Question

In: Operations Management

Mechelle Vinson worked at Meritor Savings Bank, initially as a teller-trainee, but was later promoted to...

Mechelle Vinson worked at Meritor Savings Bank, initially as a teller-trainee, but was later promoted to teller, head teller, and assistant branch manager, admittedly based upon merit. Sidney Taylor was the bank branch manager and the person who hired Vinson. Vinson alleged that in the begin- ning Taylor was “fatherly” toward her and made no sexual advances, but eventually he asked her to go out to dinner. During the course of the meal Taylor suggested that he and Vinson go to a motel to have sexual relations. At first she refused, but out of what she described as fear of losing her job, she eventually agreed. Taylor thereafter made repeated demands upon Vinson for sexual activity, usually at the branch, both during and after business hours. She estimated that over the next several years she had intercourse with him some 40 or 50 times. In addition, she testified that Taylor fondled her in front of other employees, followed her into the women’s restroom when she went there alone, exposed himself to her, and even forcibly raped her on several occasions. These activities ceased in 1977 when Vinson started going with a steady boyfriend.

Courts have applied Title VII protection to racial ha- rassment and nothing in Title VII suggests that a hostile environment based on discriminatory sexual harassment should not be likewise prohibited. The Guidelines thus appropriately drew from, and were fully consistent with, the existing case law.
Of course, not all workplace conduct that may be de- scribed as “harassment” affects a “term, condition, or privi- lege” of employment within the meaning of Title VII. For instance, mere utterance of an ethnic or racial epithet which engenders offensive feelings in an employee would not af- fect the condition of employment to a sufficiently signifi- cant degree to create an abusive working environment. For sexual harassment to be actionable, it must be sufficiently severe or pervasive to alter the conditions of the victim’s employment and create an abusive working environment. Vinson’s allegations in this case—which include not only pervasive harassment, but also criminal conduct of the most serious nature—are plainly sufficient to state a claim for hostile environment sexual harassment.
The District Court’s conclusion that no actionable ha- rassment occurred might have rested on its earlier finding that if Vinson and Taylor had engaged in intimate or sexual relations, that relationship was a voluntary one. But the fact that sex-related conduct was “voluntary” in the sense that the complainant was not forced to participate against her will, is not a defense to a sexual harassment suit brought under Title VII. The gravamen of any sexual harassment claim is the alleged sexual advances were “unwelcome.” While the question whether particular conduct was indeed unwelcome presents difficult problems of proof and turns largely on credibility determinations committed to the trier of fact, the District Court in this case erroneously focused
on the “voluntariness” of Vinson’s participation in the claimed sexual episodes. The correct inquiry is whether Vinson, by her conduct, indicated that the alleged sexual advances were unwelcome, not whether her participation in sexual intercourse was voluntary.
The district court admitted into evidence testimony about Vinson’s “dress and personal fantasies.” The court of appeals stated that testimony had no place in the litigation, on the basis that Vinson’s voluntariness in submitting to Taylor’s advances was immaterial to her sexual harassment claim. While “voluntariness” in the sense of consent is not a defense to such a claim, it does not follow that a complain- ant’s sexually provocative speech or dress is irrelevant as a matter of law in determining whether she found particular sexual advances welcome. To the contrary, such evidence is obviously relevant. The EEOC Guidelines emphasize that the trier of fact must determine the existence of sexual ha- rassment in light of “the record as a whole” and the “totality of circumstances,” such as the nature of the sexual advances and the context in which the alleged incidents occurred.
In sum we hold that a claim of “hostile environment” sexual harassment gender discrimination is actionable under Title VII. AFFIRMED.
Case Questions
1. As a manager, what would you have done if Vinson had come to you with her story?
2.   Under the circumstances, should it matter that Vinson “voluntarily” had sex with Taylor? That she received her regular promotions? Explain.
3. As a manager, how would you determine who to believe?

Solutions

Expert Solution

1: As a manager it is very much required to understand the views from both side ( Vinson & Taylor). Then the manager can go in detail where Taylor had taken or given any inappropriate or undeservable promotion or hike to the Vinson. The detailed evaluation may help in understanding whther the relationship started mutually or was it forcibly made.

2: Yes it matter. She cannot alleged later on that somebody without her interest started sexual relationship and done intercourses for more than 40 times. If she has fear about losing the job she couldnt have expressed the concern to senior management that time itself. Now she cannot claim everyhting in favor of her as now she is a well established employee in that company.. T

3: It is a very tough situation to handle. Vinson claim must be true to an extent as Taylor must have had sexual relationship with her. But cannot take the entire details or situation only from one angle. The multiple versions of the same scenario will help in providing some more insight which would be more judgemental in nature . In this both parties have done mistake by building an illegal relationship in the cover of employement. They have even utilised the space in office for their sexual activities which is an offense.


Related Solutions

Betty Vinson was the director of management reporting at WorldCom. She had worked there for five...
Betty Vinson was the director of management reporting at WorldCom. She had worked there for five years when the fraud was uncovered and received two promotions during that time. Vinson’s salary increased from $50,000 when she started to $80,000 in 2002. Vinson reported to Buford Yates, director of general accounting, who reported to David Myers, senior vice president and controller, who then reported to CFO Scott Sullivan. (See Figure 1 for an organizational chart.) A hard worker who often stayed...
The La Puerta Bank of Stockholm City has one outside drive-up teller. It takes the teller...
The La Puerta Bank of Stockholm City has one outside drive-up teller. It takes the teller an average of 4 minutes to serve a bank customer. Customers arrive at the drive-up window at a rate of 12 per hour. The bank operations officer is currently analyzing the possibility of adding a second drive-up window, at an annual cost of Php 1,000,000. It is assumed that arriving cars would be equally divided between both windows. The operations officer estimates that each...
Alex was a bank teller at Wells Fargo Bank. One of his long time customers is...
Alex was a bank teller at Wells Fargo Bank. One of his long time customers is Bill. Bill is the manger of Buffalo Wild Wings. Everyday is comes in noon to do a deposit, he leaves the deposit and Alex emails the receipt. This particular day Bill was in a hurry and missed indorsing two of the checks. Using IRAC, determine whether Alex can accept the deposit from Bill.
(Using Excel)  The length of time for a teller to serve a customer in a bank is...
(Using Excel)  The length of time for a teller to serve a customer in a bank is important. The teller service time has been recorded by camera and follows a normal distribution but has an unknown standard deviation. A simple random sample of 20 service times is selected and the times are measured. The sample mean is found to be 120 seconds. The sample standard deviation is found to be 22 seconds.  Since we do not know the population standard deviation, we...
2. The amount of time that a drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a...
2. The amount of time that a drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a random variable with a mean  minutes and a standard deviation  minutes. If a random sample of 64 customers is observed, find the probability that their mean time at the teller’s window is: a) At most 2.7 minutes b) more than 3.5 minutes
The amount of time that a​ drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a random...
The amount of time that a​ drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a random variable with a mean mu = 4.9 minutes and a standard deviation sigma = 2.4 minutes. If a random sample of 36 customers is​ observed, find the probability that their mean time at the​ teller's window is ​(a) at most 4.3 ​minutes; ​(b) more than 5.3 ​minutes; ​(c) at least 4.9 minutes but less than 5.7 minutes. (a) The probability that the mean time...
The amount of time that a drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a random...
The amount of time that a drive-through bank teller spends on a customer is a random variable with a mean   3.1 minutes and variance 2.65 . If a random sample of 51 customers is observed. (a) Find the probability that their mean time at the teller’s window is at least 3.2 minutes but less than 3.4 minutes (a) Find the probability that their variance at the teller’s window is not more than 1.7855.
The amount of time a bank teller spends with each customer has a population mean of...
The amount of time a bank teller spends with each customer has a population mean of 3.086 minutes. You select a random sample of 16 customers. The sample standard deviation is 0.40 minutes. There is a 95% chance that the sample mean is below ______ minutes
The management of Iroquois National Bank is considering an investment in automatic teller machines. The machines...
The management of Iroquois National Bank is considering an investment in automatic teller machines. The machines would cost $134,400 and have a useful life of seven years. The bank’s controller has estimated that the automatic teller machines will save the bank $28,000 after taxes during each year of their life (including the depreciation tax shield). The machines will have no salvage value. Use Appendix A for your reference. (Use appropriate factor(s) from the tables provided.) Required: 1.Compute the payback period...
What could be a recruitment advertising for bank teller? What kind payment and benefits of the...
What could be a recruitment advertising for bank teller? What kind payment and benefits of the job as bank teller? What kind interview questions would be ask if to get into this job. Would like 6 examples please.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT