Question

In: Economics

essay question What factors have courts considered when evaluating factual statements versus opinion-based statements? Could there...

essay question

What factors have courts considered when evaluating factual statements versus opinion-based statements? Could there still be liability for purely opinion-based statements?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The Supreme court stated that the firsr amendment required a distinction between statement of fact and the statement of opinion.The inherent indeterminacy of words and thesubjectivity of interpretationmakes the fact \ opinion distinct. Politically free speech is necessary in democratic governance,the freedom to form ,communicate one's own opinion is amust in the forming of individual and common judgement.The distinction between fact and opinion made under the common law of fair comment.Courts were however unable to agree on how the distinction between fact and opinion should be made.Some courts simply refused to make the distinction.The first case which the United States Supreme Court expressly addressed the fact/opinion distinction was Greenbelt cooperative Publishing Assoc vs Bresler.

"A fact "in its basic form refers to a tangible objectbut opinion can not be compared to a physical object to determine the relation between the two. Factual statements are true or false independenty of any value judgements but opinions may deal with subject matters in which there is no conclision, it is not always easy to determine wether it is a pure opinion. In general the facts are statements that can be proven true or false opinions are believes or ideas. Courts will look at the context and medium in which the alleged defamation occured. For example, a statement is more likely to be regarded as an opinion rather than a fact if it occurs in an editorial blog as opposed to a piece of investigative journalism.
The factors courts often use to determine whether a statement is a protected opinion are:
1. What is the common usage and specific meaning of the language used?
2. Is the statement verifiable? Can it be proven false?
3. What is the full context of the statement?
4. What are the social conventions surroundings the medium the statementoccured in?
Note that each state decides what is required to establish defamation and what defences .
The court analyise the statement of opinion under its two potential bases for liability ;;;;
1. The prohibition on making an untrue statement of material fact.
2. The prohibition on omitting material fact necessary to make a statement not misleading.
Lower courts seem confused about what to do with the supreme court findings of fact some courts deny being bound by the factual findings of highing courts.

The US supreme Court ruled today that a statement of opinion in a registered statement cannot ba actionable as amisstatement of fact uner sec 11 of the Securities Act1933 if the assure actually believed the opinion expressed.It clarifies the liability under this section.The court announced important principles for interpreting the application of the two bases for liability unde section 11 as fallows;;

A) The statement of "pure opinion" that turns out to be wrong cannot be a basis for section11 liability as" an untrue statement of material fact .If the issuer honestly believed the opinion when making.The court observed that section 11 is not an invitation to monday morning quarterback an issuer's opinion"

B) A statement of opinion ,however, could be actionble under section 11 as meterially misleading if the rgistration statement omits material facts about the bases for the issuer,s opinion that a reasonable investor,upon consideration of the totally of information disclosed,would infer from the opinion and such omitted material facts are untrue.

This has a significant implications for the litigation of sec 11 claims challenging statement of opinion and for the preparation of registration of of statement disclosure.The courts indicated the statements started with "we believe" and " we think" would br identified as purely opinions,these statements will mislead audience and support sec 11.

The supreme court clarified the circumstances in the case Omnicare,Inc.v.labourers.


Related Solutions

What environmental factors must be considered when evaluating financial statements? Be specific.
What environmental factors must be considered when evaluating financial statements? Be specific.
When evaluating research, what factors should be considered? Why are these factors important? Provide some examples...
When evaluating research, what factors should be considered? Why are these factors important? Provide some examples to illustrate the importance of each factor.
When evaluating research, what factors should be considered? Why are these factors important? Provide some examples...
When evaluating research, what factors should be considered? Why are these factors important? Provide some examples to illustrate the importance of each factor.
What additional factors must be considered when evaluating international investment opportunities when compared to domestic ones?...
What additional factors must be considered when evaluating international investment opportunities when compared to domestic ones? In what ways is appraisal of investments with an international element more difficult for the financial manager to deal with than domestic investments with no international implications? How is such an appraisal complicated by it being a joint venture or one in which there is a minority interest? (600 WORDS)
Please DISCUSS the factors should be considered when EVALUATING A LOAN. (ANY FOUR)
Please DISCUSS the factors should be considered when EVALUATING A LOAN. (ANY FOUR)
What factors should be considered when investigating variances?
What factors should be considered when investigating variances?
Perform an internet search and answer the following question: What factors should be considered when determining...
Perform an internet search and answer the following question: What factors should be considered when determining whether to classify someone as an employee or as an independent contractor? What is the “economic reality” test? Would you prefer to be classified as an employee or as an independent contractor? Explain your choice.
In your opinion, what are some of the important factors or current trends that could shape...
In your opinion, what are some of the important factors or current trends that could shape the future of currencies? (about 250 words)
What factors need to be considered to determine markdowns? What issues could possibly arise if a...
What factors need to be considered to determine markdowns? What issues could possibly arise if a partnering store doesn’t sell through the collaboration product or is not selling through the product as well as expected? Who should dictate when markdowns are taken, the parent company or the partnership retailer?
What factors might be considered when creating a tax that is considered fair by most people...
What factors might be considered when creating a tax that is considered fair by most people in a society? (LO3.1) What are the ethical implications of not paying your fair share of taxes? (LO3.1) What are some advantages of electronic filing? (LO3.3)
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT