Question

Why would it be insufficient to impose an estate tax without a gift tax?

Answer 1

Government imposes gift and estate taxes on transfers of wealth during an individual's life and at his or her death. At federal level, Internal Revenue Code governs gift and estate taxes, while individual state tax codes codify state estate tax laws.

Federal estate tax is set forth beginning in Section 2001 of Internal Revenue Code. Estate taxes are imposed at the time of the estate holder's death. A person's taxable estate consists of all property owned by estate holder at death, known as "gross estate," subtracting allowable deductions. Gross estate can include real estate, stocks, bonds, business interests, and personal property. If the estate holder left a surviving spouse, spouse's share of property will be deducted from the gross estate. Deductions will also be taken from gross estate for estate holder's funeral expenses, debts owed at time of death, & property devised to a tax-exempt charity.

Under the Economic Growth & Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001, a certain portion of the taxable estate is also exempt from estate taxes. The exemption amounts for 2006, 2007, and 2008 were $2 million. Accordingly, estates worth less than $2 million are not liable for any estate taxes. For larger estates, however, the value of the estate over $2 million is taxed at rates starting at 39% and rising to 47%. The estate tax is scheduled to phase out by year 2010, although it can be re-established in 2011 unless the repeal is made permanent.

The federal gift tax is set forth beginning in Section 2501 of the Internal Revenue Code. Gift taxes are imposed on money or property transferred gratuitously by a donor to another individual or non-charitable organization during the donor's life. Not all gifts are subject to the gift tax. Typically, it is not applied to gifts between spouses and gifts made to qualified charities. Additionally, the federal gift tax exclusion allows a donor to give up to a certain amount in gifts each year without paying gift taxes. In 2006, this annual exclusion was $12,000. It applies to each person to whom a gift is made. Thus, a donor may give any number of people up to $12,000 apiece without filing a gift tax return.

A number of states impose estate taxes, often called "inheritance taxes," on estates that are not large enough to owe federal estate taxes. Like federal estate taxes, property left to a surviving spouse or to a tax-exempt charity can be exempt from state estate taxes.

Recipients of an inter vivo gift or a decedent's estate are not liable for gift or estate taxes on that property. Additionally, since property received by gift or inheritance need not be included in income, a recipient is not required to pay income tax on the value of the gift or inheritance received.

Many individuals engage in estate planning before death in an effort to reduce or avoid substantial estate taxes. Most popular estate planning tool is the trust. Funds placed in a trust are not owned by the estate holder at death & are therefore not subject to the estate tax.