Question

In: Psychology

Describe & give examples of the three types of authority by Max Weber. Why would the...

Describe & give examples of the three types of authority by Max Weber. Why would the interactionist perspective be particularly interested in charismatic authority? Which type of authority do you think would be the most effective & why? Which type of authority do you think would be the least effective & why?

Solutions

Expert Solution

  • The sociologist and philosopher Max Weber distinguishes three types of authority—charismatic, traditional and legal-rational—each of which corresponds to a brand of leadership that is operative in contemporary society.
  • First, charismatic authority points to an individual who possesses certain traits that make a leader extraordinary. This type of leader is not only capable of but actually possesses the superior power of charisma to rally diverse and conflict-prone people behind him. His power comes from the massive trust and almost unbreakable faith people put in him.
  • Second, traditional authority indicates the presence of a dominant personality. This leader is someone who depends on established tradition or order. While this leader is also a dominant personality, the prevailing order in society gives him the mandate to rule. This type of leadership, however, is reflective of everyday routine and conduct.
  • Third, legal-rational authority is one that is grounded in clearly defined laws. The obedience of people is not based on the capacity of any leader but on the legitimacy and competence that procedures and laws bestow upon persons in authority. Contemporary society depends on this type of rationalization, as the complexities of its problems require the emergence of a bureaucracy that embodies order and systematization.
  • Charismatic leadership can be problematic because it is somehow based on some form of a messianic promise of overhauling an unjust system. It is not impossible, however, to find such type of a leader, as history would show. Consider Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., or Nelson Mandela. A charismatic leader holds the mission to unite his people amid adversity and differences in order to attain an almost insurmountable goal.
  • Second, traditional authority poses its particular difficulty insofar as it is based on some kind of a dominant power. For Weber, all authority exhibits some form of domination. A traditional leader may rely on or even exploit prevailing practices. Traditional authority may suffer from a lack of moral regularity in the creation of legal standards.
  • Third, legal-rational authority makes manifest the power of the bureaucracy over the individual. In the exercise of authority, the administration of power, laws and rules, including institutional duties and protocols, have control over individuals. While order and systematization are desirable, the bureaucracy may not be able to fully address the problems and concerns of everyone, as what the development of nation-states today suggests,making it least effective.
  • The charismatic form of authority may be particularly applicable and effective in today's chaotic and rapidly changing environments.Weber also suggested that charismatic authority is inherently transitory and unstable, and is therefore most effective in times of crisis and change, serving primarily to facilitate the transition from one order to another.


Related Solutions

Describe the three bases of authority identified by Weber. Is it possible for each of these...
Describe the three bases of authority identified by Weber. Is it possible for each of these types of authority to function at the same time within an organization? Discuss.
Define each of Weber's three types of authority and give an example of each.
Define each of Weber's three types of authority and give an example of each.
Give some examples of manufacturing processes that would fit into each of the three different types...
Give some examples of manufacturing processes that would fit into each of the three different types of production processes: continuous processing, batch processing, and custom made-to-order.
Max Weber would argue that overt displays of sexuality are part of the economy Select one:...
Max Weber would argue that overt displays of sexuality are part of the economy Select one: a. uncertain b. none of the above c. true d. false The basis for ethnic group identity Select one: a. develops from their language or dialect b. develops from their biological characteristics c. develops from their unique historical and social experiences d. develops from their religious practices Sexual harassment is a form of overt discrimination that has a negative impact on women's employment. Which...
Define Fraud and give specific examples of three types
Define Fraud and give specific examples of three types
short answer : List two of the six traits that Max Weber used to describe bureaucratic...
short answer : List two of the six traits that Max Weber used to describe bureaucratic social organizations and give an explanation of your two choices. What is the "McDonaldization" of society? List two of the four principles that define this organizational pattern and briefly describe them. What does it mean to say that rationality may be irrational? How might Weber respond to this question?
a. Explain why Karl Marx believed capitalist society was irrational, while Max Weber believed it was...
a. Explain why Karl Marx believed capitalist society was irrational, while Max Weber believed it was very rational. b. Explain how Marx and Weber held somewhat different ideas about the cause of alienation in modern society. c. Identify the seven traits that define rational social organization, according to Max Weber. What makes these traits “rational”?
Name and describe 3 types of community interactions and give examples.
Name and describe 3 types of community interactions and give examples.
Give at least three examples of when you would use ANOVA. Why would you use ANOVA...
Give at least three examples of when you would use ANOVA. Why would you use ANOVA as opposed to t-Tests to determine the mean differences? Which method do you feel is easier to comprehend?
Describe the three types of Economies giving relevant examples
Describe the three types of Economies giving relevant examples
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT