Which capital budgeting technique is better--NPV or IRR? Is the assumption of reinvestment of cash inflow...

Which capital budgeting technique is better--NPV or IRR? Is the assumption of reinvestment of cash inflow beneficial for NPV or IRR? Which technique is preferred in real practice and why? Feel free to expand on your answers

Solutions

Expert Solution

The capital budgeting technique which amongst NPV and IRR is better ,

NPV is better. NPV, discounts each cash flow separately. IRR needs to be compared to the discount rate to determine weather the IRR of the project is good or not. The NPV analysis does not require a discount rate. If the IRR > discount rate, then the project is feasible. NPV can also be sued for projects , where a project's discount rate is not known.

NPV does not have any reinvestment rates, the IRR does.The IRR has a reinvestment rate assumption that assumes that the company will reinvest cash inflows at the IRR's rate of return for the lifetime of the project.

It is beneficial for the IRR, which makes the bad projects look better and the better ones look great .

In the real world the NPV is preferred, NPV takes into account Time Value of Money. NPV gives priority to project profitability and it's risk factors. If there are two or more mutually exclusive projects, where we have to reject one of the projects in order to accept the other, then in that case too IRR is not effective.

jeff jeffy answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

1. What is the reinvestment rate assumption and how does it affect the NPV vs. IRR...

1. What is the reinvestment rate assumption and how does it affect the NPV vs. IRR conflicts? 2. What is the rationale behind the MIRR method? 3. Would the MIRR change if the required rate of return changed?

Compare and contrast NPV and IRR. Out of the six capital budgeting decision models which would...

Compare and contrast NPV and IRR. Out of the six capital budgeting decision models which would you choose to measure a potential project and why?

Which of the following is a reason that makes NPV a better approach to capital budgeting on a purely theoretical basis?

Which of the following is a reason that makes NPV a better approach to capital budgeting on a purely theoretical basis? A. Financial decision makers are inclined to higher rates of return. B. It measures the benefits relative to the amount invested. C. It measures the actual value created by an investment. D. Interest rates are expressed as annual rates of return.

In capital budgeting, the NPV method is preffered to other alternativessuch as PI or IRR. What...

In capital budgeting, the NPV method is preffered to other alternativessuch as PI or IRR. What is the justification? A. Financial management seeks to maximize firm's profit margin. B. Financial management seeks to maximize firm's market value. c. Financial management seeks to maximize firm's price earning ratio D. Financial management seeks to maximize firm's ROE

What are the pros and cons of the various capital budgeting decision methods (NPV, IRR, MIRR,...

What are the pros and cons of the various capital budgeting decision methods (NPV, IRR, MIRR, PB, DPB)? If you had to pick one method to use for all project valuation situations, which one would you pick, and why? Please explain your answer! I am trying to understand the concept.

Explain how to calculate the capital budgeting criterion (in excel) : NPV, IRR, MIRR, Payback, Discounted...

Explain how to calculate the capital budgeting criterion (in excel) : NPV, IRR, MIRR, Payback, Discounted Payback, Crossover Rate, and decide between mutually exclusive and/or independent projects

1)the major differences between the NPV and IRR method for capital budgeting analysis. Also, explain the...

1)the major differences between the NPV and IRR method for capital budgeting analysis. Also, explain the pros and cons of the IRR technique in the capital budgeting analysis. 2)What should be used as an appropriate discount rate for the project analysis of a division whose risk level is different from that of the company as a whole. Explain why.

Are the capital budgeting rules discussed in Chapter 5 (namely NPV, IRR, Payback Period and Profitability...

Are the capital budgeting rules discussed in Chapter 5 (namely NPV, IRR, Payback Period and Profitability Index) applicable to not-for-profit corporations? How should such entities make capital budgeting decisions? Defend your recommendation.

Three distinct capital budgeting tools are referred to including NPV, payback and IRR, but all three...

Three distinct capital budgeting tools are referred to including NPV, payback and IRR, but all three need to be used simultaneously as the advantages of one are disadvantages to the other. What are the advantages and disadvantages of each of the capital budgeting tools? Why would they all need to be used simultaneously?

why is the NPV a better method than using the IRR for project rankings? which would...

why is the NPV a better method than using the IRR for project rankings? which would you rather use? how can you apply the capital budgeting techniques to your purchase of a rental property?

Subjects