Question

In: Accounting

Nemo Seafood International Pty Ltd (“Nemo”) operates a seafood export and processing business. The directors of...

Nemo Seafood International Pty Ltd (“Nemo”) operates a seafood export and processing business. The directors of Nemo are Marlin and Dory. There are 2,500 issued shares in Nemo, the majority owned by Lake Harbour Pty Ltd, a company also owned and controlled by Marlin and Dory. The day-to-day operation and management of Nemo were undertaken by Marlin and Nemo’s operations manager, Nigel. Nigel is recommending that Nemo enter into a strategic alliance (merger) with its rival, Jacques Fish Markets (JFM). Under the terms of the merger: (a) Nemo is to issue Jacques, the owner of JFM, with 1,500 new shares, which will represent 3/8 (37.5%) of the total issued shares in the company. Jacques’ shares will carry superior rights with respect to voting, dividends and repayment of capital than the ordinary shares already held by Lake Harbour and the other shareholders. (b) In return, Jacques will transfer all of his shares in JFM to Nemo. (c) From its profit and loss account, JFM will pay a dividend to Nemo, but payable directly to Nemo’s shareholders.

Should the existing members of Nemo have any concerns with this proposal? Specifically, consider:

i) As Lake Harbour is the majority shareholder of Nemo, outline the extent to which it could influence the day-to-day management of Nemo.

ii) Is it legal for JSM to pay a dividend direct to Nemo’s shareholders?

iii) What power does Nemo have to issue new shares?

iv) Should members’ approval have been first obtained before the new shares in Nemo are issued to Jacques?

Solutions

Expert Solution

i)

Majority shareholder is a shareholder who possesses and controls the majority of a company's stock. Just those people who claim increasingly that 50 percent of an organization's offers can be a majority shareholder. By and large, a majority shareholder has more power than the majority of alternate shareholders joined. S/he additionally has the specialist to do things that different shareholders don't have, for example, supplanting a company's officers or governing body. Majority shareholder is usually found in privately owned businesses as opposed to open organizations.

In Crosby v. Shaft, 47 Ohio St. 3d 105 (Ohio 1989), the court held that "Majority shareholders have a guardian obligation to minority shareholders. A majority shareholder has a guardian obligation not to abuse his capacity by advancing his own advantages to the detriment of corporate interests." The court additionally saw that "Majority or controlling shareholders rupture the trustee obligation to minority shareholders when control of the nearby company is used to keep the minority from having an equivalent open door in the enterprise."

.

Be that as it may, the court in Smith v. N.C. Engine Speedway, Inc., 1997 NCBC 5 (NCBC 1997), saw that, "Shareholders, including majority shareholders, don't owe guardian commitments to different shareholders when offering their own stock in an enterprise. Shareholders have a privilege to control and vote their offers to their greatest advantage. They are constrained just by any guardian obligation owed to different investors. It isn't shocking that their thought processes might be for individual benefit, or dictated by impulse or fancy, insofar as they damage no obligation owed different shareholders. The proprietor of corporate stock may discard his offers as he sees fit. In offering their stock, investors essentially represent themselves and not as trustees for different investors.

Based on the above discussion, Lake harbour can change the board of directors and control the management through the board but can not interfere with the day to day management of Nemo.

ii)

From the above discussion, it is clear that the owners of the share can transfer their share to whoever they want. But paying dividends directly to the shareholders of another company is not legal, as it is the BOD which has to decide the amount, nature and payment of dividends and JSM being an outsider can not make such decision.

iii)

As Nemo can issue new shares through special resolution passed in the general meeting of the board of directors.

iv)

There is no need for the members' approval for issuing shares. It is the board of directors who can issue shares through resolution. If the constitution of the company allows that. If it doesnt then members approval becomes mandatory.


Related Solutions

Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton...
Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton van with a 3-ton van. Details of the respective vehicles are as follows: 2-ton truck Remaining life3 years Salvage Value now$4,000 Salvage Value in 3 years$0 Written down value now$6,600 Annual Depreciation for tax purposes$2,200 Annual net cash flows before tax$12,000 3-ton truck Estimated life4 years Salvage Value in 4 years$2,000 Annual Depreciation for tax purposes$6,000 Cost$24,000 Annual net cash flows before tax$20,000 The...
Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton...
Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton van with a 3-ton van. Details of the respective vehicles are as follows: 2-ton truck Remaining life3 years Salvage Value now$4,000 Salvage Value in 3 years$0 Written down value now$6,600 Annual Depreciation for tax purposes$2,200 Annual net cash flows before tax$12,000 3-ton truck Estimated life4 years Salvage Value in 4 years$2,000 Annual Depreciation for tax purposes$6,000 Cost$24,000 Annual net cash flows before tax$20,000 The...
Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton...
Speedy Pty Ltd operates a suburban delivery business. It is considering the replacement of a 2-ton van with a 3-ton van. Detail of the respective vehicles are as follows: 2-ton truck 3-ton truck Remaining life 3 years estimated life 4 year salvage value now $4,000 salvage value in 4 years $2,000 salvage value in 3 years $0 Annual depreciation for tax purposes $6,000 written down value now $7,600 Cost $24,000 Annual Depreciation for tax purposes $2,200 Annual net cash flows...
george green was apppointed by the board of directors of nature pty ltd to be the...
george green was apppointed by the board of directors of nature pty ltd to be the company's managing director. nature now arranges camping holiday. green arranged a $15000 supply contract on the company's behalf, with canvas tenis ltd. however nature now's constitution contains the following provision: clause 1 the managing diretor may take contracts upto $10000 but above that amount the board approval is required. greeen had not obtained the boards approval for this contract, later the board refused to...
Kestrel Pty Ltd (Kestrel) is a small family company which operates a business breeding kestrels, eagles,...
Kestrel Pty Ltd (Kestrel) is a small family company which operates a business breeding kestrels, eagles, falcons and other large birds of prey. Keenan, Chelsea and Campbell are all siblings and the only directors of Kestrel, and each owns 25 ordinary shares. Clause 15 of the constitution of Kestrel provides that Keenan, Chelsea and Campbell shall be directors of Kestrel at all times. Late last year Keenan fought with the rest of the family and now Chelsea and Campbell don’t...
1) Parramatta Scenic Cruises Pty Ltd (PSC) is a family-owned ferry business that operates on Sydney’s...
1) Parramatta Scenic Cruises Pty Ltd (PSC) is a family-owned ferry business that operates on Sydney’s Parramatta River. Jane Jetson founded the company when she arrived in Australia and remains the Chief Executive Officer. Jane’s two children, Judy and Elroy, occupy key management roles in PSC. Judy Jetson is the Chief Financial Officer and Elroy Jetson is the tax accountant. PSC reported sales of $11 million for the 2017 financial year. 2) PSC is investigating a proposal to renew part...
Parramatta Scenic Cruises Pty Ltd (PSC) is a family-owned ferry business that operates on Sydney’s Parramatta...
Parramatta Scenic Cruises Pty Ltd (PSC) is a family-owned ferry business that operates on Sydney’s Parramatta River. Jane Jetson founded the company when she arrived in Australia and remains the Chief Executive Officer. Jane’s two children, Judy and Elroy, occupy key management roles in PSC. Judy Jetson is the Chief Financial Officer and Elroy Jetson is the tax accountant. PSC reported sales of $11 million for the 2017 financial year. 2) PSC is investigating a proposal to renew part of...
Kremlin Spirits Pty Ltd (Kremlin) operates a business from premises it owns in Brisbane importing premium...
Kremlin Spirits Pty Ltd (Kremlin) operates a business from premises it owns in Brisbane importing premium quality vodka. Its directors are Vasili and Svetlana (his niece). Kremlin has three shareholders: Vasili, Svetlana and Mikhail. Mikhail has lent considerable amounts of money to Kremlin over the years. Vasili controls the company’s business activities, while Svetlana does not concern herself with the day-to-day management of Kremlin’s business so that she does not really understand the business or its finances. Svetlana is currently...
Amy, James and Laura are the directors of Elite Editing Pty Ltd (“Elite”), a company that...
Amy, James and Laura are the directors of Elite Editing Pty Ltd (“Elite”), a company that provides online thesis editing for university students. The company is performing badly and Amy seeks the professional advice of Marie, a business advisor. Marie advises Amy that she has designed new software that can reduce overhead costs and help generate profit. Marie asks whether Amy and Elite would be interested in marketing and using this new software. Amy tells Marie that there is no...
Amy, James and Laura are the directors of Elite Editing Pty Ltd (“Elite”), a company that...
Amy, James and Laura are the directors of Elite Editing Pty Ltd (“Elite”), a company that provides online thesis editing for university students. The company is performing badly and Amy seeks the professional advice of Marie, a business advisor. Marie advises Amy that she has designed new software that can reduce overhead costs and help generate profit. Marie asks whether Amy and Elite would be interested in marketing and using this new software. Amy tells Marie that there is no...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT