Question

In: Economics

Mindless in Seattle As unemployment soars, the City Council wants to tax job creation. By The...

Mindless in Seattle

As unemployment soars, the City Council wants to tax job creation.

By The Editorial Board

April 30, 2020 7:17 pm ET


The economy is on life support, but that isn’t stopping the Seattle City Council from trying to soak employers with a new tax on hiring. The wizards seem not to have heard that when you tax something you get less of it.

The proposal is a reprise of the council’s 2018 tax on each new hire that was repealed amid public opposition. The new proposal “is 10 times larger than the 2018 version, and it’s also in an economy that’s about 1,000 times worse,” says James Sido of the Downtown Seattle Association, which represents business and nonprofits.

Co-sponsors Kshama Sawant and Tammy Morales want to raise $500 million a year with a 1.3% payroll tax on most Seattle businesses with $7 million or more in payroll. The Seattle Chamber of Commerce says this would hit some 800 businesses. The minimum liability would be $91,000, but many companies would see a six-figure hike or more.

Businesses would be assessed based on the prior year’s payroll, but revenue has cratered this year amid the pandemic. Amazon will be fine, but businesses on the margin that have been forced to lay off or furlough employees may not bring them back if it means crossing that $7 million payroll threshold. The tax would discourage smaller companies from growing in Seattle.

Ms. Sawant blames corporate greed for lost jobs: “As long as capitalism is in existence, the billionaire class will extract its vengeance for whatever we can do as far as reforms.” Yes, trying to stay in business is now “vengeance.”

Most of the new tax revenue would go to public housing for those earning up to 100% of area median income, which was $85,562 in Seattle from 2014-2018, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. The tax would also pay for Green New Deal initiatives like converting homes from natural gas to electricity.

Councillors Sawant and Morales are pushing for a vote in mid-May, but support isn’t unanimous. One risk is that their fellow far-left councillors will pass a scaled-down version of the business tax and portray it as moderate.

The personal-finance website WalletHub reported this week that Seattle is the hardest hit city in the U.S., with unemployment rising 105.92% between January and March. Only a socialist would think now is the time to further punish job creation.

Economic Issue: Taxes Matter

Comment!

just comment for this situation

Solutions

Expert Solution

Key points from the case:

Seattle City Council is trying to soak employers with a new tax on hiring. Downtown Seattle Association member is thinking that currently economy is worst in situation.

Attempt is to raise $500 million a year with a 1.3% payroll tax on most Seattle businesses with $7 million or more in payroll. Revenue to go to fund public housing and energy consumption.

Experts believe that pandemic has led to job loss. Companies will not hire in Seatle to avoid this tax and also wont expand in Seatle.Unemployment is already very high Seattle.

In my opinion, other avenues of money collection can be found out. Taxing in current situation is not a good idea s costs iincrease will lead to higher prices and higher inflation.


Related Solutions

The City Council wants to gather input from residents about the recreational opportunities in the city....
The City Council wants to gather input from residents about the recreational opportunities in the city. Categorize each technique as simple random sample, stratified sample, systematic sample, cluster sample, or convenience sample. a) Get an alphabetical list of all residents and question every 250th resident on the list. b) Have 10 volunteers go downtown on Saturday afternoon and question people that they see. The volunteers may quit when they have questioned 25 people. c) Get an alphabetical list of all...
A city council wants to get a sense of whether people are getting rich running short-term...
A city council wants to get a sense of whether people are getting rich running short-term rentals in the city. You were given four choices regarding the  numerical summary of the short-term rental data for their city  that would be most informative for this purpose. Explain the advantages and disadvantages of each statistic. maximum - 90th percentile - range - interquartile range -
A city council has estimated that it has a surplus of $100 Million (M). The council...
A city council has estimated that it has a surplus of $100 Million (M). The council is exploring the following three projects, each of which costs $100 M. a. A bridge which takes five years to build, then yields $50M benefit per year for the next 10 years. The benefits are received at the end of each year. Assume that the costs are spread out evenly over the five years (i.e. year 1 to year 5) and are paid at...
The City of Chicago has to select a representative from the city council to go to...
The City of Chicago has to select a representative from the city council to go to an economic development conference. It will also select an alternate representative, in case there is a conflict or emergency that prevents the representative from attending. City policy says that these selections are to be made completely at random from the members of the city council. The council’s membership is made up of 7 Democrats and 5 Republicans. I'm interested in the political party affiliation...
City Council Transportation hearing on Congestion Pricing
City Council Transportation hearing on Congestion Pricing
A city budget transmittal memo to the city council included this statement: similar to the 2008...
A city budget transmittal memo to the city council included this statement: similar to the 2008 budget, our 2009 proposed expenditures exceed projected revenues in our levy controlled funds in order to invest cash reserves generated by sound fiscal management back into the community. How would you respond to that approach to budget development.
A struggling economy is not producing like a strong economy: there is less investment, less job creation, stagnant wages, perhaps increasing unemployment.
A struggling economy is not producing like a strong economy: there is less investment, less job creation, stagnant wages, perhaps increasing unemployment. For the government debt, the lower interest rates mean that the government does not have to pay out as much in interest payments to the holders of the debt. This means the debt is "cheaper" than the same debt at a higher interest rate. This might lead you to think that this means that it can be paid...
A city wants to partially finance a stadium using a 6% tax on alcohol purchased at...
A city wants to partially finance a stadium using a 6% tax on alcohol purchased at all restaurants in city. Describe the advantages and disadvantages of this plan in terms of vertical equity, horizontal equity, and the concept of a “sin tax”.
A city wants to partially finance a stadium using a 6% tax on alcohol purchased at...
A city wants to partially finance a stadium using a 6% tax on alcohol purchased at all restaurants in city. Describe the advantages and disadvantages of this plan in terms of vertical equity, horizontal equity, and the concept of a “sin tax”.
10. A city is experiencing over-exploitation of its grazing areas. The city council is looking for...
10. A city is experiencing over-exploitation of its grazing areas. The city council is looking for a consultancy organization that can suggest viable solutions. Your research team is bidding for this job, and you are responsible for the methodology section in the bidding document. Carefully explain what you would include in the methodology section. Your explanation must include the details of the method (or methods) you choose, the data that need to be collected, the assumptions or restrictions you may...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT