Question

In: Operations Management

Laws are enacted by Congress, and the courts apply those laws to the facts of a...

Laws are enacted by Congress, and the courts apply those laws to the facts of a case to reach a decision. For cases that get appealed to the United States Supreme Court, the nine justices often do not reach unanimous decisions. Explain in substantial detail how judges that are interpreting the same laws and the same facts may reach different conclusions, and specifically comment on how it is never simply because a judge may be Republican or Democrat.

Solutions

Expert Solution

****Please please please LIKE THIS ANSWER, so that I can get a small benefit, Please****

Judges may may come to different conclusions even though they are interpreting the same laws and constitution because different judges uses a different way in interpreting the laws.Some of the elements judges use in interpreting law and that makes them end up in different conclusion include:

  1. Historical Interpretation-in this case judges looks at the historical activities in ratifying and interpreting the laws.
  2. Doctrinal Interpretation-A judge here applies other laws made by different judges before
  3. Structural Interpretation-In this case a judge considers structural laws specially in the constitution
  4. Textual Interpretation- A judge looks the meaning of the words of the constitution,relying on common words used
  5. prudential Interpretation-In this case a judge interest is to balance the costs and damages of a particular ruling
  6. Ethical Interpretation- judges the laws by looking at the moral commitments provided in the constitution'

Explanation:

Judges that are interpreting the same laws and the same facts may reach different conclusions,Even though a judge may be Republican or Democrat.This because every judge uses a different skill in interpreting the laws.Additionally,judicial decision are also affected by internal or external factors may may be based on ideology,personal,legal and political influence.

****Please please please LIKE THIS ANSWER, so that I can get a small benefit, Please****

keosha answered 5 months ago
Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Is it unethical to exempt congress from laws that apply to all U.S. citizens? What is...
Is it unethical to exempt congress from laws that apply to all U.S. citizens? What is different about the insider trading Martha Stewart engaged in compared to the exemptions given to Congress? Since some citizens can conduct insider trading should all citizens be able to?
•What is the relationship between Congress and the federal courts and what is Congress responsible for?
•What is the relationship between Congress and the federal courts and what is Congress responsible for?
Statutes enacted by legislatures, whether the Congress of the United States or at a state level,...
Statutes enacted by legislatures, whether the Congress of the United States or at a state level, often are vague. Hence, the policy mandates given to public administrators via the legislation are vague. This also shifts much of the policy making to public administrators. Explain the advantages to the public of the public administrators, rather than the elected representatives, making policy via rules and regulations.
Statutes enacted by legislatures, whether the Congress of the United States or at a state level,...
Statutes enacted by legislatures, whether the Congress of the United States or at a state level, often are vague. Hence, the policy mandates given to public administrators via the legislation are vague. This also shifts much of the policy making to public administrators. Explain the advantages to the public of the public administrators, rather than the elected representatives, making policy via rules and regulations.
Compare and contrast the ways in which the media cover the Congress and Courts versus the...
Compare and contrast the ways in which the media cover the Congress and Courts versus the Presidency. YOU MUST GIVE EXAMPLES.
Should the modern President have imperial power and treat the Congress and Courts as advisors to...
Should the modern President have imperial power and treat the Congress and Courts as advisors to implement his orders to get things done. Or should we go back to the Constitutional idea that Congress, specifically the House, be the governor of the country and protector of the people with the President staying out of domestic issues?
6. Most of the laws enacted that affect nutrition, food, and health are passed to the...
6. Most of the laws enacted that affect nutrition, food, and health are passed to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) or the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) for implementation in public health services. True False 7. Students enrolled in a community nutrition course were required to identify the government agency responsible for administering nutrition monitoring and other nutrition surveillance activities of the DHHS, which is known as: A) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. B) U.S....
As a result of federal laws and the 14th amendment to the us constitution federal courts...
As a result of federal laws and the 14th amendment to the us constitution federal courts _________
Article III Judge Smith is asked to review a provision of Congress' recently enacted law titled,...
Article III Judge Smith is asked to review a provision of Congress' recently enacted law titled, the National Bubblegum Trade Act, which in part, requires all sales of bubblegum to be conducted in physical stores. If Judge smith looks to Webster's dictionary to determine what the meaning of the words " physical" and "store" mean, what type of analysis would he be engaged in?
Political parties influence both Congress and decision making in federal courts but this influence occurs differently....
Political parties influence both Congress and decision making in federal courts but this influence occurs differently. 1a) Explain what conditional party government (CPG) is. How does CPG affect the relationship of congressional party leaders and US Senators and Representatives? 1b) How do legislative parties and party leaders influence how their members vote? 1c) Partisan influence exists within federal courts but it works differently. What causes partisan behavior on the courts? 1d) Do party leaders explicitly lobby (talk about court cases...
ADVERTISEMENT
Subjects
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest Questions
ADVERTISEMENT