Question

In: Accounting

Question 5 (10 marks) Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty...

Question 5

Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Holly, one of the directors, believes she is not liable as she relied on a financial report prepared by the accounting intern that showed the financial situation of Tanked was good. Bob also believes he is not liable as he stood down from management some months earlier to assist his unwell wife. Richmond also believes he is not liable as he didn’t read the financial report from the Chief Financial Officer which showed Tanked was heading towards insolvency.

Advise Holly, Bob and Richmond as to what defences they might be able to raise to avoid liability for insolvent trading.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Question :

Advise Holly, Bob and Richmond as to what defences they might be able to raise to avoid liability for insolvent trading.

Answer :

As per Section 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a director has 4 potential defences to a civil liability claim:

1. The director had reasonable grounds to expect solvency;

2. The director expected solvency relying on the advice of a competent and reliable person responsible for providing adequate information as to solvency;

3. The director did not take part in the management of the company because of illness or other good reason;

4. The director took steps to stop the debts from being incurred.

The director has the onus of proving the defences.

In the present case Holly expected solvency relying on the financial statement prepared by accounting intern hence she falls under point no 2 above.

Bob stood down from management some months earlier to assist his unwell wife hence he also falls under point no-3 above.

However, reason cited by Richmond does not fall under any category.


Related Solutions

Question 5 (10 marks) Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty...
Question 5 Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Holly, one of the directors, believes she is not liable as she relied on a financial report prepared by the accounting intern that showed the financial situation of Tanked was good. Bob also believes he is not liable as he stood down from management some months earlier to assist his unwell wife. Richmond also...
Company Law ILAC Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of...
Company Law ILAC Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Holly, one of the directors, believes she is not liable as she relied on a financial report prepared by the accounting intern that showed the financial situation of Tanked was good. Bob also believes he is not liable as he stood down from management some months earlier to assist his unwell wife. Richmond...
Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of insolvent trading under...
Tanked Pty Ltd (Tanked) has four directors who have been found guilty of insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Holly, one of the directors, believes she is not liable as she relied on a financial report prepared by the accounting intern that showed the financial situation of Tanked was good. Bob also believes he is not liable as he stood down from management some months earlier to assist his unwell wife. Richmond also believes he...
Question 1 (10 marks) Computer Whiz Pty Ltd (Computer) has four directors. Charlie is one of...
Question 1 Computer Whiz Pty Ltd (Computer) has four directors. Charlie is one of the directors. Computer’s constitution provides that all transactions over $5,000 need to be approved by a majority of directors. Charlie enters into a contract for $7,000 with Simone to take photos to update the company website. Simone sends the bill to Computer who are refusing to pay on the basis they never authorised the contract. Advise Simone as to which statutory assumptions in the Corporations Act...
Question 1 [10 marks] The five directors of Fly-By-Night Pty Ltd (‘FBN’) decided that at their...
Question 1 [10 marks] The five directors of Fly-By-Night Pty Ltd (‘FBN’) decided that at their next board meeting they would discuss paying a dividend of 15 cents per share. As FBN’s accountant, you have previously identified a potential cash flow issue due to the company’s loss of a business contract with a key customer. FBN is presently able to cover this loss in revenue because of its positive net asset position. However, you think that cash flow problems will...
QUESTION 1 – Principles and Concepts (10 Marks) Renovations Pty Ltd (“RPL”) has been in the...
QUESTION 1 – Principles and Concepts Renovations Pty Ltd (“RPL”) has been in the business of home renovation for over 30 years. Following a downturn in the renovations market however, RPL sought out new sources of income. In 2012, RPL decided to purchase old run-down houses in the inner-city, renovate them and lease them out for very high rents. After some time, the directors of RPL decided that the company should again concentrate on its core business activity. Consequently, in...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been having cash flow problems with respect to acquiring a third vehicle (with equipment) to expand their business. They approach Ali to invest in Flowers First Pty Ltd. Ali has offered to invest $100,000 into Flowers First Pty Ltd on the basis that he will be issued with 50 Ordinary shares in the company (equating to 20% of the Company). At a general meeting of...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been...
Alisha and Diva are the directors and shareholders in Flowers First Pty Ltd. They have been having cash flow problems with respect to acquiring a third vehicle (with equipment) to expand their business. They approach Ali to invest in Flowers First Pty Ltd. Ali has offered to invest $100,000 into Flowers First Pty Ltd on the basis that he will be issued with 50 Ordinary shares in the company (equating to 20% of the Company). At a general meeting of...
XY Mine Pty Ltd has four directors: Archy, Bruce and two nominees of QLD Ltd, the...
XY Mine Pty Ltd has four directors: Archy, Bruce and two nominees of QLD Ltd, the company that owns the other 50% of the issued shares in XY Mines. In 2019, the mine operated by XY Mine was hit by severe flooding and ceased production for several months. The chief operating officer of XY Mine sent a report to its directors explaining that there were cash flow difficulties, that copper prices were dropping, and that the prospects of XY Mine...
XY Mine Pty Ltd has four directors:  Archy, Bruce and two nominees of QLD Ltd, the company...
XY Mine Pty Ltd has four directors:  Archy, Bruce and two nominees of QLD Ltd, the company that owns the other 50% of the issued shares in XY Mines.  ​ In 2019, the mine operated by XY Mine was hit by severe flooding and ceased production for several months. The chief operating officer of XY Mine sent a report to its directors explaining that there were cash flow difficulties, that copper prices were dropping, and that the prospects of XY Mine raising...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT