Judge Learned Hand, stated in the Helvering v. Gregory case, that: “Anyone may so arrange his...

Judge Learned Hand, stated in the Helvering v. Gregory case, that: “Anyone may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury, there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one’s taxes.” Do you agree with this quote? Do you believe there is a gray area between “tax planning” and “tax avoidance”?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Yes, I do agree with the quote as over and over again court have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging affairs so as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everyone does it rich and poor alike and all do right, nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands.

No, there is a gray area between tax planning and tax avoidance.

Reason :- Tax planning is described as the arrangement of financial activities in a way that the person can avail maximum tax benefits, i.e deductions, exemptions, etc.Tax planning is completely legal because it does not involve taking advantage of the loopholes in the law, and so it is permissible.

On the other hand tax avoidance is a technique of refraining from tax liability, it intends to defeat the fundamental motive of the legislature. Tax avoidance is as evil as evasion and even attracts penalty when discovered. Tax avoidance is accomplished with a malafide motives.

ekkarill92 answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Accounting: Public Sector Auditing Judge Learned Hand, in discussing "degree of care" in connection with the...

Accounting: Public Sector Auditing Judge Learned Hand, in discussing "degree of care" in connection with the standard by which a prudent person is to be held, said this: "The degree of care demanded of a person by an occasion is the result of three factors: the likelihood that his conduct will injure others, taken with the seriousness of the injury if it happens, and balanced against the interest which he must sacrifice to avoid the risk." Discuss how Judge Hand’s...

In the court case Harris v. McRae what did district court Judge Dooling mean when he...

In the court case Harris v. McRae what did district court Judge Dooling mean when he said that a woman’s decision to terminate her pregnancy because medically necessary to her health is an exercise of “the most fundamental of rights, nearly allied to her right to be.”? Does the denial of that right for poor women by the U.S. Supreme Court deny those women their “right to be”?

What happened in Powell v. Alabama? Why was this case so important? How does this case...

What happened in Powell v. Alabama? Why was this case so important? How does this case still impact us as a system?

Have anyone worked with case study Continental Carriers, Inc Problem info: In may 1988 Elizabeth thorp...

Have anyone worked with case study Continental Carriers, Inc Problem info: In may 1988 Elizabeth thorp treasurer of CCI was considering advantages and disadvantages of several alternative methods of financing CCI’s acquisition of Midland Freight Inc. At a recent meeting of the board of directors there had been substantial disagreement as to the best method of financing the acquisition. After the meeting Ms. Thorp was asked by John Evans president of CCI to assess the arguments presented by the various...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You can propose your own questions and then answer them. Remember, there is no absolutely correct answer to this exercise. Its purpose is to provide you an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to think like an economist by applying economic principles to interpret the logic of a real-world phenomenon. The Fortunes of Delta Airlines Follow the Business Cycle Delta Airlines has grown into the world’s...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You can propose your own questions and then answer them. Remember, there is no absolutely correct answer to this exercise. Its purpose is to provide you an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to think like an economist by applying economic principles to interpret the logic of a real-world phenomenon. Can Greece Function without Banks? In 2001, Greece and most other European countries abandoned their individual...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You can propose your own questions and then answer them. Remember, there is no absolutely correct answer to this exercise. Its purpose is to provide you an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to think like an economist by applying economic principles to interpret the logic of a real-world phenomenon. Why Is JPMorgan Chase Laying Off Workers? Many workers lost their jobs during the 2007–2009 recession...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You can propose your own questions and then answer them. Remember, there is no absolutely correct answer to this exercise. Its purpose is to provide you an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to think like an economist by applying economic principles to interpret the logic of a real-world phenomenon. Will Economic Reforms in Mexico Boost Economic Growth? More than 18,000 U.S. companies, including Fortune 500...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You...

Please use the economics knowledge you have learned so far to analyze the case below. You can propose your own questions and then answer them. Remember, there is no absolutely correct answer to this exercise. Its purpose is to provide you an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to think like an economist by applying economic principles to interpret the logic of a real-world phenomenon. Economic Growth and the Business Cycle at Corning, Inc. In 1851, Amory Houghton founded the company...

In his New York Times column of May 27, 2005, economist Paul Krugman stated: “After all,...

In his New York Times column of May 27, 2005, economist Paul Krugman stated: “After all, the Fed’s ability to manage the economy mainly comes from its ability to create booms and busts in the housing market.” What do you think he meant by that statement? Is it an accurate characterization of the Federal Reserve’s influence over the real economy?

Subjects