Question

In: Economics

The year is 1870, the location is the town of Silverton in Colorado. There are two...

The year is 1870, the location is the town of Silverton in Colorado. There are two saloons in town: Red's Beard and Sadie's White Garter. After years of cut-throat competition the two owners, Red and Sadie, decide to cooperate in order to make more money. They have been making $400 per month each by competing fair and square. They decide if they each raise prices and limit the number of beers served, they will earn $1,000 per month each. However if one limits the number of beers and raises prices and the other does not, then they will earn only $200 per month while their competitor will earn $1,500 per month. Not knowing what to do, they turn to you, the prospecting game theorist, to help them figure out what to do.

Fill in the following table with the payoffs they can expect. Enter as follows: (Red's payoff, Sadie's payoff). Enter whole numbers - no commas.

Sadie's
Raise Prices Do Not Raise Prices
Red's Raise Prices (                            [ Select ]                       ["400", "1,000", "1,500", "200"]         ,                            [ Select ]                       ["1,500", "1,000", "200", "400"]         ) (                            [ Select ]                       ["400", "1,500", "1,000", "200"]         ,                            [ Select ]                       ["200", "1,500", "400", "1,000"]         )
Do Not Raise Prices (                            [ Select ]                       ["1,500", "200", "1,000", "400"]         ,                            [ Select ]                       ["1,000", "400", "200", "1,500"]         ) (                            [ Select ]                       ["400", "1,000", "1,500", "200"]         ,                            [ Select ]                       ["1,500", "400", "1,000", "200"]         )

Based on the payoffs, what is the likely outcome of the game? Explain

both of them raises prices

both of them do not raise prices

sadie does but red does not

red does but sadie does not raise prices

Solutions

Expert Solution

The problem seems to have an uncanny similarity with the classic 'Prisoners Dilemma' problem. Not surprising. As the situation stands, it seems that cooperation could give them both a steady income but, if one of them breaks the deal and takes advantage, there is a good amount of money to be earned. ( also friendship will be lost over beer, oddly) Then again both of them are in a similiar position to take advantage and if they both try to take advantage, they will lose a lot of  money, becoming competitors,. The payoff matrix makes the story a bit more clear:

red(first)/sadie(next) raise prices do not raise prices
raise prices 1000,1000 200,1500
do not raise prices 1500,200 400,400

It seems that if both Red and Sadie cooperate with each other and raise prices, they will be doing good earning 1000 each. It seems like a good deal. The only problem is that in that case, each of them will have an incentive to under-cut the prices and lure away the customers to gain more (from 1000 to 1500). Now if one cuts the price, the other will follow suit and then with successive undercuts, they will be back to being competitors earning a paltry 400 each. Not raising is the equililibrium strategy for both but they will only get sub-optimal results. The dilemma of this game is that both have an incentive to under-cut each other to gain more but sadly, since both take the same path to retaliation they end up being worse off then thwy would be if they could keep their promise.


Related Solutions

Would it be better to have a permanent location for the Olympics? Do you think Colorado...
Would it be better to have a permanent location for the Olympics? Do you think Colorado would benefit economically from hosting the Winter Olympics?
Colorado Equipment is evaluating two financing options to raise $10 million for an expansion project. Colorado...
Colorado Equipment is evaluating two financing options to raise $10 million for an expansion project. Colorado Equipment can borrow money from a bank and the interest rate will be 8%, or Colorado Equipment can issue one million common stocks for $10 per share. The company currently has 2.5 million common shares. Without the new financing, the projected income statement of Colorado Equipment is shown below. The earnings per share for Colorado Equipment are: 1.03 under public issue and 1.95 under...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,000 shares of...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,000 shares of stock and $410,400 in debt. Plan II would result in 12,450 shares of stock and $250,200 in debt. The interest rate on the debt is 10 percent. a. Ignoring taxes, compare both of these plans to an all-equity plan assuming that EBIT will be $53,300. The all-equity plan would result in 19,400 shares of stock outstanding. Compute the EPS for each plan. (Do not...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,500 shares of...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,500 shares of stock and $402,500 in debt. Plan II would result in 12,000 shares of stock and $280,000 in debt. The interest rate on the debt is 11 percent. a. Ignoring taxes, compare both of these plans to an all-equity plan assuming that EBIT will be $54,500. The all-equity plan would result in 20,000 shares of stock outstanding. Compute the EPS for each plan. (Do not...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 9,000 shares of...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 9,000 shares of stock and $342,000 in debt. Plan II would result in 12,600 shares of stock and $205,200 in debt. The interest rate on the debt is 10 percent. a. Ignoring taxes, compare both of these plans to an all-equity plan assuming that EBIT will be $53,500. The all-equity plan would result in 18,000 shares of stock outstanding. Compute the EPS for each plan. (Do not...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 9,000 shares of...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 9,000 shares of stock and $430,000 in debt. Plan II would result in 12,600 shares of stock and $275,200 in debt. The interest rate on the debt is 9 percent. a. Ignoring taxes, compare both of these plans to an all-equity plan assuming that EBIT will be $54,000. The all-equity plan would result in 19,000 shares of stock outstanding. Compute the EPS for each plan. (Do not...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,700 shares of...
Silverton Co. is comparing two different capital structures. Plan I would result in 8,700 shares of stock and $399,000 in debt. Plan II would result in 12,500 shares of stock and $239,400 in debt. The interest rate on the debt is 11 percent. a. Ignoring taxes, compare both of these plans to an all-equity plan assuming that EBIT will be $53,900. The all-equity plan would result in 18,200 shares of stock outstanding. Compute the EPS for each plan. (Do not...
Design a class named Location for locating a maximal value and its location in a two-dimensional...
Design a class named Location for locating a maximal value and its location in a two-dimensional array. The class contains public data fields row, column and maxValue that stores the maximal value and its indices in a two-dimensional array with row and column as int types and maxValue as a double type. Write the following method that returns the location of the largest element in a two dimensional array: public static location locate Largest(double[][] a) The return value is an...
Old Town Entertainment has two employees in Year 1. Clay earns $4,400 per month, and Philip,...
Old Town Entertainment has two employees in Year 1. Clay earns $4,400 per month, and Philip, the manager, earns $10,100 per month. Neither is paid extra for working overtime. Assume the Social Security tax rate is 6 percent on the first $110,000 of earnings and the Medicare tax rate is 1.5 percent on all earnings. The federal income tax withholding is 16 percent of gross earnings for Clay and 20 percent for Philip. Both Clay and Philip have been employed...
John turned 19 and started college at Northern Colorado University after a year of community college....
John turned 19 and started college at Northern Colorado University after a year of community college. His father bought him a 2003 Honda Accord for $3,500 to drive while in school. John’s father promised him if he did not have any accident he would buy him a brand-new Ford Mustang GT once he finished his undergraduate degree. How much liability coverage (per person bodily injury liability, total liability, property damage liability) do you recommend for his 2003 Honda Accord? Give...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT