Theology Question: How does the fact that the Gospels are the product of a society that...

Theology Question:

How does the fact that the Gospels are the product of a society that transmitted most of its historical activities by means of oral transmission differ from your understanding of history? Does this diminish in any way your confidence in what you read? Explain your response.

Solutions

Expert Solution

What we understand as history has mostly come from written sources, such as books, diaries, notes, autobiographies, biographies, inscriptions and more. Gospels come from an oral tradition, meaning the they were transferred by reciting and memorizing- from one person to another, from one place to another, and from one time to another.

There is no denying that written methods have one big advantage- they are likely to remain the same. Not that the person copying a source (there were no printing press in those times) couldn't have changed some things here and there- based on their biases and understanding, but for the most part written sources remain the same- especially if we get the original manuscript. Seen from that perspective, it indeed seem to me that it would've been better if these were written sources rather than oral tradition. On the other hand, there are communities which have oral traditions and have been able to keep the exact same language and material- for examples Hindus in some parts of India. So, its not unheard of and Gospels are not an anomaly. Not to mention the subject is such that it lends to itself to many interpretations anyway, even if in written form.

So, I would summarize it by saying that while I personally would've preferred it slightly that these were written sources, it doesn't diminish my confidence in them by an appreciable margin.

Rahul Sunny answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Is the foundation of Paul’s theology Jewish or Christian? Does Paul base his theology on the...

Is the foundation of Paul’s theology Jewish or Christian? Does Paul base his theology on the God of the Old Testament, the work of Jesus Christ in the New Testament, or a mixture of both?

Why Matthew, Mark and Luke Gospels is it important, in fact critical, that we have divergent...

Why Matthew, Mark and Luke Gospels is it important, in fact critical, that we have divergent witnesses of the life of Jesus?

Question: 1. What is the free rider problem and how does society can overcome the free...

Question: 1. What is the free rider problem and how does society can overcome the free rider problem? Give at least two examples. 2. What is the difference between private and social cost? Provide an example and explain in details. 3. Give an example and explain in detail the differences between social and private benefits.

· How does marketing play a role in society? · How can marketing benefit society? What...

· How does marketing play a role in society? · How can marketing benefit society? What is socially responsible marketing? · Do you purchase brands or products because of their social mission or position on social marketing? If yes, what brand(s)? · Think about whether a socially responsible marketer uses target marketing. If they do, explain how; if not, why not?

"Music does not change a society; rather it reflects the society in which it exists." How...

"Music does not change a society; rather it reflects the society in which it exists." How do you feel about this statement? There are many people who would say that music can and does affect a society. Discuss which view point you believe and why you feel the way you do. Provide examples that will support your belief. In these writing assignments you will be graded on content, grammar, punctuation, sentence structure, mechanics, organization, and evidence or support.

Question