Question

In: Accounting

John, Lorna and Gabriel are shareholders and directors of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd, which makes...

John, Lorna and Gabriel are shareholders and directors of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd, which makes and sells pine furniture. The company has a total of 15,000 shares. John, the Managing Director, has 5,500 shares, Lorna (who is John's wife), the Secretary, has 2,500 shares. Gabriel, a mere Director, has 4,000 shares. The remaining 3000 shares are held in small amounts by 10 other members of the company. John runs the factory that produces the furniture. Lorna runs the front office and handles all administrative duties. Gabriel runs the sales department and is also in charge of marketing. Recently the company prepared a tender for a government department to supply a large number of desks, tables and chairs. The government accepted the tender and offered to enter into a contract with Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd. Gabriel was excited about the success of the tender and was very keen for the company to take on the contract. However, John and Lorna did not think it would be a good idea to accept the offer by the government department. Lorna organised a company meeting in order to vote on the pending offer. At the meeting, John and Lorna voted against the offer to supply desks to the government department. Gabriel voted to accept the offer. The other shareholders also voted to accept the offer by the government department. The resolution was passed by vote of the majority that the company would not accept the offer to provide desks, tables and chairs to the government department. Gabriel was very upset that such a valuable opportunity to increase the company’s profits was being “thrown away”. He vociferously objected to the outcome of the vote. Upon hearing his objection, John and Lorna passed a resolution to vote Gabriel off the board of Directors. He was quickly replaced by the company's accountant who holds 300 shares. A few days after the vote, John and Lorna formed a partnership which then contracted with the government department. The contract was exactly the same as the one offered to Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd and involved the suppling a large number of desks, tables and chairs. The operations of the partnership are conducted on the premises of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd. Also, the labour involved in making the desks, tables and chairs for the partnership is being done by the employees of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd. The directors of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd (John and Lorna and the Accountant) have also decided to reduce dividends to other shareholders and to increase the payments to the directors. Gabriel is understandably very upset with these developments. He has been organising with the other shareholders to try and find a legal solution to this situation. Upon learning that Gabriel was “making trouble”, John and Lorna called for meeting. The resolution at the meeting was to force Gabriel to sell his shares in the company. Gabriel refused to sell his shares and protested the resolution. However, the Directors of the company passed the resolution (with a majority of the votes) to compulsorily acquire Gabriel’s shares. Consider whether:

(a) John and Lorna have breached any of their duties as directors of the company.

(b) The company is able bring an action against John and Lorna.

(c) Any remedies available to Gabriel for the compulsory acquisition of his shares.

Solutions

Expert Solution


Related Solutions

John, Lorna and Gabriel are shareholders and directors of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd, which makes...
John, Lorna and Gabriel are shareholders and directors of Basically Nice Furniture Pty Ltd, which makes and sells pine furniture. The company has a total of 15,000 shares. John, the Managing Director, has 5,500 shares, Lorna (who is John's wife), the Secretary, has 2,500 shares. Gabriel, a mere Director, has 4,000 shares. The remaining 3000 shares are held in small amounts by 10 other members of the company. John runs the factory that produces the furniture. Lorna runs the front...
Lily and Morris are the directors and shareholders of Zap Graphics Pty Ltd. Recently, the company...
Lily and Morris are the directors and shareholders of Zap Graphics Pty Ltd. Recently, the company began to suffer cash flow problems and needed additional capital. Lily persuaded Rodney to invest $100,000 in Zap Graphics Pty Ltd. Lily and Morris held a directors’ meeting and decided to issue Rodney with two shares in the company. A general meeting of shareholders also appointed Rodney as a director of the company. The company’s financial position improved as a result of Rodney’s $100,000...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been having cash flow problems with respect to acquiring a third vehicle (with equipment) to expand their business. They approach Ali to invest in Flowers First Pty Ltd. Ali has offered to invest $100,000 into Flowers First Pty Ltd on the basis that he will be issued with 50 Ordinary shares in the company (equating to 20% of the Company). At a general meeting of...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been having cash flow problems with respect to acquiring a third vehicle (with equipment) to expand their business. They approach Ali to invest in Flowers First Pty Ltd. Ali has offered to invest $100,000 into Flowers First Pty Ltd on the basis that he will be issued with 50 Ordinary shares in the company (equating to 20% of the Company). At a general meeting of...
QUESTION 1 Mick, Mark and Mike are directors and shareholders of MMM Hotels Pty. Ltd. Mick,...
QUESTION 1 Mick, Mark and Mike are directors and shareholders of MMM Hotels Pty. Ltd. Mick, the founder of the company, owns 80% of the shares while Mark and Mike each own 10% of the shares in the company. Mick is also a single director and shareholder of CAT Construction Pty Ltd. Mick convinced the board of MMM Hotels that the company could improve its position by refurbishing and expanding one of its hotels. The expansion required Council approval and...
Ergonomics Furniture Pty Ltd (Ergonomics Furniture) is an Ergonomics Furniture manufacturer located in Sydney and has...
Ergonomics Furniture Pty Ltd (Ergonomics Furniture) is an Ergonomics Furniture manufacturer located in Sydney and has just installed the company’s first computer system. In preparing for your current audit, you have identified the following information: The system is a local area network (LAN). The file server and two PCs are located at Head Office in Sydney, with two other PCs located in Melbourne. Selma Taylor, the CEO, who is located at Head Office and three clerical staff, Scot Davis, who...
Ergonomics Furniture Pty Ltd (Ergonomics Furniture) is an Ergonomics Furniture manufacturer located in Sydney and has...
Ergonomics Furniture Pty Ltd (Ergonomics Furniture) is an Ergonomics Furniture manufacturer located in Sydney and has just installed the company’s first computer system. In preparing for your current audit, you have identified the following information: The system is a local area network (LAN). The file server and two PCs are located at Head Office in Sydney, with two other PCs located in Melbourne. Selma Taylor, the CEO, who is located at Head Office and three clerical staff, Scot Davis, who...
george green was apppointed by the board of directors of nature pty ltd to be the...
george green was apppointed by the board of directors of nature pty ltd to be the company's managing director. nature now arranges camping holiday. green arranged a $15000 supply contract on the company's behalf, with canvas tenis ltd. however nature now's constitution contains the following provision: clause 1 the managing diretor may take contracts upto $10000 but above that amount the board approval is required. greeen had not obtained the boards approval for this contract, later the board refused to...
Bill, Amy and Paul are the directors of Mind Your Mine Pty Ltd (“MYM”) which owns...
Bill, Amy and Paul are the directors of Mind Your Mine Pty Ltd (“MYM”) which owns a number of upmarket retreats in Australia. The retreats typically charge $2,000+ per person, per night. Business was going well, and the company was looking to expand. Bill’s niece owned vacant land near Mt Tambourine, Queensland. The niece was having financial difficulties after a marriage breakdown and was struggling to support her 5 children. Bill wanted to help his niece and thought her land...
Mr T and Mrs T are directors of P Pty Ltd which trades as “Fluffy Donuts...
Mr T and Mrs T are directors of P Pty Ltd which trades as “Fluffy Donuts of Manly”. Mrs T makes the donuts and serves in the shop while Mr T attends to financial matters. In fact Mrs T was attracted to Mr T before they were married because he was an accountant, and could, she believed, provide her with the financial guidance she lacked. The business operates from leased premises. The company owns certain stock and fittings valued at...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT