a sound analysis of a caseInstructionsIndividually, review the case, which can be purchased using the following link from Ivey Publishing: https://www.iveycases.com/ProductView.aspx?id=101830Leverage the Intermediate Managerial Accounting textbook.Develop a formal response to the problem(s) posed in...
ssume the data presented below are from the financial statements of JetBlue and Southwest Airlines. ($...
ssume the data presented below are from the financial statements of JetBlue and Southwest Airlines. ($ millions) Jet Blue Airways Southwest Airlines Total Liabilities, 2013 $4,059 $10,326 Total Liabilities, 2012 5,003 8,815 Total Assets, 2013 6,593 15,463 Total Assets, 2012 6,549 14,269 Revenue, 2013 3,779 12,104 Net Income, 2013 237 629 Required a. Compute the return on equity ratio for JetBlue and Southwest for 2013. (Round your answer to one decimal place.) JetBlue Airways Answer% Southwest Airlines Answer% Which company...
Financial information for Kurzen Inc. is presented below.
Question Description   Financial information for Kurzen Inc. is presented below.   Instructions Prepare a schedule showing a horizontal analysis for 2017 using 2016 as the base year.
Selected data from the financial statements of KRJ Manufacturing are presented below. Calculate the return on...
Selected data from the financial statements of KRJ Manufacturing are presented below. Calculate the return on assets for the year, presenting your answer in percentage terms, rounded to two decimal places. e.g. 20.00%. Sales $117,358 Gross profits $51,639 Operating profits (EBIT) $32,879 Earnings before taxes (EBT) $25,389 Net profits $24,739 Tax expense 8,000 Depreciation expense $13,207 Total assets, beg of year $80,302 Total assets, end of year $99,082 Total equity, beg of year $46,237 Total equity, end of year $53,675...
he main reason for the financial statements and reporting for any city or municipality is for...
he main reason for the financial statements and reporting for any city or municipality is for the following … Select one: a. Implement the interperiod equity concept. b. Create accountability of the reports. c. Budgetary compliance. d. To show the service efforts. e. To show the accomplishments.
How does financial accounting differ from financial reporting?
How does financial accounting differ from financial reporting?
Selected data from the financial statements of KRJ Manufacturing are presented below. Calculate the gross profit...
Selected data from the financial statements of KRJ Manufacturing are presented below. Calculate the gross profit margin, presenting your answer in percentage terms, rounded to two decimal places. e.g. 20.00%. Sales $107,262 Cost of goods sold $51,727 Operating profits (EBIT) $32,852 Earnings before taxes (EBT) $28,308 Net profits $18,706 Tax expense 8,310 Depreciation expense $14,562 Total assets, beg of year $89,075 Total assets, end of year $83,449 Total equity, beg of year $42,951 Total equity, end of year $40,310 Cash...
Presented below are condensed financial statements adapted from those of two actual companies competing in the...
Presented below are condensed financial statements adapted from those of two actual companies competing in the pharmaceutical industry—Benatar and Jett, Inc. ($ in millions, except per share amounts). Balance Sheets ($ in millions, except per share data) Benatar Jett Assets: Cash $ 18,143 $ 12,398 Short-term investments 6,390 12,646 Accounts receivable (net) 9,184 11,385 Inventory 6,016 10,135 Other current assets 6,100 5,965 Current assets 45,833 52,529 Property, plant, and equipment (net) 16,254 24,695 Intangibles and other assets 20,030 73,355 Total...
Presented below are financial data from ECI’s 2016 annual report. Your job is to take this...
Presented below are financial data from ECI’s 2016 annual report. Your job is to take this information and put together a cash flow statement. Balance Sheet Data 12/31/2016 12/31/2015 Cash 102,500 45,000 Net Accts Receivable 28,000 35,000 Inventories 270,000 200,000 Land 43,000 35,000 Plant Assets, Gross 274,000 260,000 Accumulated Depreciation 82,000 75,000 Accounts Payable 50,000 64,000 Wages Payable 6,000 1,000 ST Notes Payable 3,000 10,000 Dividends Payable 3,000 2,000 LT Bonds Payable 107,000 90,000 Common Stock 200,000 170,000 APIC-CS 207,000...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT