Question

In: Physics

What are the two fundamental problems of measurement?

What are the two fundamental problems of measurement?

Solutions

Expert Solution

the first problem is justification of the assignment of numbers to objects or (phenomena.).

The second problem Concerns the specification of the degree to which this assignment is unique.

First Fundamental Problem: The Representation Theorem
The early history of mathematics shows how difficult it was to divorce arithmetic from particular empirical structures. The ancient Egyptians could not think of 2 + 3 , but only of 2 bushels of wheat plus 3 bushels of wheat. Intellectually,it is a great step forward to realize that the assertion that 2 bushels of wheat plus 3 bushels of wheat equals 5 bushels of wheat involves the same mathematical considerations as the statement that .2 quarts of milk plus 3 quarts of milk equals 5 quarts of milk.
From a logical standpoint, there is just one arithmetic of numbers,not an arithmetic for bushels of Wheat, and a separate arithmetic for quarts of milk. The first problem for a theory of measurement is to show how various features of this arithmetic of numbers may be applied in a variety of empirical situations. This is done by showing that certain aspects of the arithmetic of numbers have the same structure as the empirical situation investigated. The purpose of the definition of isomorphism to be given is to make the rough-and_ready intuitive.idea of "same structure" precise. The great significance of finding such an
isomorphism of structures is that we may then use many of our familiar computational methods, applied to the arithmetical structure, to infer facts about the isomorphic empirical structure.

The first fundamental problem of measurement may be cast as the problem of showing that any empirical relational system which purports to measure by a simple number given property of the elements in the domain of the system is isomorphic (or possibly homomorphic) to an appropriately chosen numerical relational system.


Related Solutions

Discuss the three fundamental problems (what, how and for whom) of economics.
Discuss the three fundamental problems (what, how and for whom) of economics.
Discuss the three following fundamental problems (what, how and for whom) of economics. What goods and...
Discuss the three following fundamental problems (what, how and for whom) of economics. What goods and services are being produced? How goods and services are being produced? For whom goods and services are being produced. Just explain little bit about these three problems.
What are the two parts of the Fundamental Theorem of Linear Algebra?
What are the two parts of the Fundamental Theorem of Linear Algebra? How can they be applied? Give 1 example problem for each part.
What do problems with the measurement of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Consumer Price Index (CPI),...
What do problems with the measurement of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Consumer Price Index (CPI), and unemployment rate statistics mean about the actual state of the economy as compared to what the statistics indicate? Is the country really doing better or worse than what the indicators say? How can you tell?
What are the two most important fundamental limitations of the Beer-Lambert Law?
What are the two most important fundamental limitations of the Beer-Lambert Law?
What two problems are associated with actual costing? How does normal costing "solve" these two problems?...
What two problems are associated with actual costing? How does normal costing "solve" these two problems? At the end of a month, how is over or under applied overhead reported on the financial statements? At the end of the year, how is over or under applied overhead reported on the financial statements?
Public Health: What are the two ways to determine if the outcomes chosen for measurement are...
Public Health: What are the two ways to determine if the outcomes chosen for measurement are actually relevant?
What is a niche? What may happen if two organisms occupy the same fundamental niche in...
What is a niche? What may happen if two organisms occupy the same fundamental niche in an environment? A set of experiments was run to test for character displacement in two species of humming birds with regards to bill length. They found the following results: 1) When the two species are found together, their bill lengths are more different than when they are found apart. 2) The sympatric populations often have high immigration rates from the corresponding allopatric populations. 3)...
Interactive LearningWare 22.2 reviews the fundamental approach in problems such as this. A constant magnetic field...
Interactive LearningWare 22.2 reviews the fundamental approach in problems such as this. A constant magnetic field passes through a single rectangular loop whose dimensions are 0.29 m x 0.61 m. The magnetic field has a magnitude of 1.7 T and is inclined at an angle of 72o with respect to the normal to the plane of the loop. (a) If the magnetic field decreases to zero in a time of 0.61 s, what is the magnitude of the average emf...
Should policy analysts try to deal with the fundamental causes of social problems such as crime,...
Should policy analysts try to deal with the fundamental causes of social problems such as crime, poverty, or homelessness, or aim instead for a more pragmatic and limited approach that may be more realistic, or more politically acceptable? Use your policy as an example and discuss the approach you think would be most effective.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT