Question

In: Statistics and Probability

"Two measured variables make a study correlational." Unfortunately, this conflates (mistakenly treats as the same) the...

"Two measured variables make a study correlational."

Unfortunately, this conflates (mistakenly treats as the same) the types of claims we can make with the types of statistical tests we can use. We pick out statistical tests based on the levels of measurement in our data, and while the measured/manipulated distinction is important for interpretation (manipulated variables allow for stronger arguments for causality), this doesn't effect our choice of test.

To make this clear, first give me an example that uses two measured variables but isn't tested using a correlation (a different test is right choice).

Second, give me an example where two variables aren't both just measured (at least one is manipulated) and yet a correlation is the proper test.

Solutions

Expert Solution

"Two measured variables make a study correlational."- this happens due to mathematical coincidence, mostly we are interested to test the causation. Actually Causation always implies corelation but the reverse is not true.

Example 1. Let us assume the two measured variables are a. number of new car sold in each of last 30 years in USA and b. Numbers of divorces in each of last 30 years in USA. One can observe a very clear positive corelation between these two measured variables. But there is not direct causality. Most probabily both the variables are related to some other factors.

Example 2. Let us assume the measured variable is a. number of new car sold in each of last 30 years in USA and the manipulated variable is b. Average wage of IT employee in each of last 30 years in USA . One can observe a very clear positive corelation between these two variables. There is causal relationship though the average wage is a manipulated variable.


Related Solutions

Design a correlational study, you will need two variables with at least five sets of data....
Design a correlational study, you will need two variables with at least five sets of data. between these two variables: time spent playing video games and aggression. My question: Assume the study produces a correlation of .56 between the variables. Analyze three possible causal reasons for the relationship.
what value does a correlational analysis have in attempting to understand if two variables are causally...
what value does a correlational analysis have in attempting to understand if two variables are causally related? Use citations and references.
The same method is used for testing the same sample measured twice as for two independent...
The same method is used for testing the same sample measured twice as for two independent samples. a. True b. False
The electrical conductance of two aqueous acidic solutions of the same concentration was measured. The first...
The electrical conductance of two aqueous acidic solutions of the same concentration was measured. The first solution was observed to be a much better conductor than the second. Which statement is correct? A. The first solution is a stronger acid than the second. B. The first solution is a weaker electrolyte than the second. C. The pH is the same for both solutions. D. The second solution contains a solute that completely ionized when dissolved in water. I know A...
A sample of 31 people took a written driver’s license exam. Two variables were measured on...
A sample of 31 people took a written driver’s license exam. Two variables were measured on them: The result of the exam (0 = fail, 1 = pass), and how much time (in hours) the person studied for the exam. Using the data, fit an appropriate regression model to determine whether time spent studying is a useful predictor of the chance of passing the exam. Formally assess the overall fit of the model. Formally assess whether time spent studying is...
A data table contains two variables. One is the 30-year fixed mortgage rate; it is measured...
A data table contains two variables. One is the 30-year fixed mortgage rate; it is measured as the best rate offered by a mortgage broker over the last 90 days. The second variable holds a column of integers, 1-40, that identify different brokers. The 40 largest mortgage brokers are included in the data table. The data will be used to understand lending practices of all mortgage brokers in the U.S. Please choose the correct answer from the brackets for the...
A study was designed to investigate the effects of two​ variables, (1) a​ student's level of...
A study was designed to investigate the effects of two​ variables, (1) a​ student's level of mathematical anxiety and​ (2) teaching​ method, on a​ student's achievement in a mathematics course. Students who had a low level of mathematical anxiety were taught using the traditional expository method. These students obtained a mean score of 380 with a standard deviation of 50 on a standardized test. Assuming no information concerning the shape of the distribution is​ known, what percentage of the students...
10. Why does it make sense to study personality, even though correlations between measured personality and...
10. Why does it make sense to study personality, even though correlations between measured personality and behavior in specific situations are often quite low?
A) A sample of 13 observations collected in a regression study on two variables, x(independent variable)...
A) A sample of 13 observations collected in a regression study on two variables, x(independent variable) and y(dependent variable). The sample resulted in the following data. summation (x_i-xbar)2=14, summation (x_i-xbar)(y_i-ybar)=72,    xbar=3, ybar=10 Calculate the y-intercept (b_0) of the estimated regression equation. B) A sample of 9 observations collected in a regression study on two variables, x(independent variable) and y(dependent variable). The sample resulted in the following data. summation (x_i-xbar)2=14, summation (x_i-xbar)(y_i-ybar)=79,    xbar=3, ybar=10 Calculate the slope of the estimated regression equation.
CASE STUDY 2: Correlation and Regression are investigating the relationship between two continuous variables such as...
CASE STUDY 2: Correlation and Regression are investigating the relationship between two continuous variables such as height and weight, time and speed or the concentration of an injected drug and heart rate. a) In your opinion, discuss the importance of Correlation and Regression as a tools for analysis purposes. b) Find any correlation and regression that have been applied in business from the online platform. From the data you required to: i. State the Independent and Dependent Variable ii. Draw...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT