The primary goals of the new lease accounting standards are to
provide greater transparency and comparability in financial
reporting and to require the liability associated with a lease be
recognized on the lessee’s balance sheet. This is in contrast to
today where only Capital and Finance Leases, representing only a
small portion of the universe of real estate leases, are required
to be recorded on the balance sheet.
For Finance Leases: Lessees must:
- recognize interest on the lease liability and amortization of
the right-of-use asset as separate line items on the income
statement, and
- classify repayments of the principal portion of the lease
liability within financing activities and payments of interest on
the lease liability within operating activities on the statement of
cash flows.
For Operating Leases: Lessees
must:
- recognize a single lease cost allocated over the lease term on,
generally, a straight-line basis, and
- classify all cash payments within operating activities on the
statement of cash flows.
For lessors, accounting practices remain largely unchanged.
Additionally, FASB 842 outlines changes to leveraged leases, and
sale-leaseback transactions.
The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and the
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), collectively the
“Boards”, will require all leases be recognized as a liability on
the balance sheet. § The IASB issued its new lease accounting
standard on January 13, 2016.
The FASB is expected to issue its new standard in February.
While very similar, there are key differences between the two
standards.
- The effective date for the IASB’s new standard is 2019, while
the effective dates for the FASB standard are 2019 for public
companies and 2020 for private companies.
- Leases of 12 months or less are excluded from the requirements
of the new standards (both IASB and FASB), as well as “low value”
leases (IASB only).
- The IASB requires all leases be classified as Finance
Leases.
- The FASB has a dual approach to lease classification with two
types of leases: Finance Leases and Operating Leases.
- Finance Leases, per the new standards, are accounted for in the
same manner as today’s Capital and Finance Leases and have a
front-end loaded expense pattern.
- Operating Leases, per the new standard (FASB only), will have a
straight-line Rent Expense; the same as today’s Operating
Leases.
- Whether a Finance or an Operating Lease, it will be recorded on
the balance sheet as a Right-of-Use (ROU) asset and a lease
liability.
- The ROU asset and lease liability are generally determined
based upon the present value of the lease payments over the primary
term of the lease.
- Renewal options are only included in the determination of the
ROU asset and lease liability if they are “reasonably certain” of
being exercised.
- The liability associated with an Operating Lease (FASB only) is
NOT DEBT, while the liability of a Finance Lease is considered
debt.
- Compared to current lease accounting, the P&L impact of the
FASB’s new standard will be minimal, while the IASB standard will
result in the straight-line rent of today’s Operating Leases being
replaced with the front-end loaded expense pattern of Finance
Leases.