Question

In: Statistics and Probability

what is the difference between case control and cohort trial with examples for each trial?

what is the difference between case control and cohort trial with examples for each trial?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Case-control and cohort studies are observational studies that lie near the middle of the hierarchy of evidence. These types of studies, along with randomised controlled trials, constitute analytical studies

In case-control, one starts from the outcomes i.e. cases and bases/controls/referents (matched or not), and tries to study what the exposure was. Using the 'rare disease assumption', both odds ratio and relative risk can be used to study association between exposure and outcome. However, odds ratio is preferred because the prevalence of the disease outcome is already identified.

Cohort is when one already has determined the exposure in the study cohort and tries to study the association of exposure to disease outcome within that cohort in a retrospective manner.

Examples :

Case-control study

Demonstration of the link between tobacco smoking and lung cancer, by Richard Doll and Bradford Hill. They showed a statistically significant association in a large case–control study. Opponents argued for many years that this type of study cannot prove causation, but the eventual results of cohort studies confirmed the causal link which the case–control studies suggested, and it is now accepted that tobacco smoking is the cause of about 87% of all lung cancer mortality in the US.

Cohort study

Framingham Heart Study, which recruited over 5,209 male and female participants in 1948 from around the area of Framingham, MA. It has continued to serve as a source of data for cardiovascular risk factors.

A second cohort was recruited in 1971 and a third in 2002. The study has made important contributions to the understanding of heart health. The researchers are now looking into how genetic factors may affect cardiovascular risk.

P.S. (please upvote if you find the answer satisfactory)


Related Solutions

Descriptions of each major types of epidemiologic study: - randomized controlled trial, - cohort, - case-control...
Descriptions of each major types of epidemiologic study: - randomized controlled trial, - cohort, - case-control Strengths for 2 Strengths weaknesses 2 weaknesses
Discuss and distinguish between a 'case-control' and a 'cohort' study.
Discuss and distinguish between a 'case-control' and a 'cohort' study.
What is the primary difference between a randomized clinical trial and a prospective cohort study? a)...
What is the primary difference between a randomized clinical trial and a prospective cohort study? a) In a randomized clinical trial, patients choose their exposure b) In a randomized clinical trial, patients are randomly assigned to exposure groups c) In a prospective cohort study, investigators can never be blinded d) All of the above e) None of the above
What is a nested case control study? What is the difference between a nested case control...
What is a nested case control study? What is the difference between a nested case control study and a case control study?
What is the difference between statistical process control and randomized control trial?  How are the two approaches...
What is the difference between statistical process control and randomized control trial?  How are the two approaches similar?
What are your thoughts on the difference between control and inspiration? Provide examples of effective measures...
What are your thoughts on the difference between control and inspiration? Provide examples of effective measures you can use to control employee/team member. Discuss what works in holding people accountable and what is not effective.
Which study design is best to minimize confounders--cohort or case-control?
Which study design is best to minimize confounders--cohort or case-control?
What is the difference between fiscal and monetary policy? Give examples of each.
What is the difference between fiscal and monetary policy? Give examples of each.
What is the difference between functional and nonfunctional requirements and give examples of each?
What is the difference between functional and nonfunctional requirements and give examples of each?
Describe Observational study designs: cohort study and case-control study. Choose an example for each study type...
Describe Observational study designs: cohort study and case-control study. Choose an example for each study type and discuss the different statistical analysis used to interpret and analyze the results. Suggest a case-control study that you prefer to conduct and explain the statistical tests that you would use in your study.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT