Mrs. Jansen is a Roman Catholic Christian 58-year-old schoolteacher. Six weeks ago, she suffered a stroke...

Mrs. Jansen is a Roman Catholic Christian 58-year-old schoolteacher. Six weeks ago, she suffered a stroke that left her with severe deficits. Her doctor told her family that due to her injury, she will be unable to walk on her own, feed herself, or be independent from full assistance for the remainder of her life. She remains in the hospital and has not communicated with her family in any way since the stroke. She is breathing on her own but will most likely experience unpredictable bouts of respiratory distress for the rest of her life, requiring future mechanical ventilation. She is receiving nutrients through a feeding tube, which was surgically inserted in her stomach.

Her husband wants the doctor to remove the feeding tube and permit the effects of the stroke to take their natural course. He is sure that this is what his wife would want, especially considering the grim diagnosis. He knows this not only from what she has told him in the past but also because of her free and independent character. He believes that she would not want to live like this. The doctor is not comfortable removing the feeding tube because she believes it to be necessary to sustain life.

Questions to consider in the case study:

What can you find in the teaching of the Catholic Church to help inform the patient’s caregivers so that they can decide on a course of action?
Do you think the husband's request is reasonable? What do you think about the doctor's response? Can the feeding tube can be removed, and the sanctity of the patient's life still be recognized?
What course of action should be taken? If you were the husband how would you proceed?

Solutions

Expert Solution

1. Teaching of the Roman Catholic Church: Roman Catholic Church has always taught the absolute and unchanging value of the commandment - you shall not kill. Considers it a grave violation of the law of God, since it is leading to deliberately and morally unacceptable killing of a human being. Patient's caregivers should be informed about the unfortunate incident of Mrs. Jansen suffering a stroke which has left her with severe deficits, requirement of assisted living & full time care.

2. Husband's request : Under the circumstances husband"s request is reasonable as he knows / understands his wife better than anybody else. He is sure that this is what his wife would want, especially considering the grim diagnosis. He knows this not only from what she has told him in the past but also because of her free and independent character. He believes that she would not want to live like this.

Doctor's response is also appropriate. Rightly so, doctor is not comfortable removing the feeding tube because she believes it to be necessary to sustain life.

3. No the feeding tube cannot be removed & sanctity of life cannot be recognized here. Human life is sacred and is a gift from God which is to be respected & protected.

4. Course of action: Follow the Doctor's advice & treatment procedure until discharge from hospital. If I were the husband move her back to home after discharge from hospital. Arrange for a home nurse / care giver to initially take care of all her medical requirement & rehabilitation. As far as possible comfort her & provide all moral / emotional support in this difficult time to her.

gladiator answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Mrs. Johnson is a 70-year-old woman who had a stroke less than a year ago. Mrs....

Mrs. Johnson is a 70-year-old woman who had a stroke less than a year ago. Mrs. Johnson is alert and oriented. She feels the sensation to void but right-sided weakness prevents her from always being able to get to the bathroom in time. For this reason, she wears incontinence undergarments. Mrs. Johnson’s daughter, Amy stops by twice each day to check on her and prepare meals for her. There are times when Mrs. Johnson is incontinent and remains in a...

Patients Profile Name: Patient James Age: 58 years old Sex: Male Nationality: Filipino Religion: Roman Catholic...

Patients Profile Name: Patient James Age: 58 years old Sex: Male Nationality: Filipino Religion: Roman Catholic Address: Quezon City Marital Status: Single Chief Complaints: “Sumasakit and dibdib ko. Nawawala pero pabalikbalik. Mga anim na buwan na na ganito and nararamdaman ko” (“Pain on my chest” on and off for the past six months”.) Admitting Diagnosis: Angina Pectoris History of Present Illness Mr. James is a 58 year old insurance broker who seeks consultation to FUMC due to an episode...

Mrs. J is a 58 year old Appalachian woman visiting the community wellness clinic. Mrs. J...

Mrs. J is a 58 year old Appalachian woman visiting the community wellness clinic. Mrs. J identifies a desire to lose weight. She has a good family support system and health insurance. After completing her health history, you note she is morbidly obese, leads a sedentary lifestyle and frequently has joint pain in her knees. She treats her arthritis by wearing a copper bracelet and rubbing her knees with a solvent commonly used to lubricate metal...

A 55-year-old married woman, who experienced a stroke approximately four months ago. She experienced dysphasia and...

A 55-year-old married woman, who experienced a stroke approximately four months ago. She experienced dysphasia and was placed on a Level 2 Dysphagia Diet which allowed her to maintain an ideal body weight of 155 pounds until one month ago. She has experienced a slow, but steady weight loss for the past 4 weeks. The patient had a speech therapy assessment for swallow and was referred to you for a Level One Dysphagia Diet with thickened fluids. Her husband assists...

Mrs. S, a 63-year-old patient who suffered a myocardial infarction last year, is in the cardiac...

Mrs. S, a 63-year-old patient who suffered a myocardial infarction last year, is in the cardiac rehabilitation center for follow up after suffering from fatigue and shortness of breath; she complains of a “fluttering” feeling with her heartbeat and she has an occasional productive cough. Mrs. S normally does not struggle with nighttime urination, but for the past month, she has to get up to use the bathroom 2-3 times per night. She has gained 5 pounds in the past...

Scenario: You are working on the postoperative surgical unit and admitted Mrs. X, a 58-year-old client...

Scenario: You are working on the postoperative surgical unit and admitted Mrs. X, a 58-year-old client with a history of obesity, hypertension, hypothyroid and sleep apnea. Mrs. X who lives independently at home falls and sustains a fractured right hip. The client will have an open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) of the right hip this afternoon. Her preoperative weight was 190 pounds (86 kg), and she is 5 feet, 5 inches (165 cm) tall. CASE STUDY PROGRESS: On postoperative...

Scenario: You are working on the postoperative surgical unit and admitted Mrs. X, a 58-year-old client...

You are the primary care provider for Mrs. Z, a 70-year-old female patient who has suffered...

You are the primary care provider for Mrs. Z, a 70-year-old female patient who has suffered from chronic back pain for a number of years. You are well acquainted with this patient, and due to recent changes in prescription regulations you now see her once a month to renew her narcotic prescription. Three months ago Mrs. Z’s 17-year-old granddaughter moved in with her, after a fight with her mother. Z’s granddaughter was a straight-A student prior to a car accident...

M.T. is a 58-year-old white female with a history of chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML). She is...

M.T. is a 58-year-old white female with a history of chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML). She is receiving maintenance therapy with hydroxyurea, with a history of prior treatment with imatinib mesylate. She was recently visiting her sister for several days who has a new grandchild in the home. During her visit, she appeared to develop a viral infection, with a low grade fever and cough. Presently, she is experiencing malaise and reports both her feet have been feeling cold throughout the...

Jill Stevens is a 58 year old patient with type 1 diabetes mellitus. She was diagnosed...

Jill Stevens is a 58 year old patient with type 1 diabetes mellitus. She was diagnosed with diabetes in her 20s and has had difficulty controlling her blood sugar, particularly for the last 5 years due to issues with health insurance and other financial concerns, as well as lack of motivation. She currently presents with hypoalbuminemia, edema, and a distended abdomen. The physician diagnoses her with nephrotic syndrome. What is physiologically causing the stomach distention? What is the connection between...

Subjects