Question

In: Economics

a. XYZ Inc. is accused of being a monopoly. The CEO claims that it’s not a...

a. XYZ Inc. is accused of being a monopoly. The CEO claims that it’s not a monopoly, arguing that if XYZ were to raise its price it would lose sales. This is because consumers always have the option to spend their money on other goods. Is the CEO’s argument persuasive? Explain (6 pts.)

b. (Unrelated to the above) A monopoly firm is currently maximizing profit, earning economic profit of $10 million per year. It is now successfully sued by a former employee who is awarded $1 million. A manager of the firm argues that to recoup the lost $1 million, the firm needs to raise its price. Do you agree? Explain. (6 pts).

Solutions

Expert Solution

a. The CEO,s arguement is persuasive. This is because if the consumers have substitutes of the commodity available in the market such that the consumers can shift to those if the price of the commodity of concern is increased, then the firm cannot be classified as a monopoly. The monopoly structure is that where there is only one firm operating in the industry with no close substitutes of the product.

b. The magager of the firm is giving an agreeable solution. However, it is not optimal.We know that the firm is already operating at the optimal level and is earning positive economic profit. Since the concerned firm is operating in a monopoly market structure, it does not need to raise the price in the market. It can simply exercise price discrimination and try to maximize the producer surplus through that. This way, firm will be able to earn maximum profits. The degree of price discrimination can vary according to the market conditions.


Related Solutions

You work for a company that is being accused of monopoly behavior, given its large size.
  You work for a company that is being accused of monopoly behavior, given its large size. Comparisons are made to the industry standard, where each establishment has on average about 16.3 employees. Your company is bigger than that, but you want to provide evidence against the monopoly charges. a. You’ve collected data at different times in your company’s history, when you had different amounts of capital. In 2012, SRATC = 17Q2 – 2,200Q + 100,000 In 2015, SRATC =...
You work for a company that is being accused of monopoly behavior, given its large size....
You work for a company that is being accused of monopoly behavior, given its large size. Comparisons are made to the industry standard, where each establishment has on average about 16.3 employees. Your company is bigger than that, but you want to provide evidence against the monopoly charges. You’ve collected data at different times in your company’s history, when you had different amounts of capital. In 2012, SRATC=17Q2−2,200Q+100,000 In 2015, SRATC=37Q2−1,500Q+55,000 In 2018, SRATC=20Q2−2,000Q+75,000 1. After plotting these three different...
For all the following, consider the company, XYZ Inc. a.         It’s preferred stock pays a dividend...
For all the following, consider the company, XYZ Inc. a.         It’s preferred stock pays a dividend of $1.00. If you require a return of 10 percent, what is the most you would pay for their preferred stock today? b.         Preferred stock is ok, but you really want common stock because of the growth potential. Consider that XYZ just paid a regular dividend of $4. If the required return on equity is 20 percent, what is the most you’d pay...
How can you protect yourself from being accused of an unintentional tort?
How can you protect yourself from being accused of an unintentional tort?
BUSINESS LAW QUESTION 1. If Charlie is being accused of battery, could this be a criminal...
BUSINESS LAW QUESTION 1. If Charlie is being accused of battery, could this be a criminal trial, a civil trial, or both? Both Neither Civil Criminal 2. Dave is starting a new company making high-end hoodies and needs to find distributors to move his product. He doesn't have any agreements with any distributors at the moment. His brother Johnny hates Dave and wants to destroy his business, so he goes to all the distributors in town and offers them $5,000...
In Chapter 1 Backhouse, Economists are accused of being “autistic” summarize the positions taken by “The...
In Chapter 1 Backhouse, Economists are accused of being “autistic” summarize the positions taken by “The Prosecution” and “The Defense”.  Do you agree or disagree with either of these?
“We’ve got a special order for 10,000 units from XYZ Inc.” said Harry Hope, CEO of...
“We’ve got a special order for 10,000 units from XYZ Inc.” said Harry Hope, CEO of Widgets R Us (WRU). If we get this order, this can mean a lot of future business from this customer in the future. WRU has extra capacity and accepting this deal will not impact sales from their current customer base. XYZ is only willing to pay $10 per unit. If overhead costs are overapplied, WRU may lose out on a profitable deal. At the...
Give an example of a real-world monopoly or a firm close to being a monopoly. Discuss...
Give an example of a real-world monopoly or a firm close to being a monopoly. Discuss what you think is the source(s) of its market power. For instance, do you think this is an example of a cost-based monopoly or is there some other explanation, such as advertising or network effects, etc.
strategies being employed by IBM to manage it’s innovation evaluate the strategies being employed by IBM...
strategies being employed by IBM to manage it’s innovation evaluate the strategies being employed by IBM manage its innovation
Case study of Monopoly Microsoft(MSFT) has been accused of violating the Anti-trust law time to time....
Case study of Monopoly Microsoft(MSFT) has been accused of violating the Anti-trust law time to time. MSFT had the legal problem with European Community(EC). Q1)Do you think Monopoly business practice is so bad for the general public's welfare? why? or why not? Explain based on cost and benefit analysis of social welfare.(0.5 point) Q2)Do you think FAANG companies are Monopoly? FAANG are Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Neflix and Google. Do you think Government should regulate and break up these FAANG companies?...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT