In: Accounting
Tom can choose when he is to receive $100,000 of fully taxable bonus. If he receives the bonus at the end of 2016, his bonus will be $100,000. If he postpones receipt of the bonus until the end of 2017, the amount will be $110,000. If Tom receives the bonus at the end of 2016, he can invest the proceeds with a pre-tax return of 10% over the next year.
If the marginal tax rate of Tom is 31% in 2016 and 2017, when should he elect to receive the bonus?
At what pre-tax rate of return will Tom be indifferent to receiving the bonus in the alternative years?
If the marginal tax rate of Tom increases to 35% in 2017, when should he elect to receive the bonus?
What would the tax rate need to be in 2017 to make Tom indifferent to the two options?
1. To decide when to receive bonus
Particulars | 2016 | 2017 |
Bonus received | 100,000 | 110,000 |
Less: Tax @ 31% | 31,000 | 34,100 |
Post tax amount received (A) | 69,000 | 75,900 |
Proceeds of 2016 reinvested @10% | 6,900 | 0 |
Tax on amount reinvested @ 31% | 2,139 | 0 |
Post tax amount received from reinvestment (B) | 4,761 | 0 |
Total cash receipts (A+B) | 73,761 | 75,900 |
Tom should elect to receive bonus in 2017
2.Pre-tax rate of return
Amount of bonus received if elected to received in 2017 = 75,900
Amount of bonus received if elected to received in 2016 = 69,000
Difference in amount = 6,900
Amount of bonus to be reinvested to earn post tax return of 6,900 = 69,000
Post tax return rate = 6,900/69,000*100 = 10%
Pre tax return - 31%* Pre tax return = 6,900
Pre tax retuen = 10,000
Pre tax return rate = 10,000/69,000*100= 14.49%
3. To decide when to receive bonus
Particulars | 2016 | 2017 |
Bonus received | 100,000 | 110,000 |
Less: Tax @ 31% for 2016 and 35% for 2017 | 31,000 | 38,500 |
Post tax amount received (A) | 69,000 | 71,500 |
Proceeds of 2016 reinvested @10% | 6,900 | 0 |
Tax on amount reinvested @ 35% | 2,415 | 0 |
Post tax amount received from reinvestment (B) | 4,485 | 0 |
Total cash receipts (A+B) | 73,485 | 71,500 |
Tom should elect to receive bonus in 2016
4. Tax rate in 2017
Let tax rate be x%
69,000+(6,900 - x% *6,900) = 110,000- x% *110,000
x% *110,000 - x% *6,900 = 110,000-69,000-6,900
103,100 *x% = 34,100
x% =34,100/103,100
x=33.07%
tax rate in 2017 = 33.07%