Question

In: Accounting

The liquidator of Smollett Pty Ltd (Smollett) claims that Robert Earnst (RE) and a company he...

The liquidator of Smollett Pty Ltd (Smollett) claims that Robert Earnst (RE) and a company he controls, Earnst Engineering Pty Ltd (EE), were acting as shadow directors of Smollett from July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2019 when the company was placed into liquidation. The liquidator further alleges that the company was trading whilst insolvent during this entire period.

  1. Required: Explain the concept of a shadow director and how the liquidator would prove these claims against RE and EE.

Click or tap here to enter text.

  1. Required: Explain the concept of ‘trading whilst insolvent’ and how the liquidator would prove that the directors of the company had allowed the company to engage in this activity.

The liquidator of Smollett Pty Ltd (Smollett) claims that Robert Earnst (RE) and a company he controls, Earnst Engineering Pty Ltd (EE), were acting as shadow directors of Smollett from July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2019 when the company was placed into liquidation. The liquidator further alleges that the company was trading whilst insolvent during this entire period.

  1. Required: Explain the concept of a shadow director and how the liquidator would prove these claims against RE and EE.

Click or tap here to enter text.

  1. Required: Explain the concept of ‘trading whilst insolvent’ and how the liquidator would prove that the directors of the company had allowed the company to engage in this activity.

Solutions

Expert Solution

A. Company directors take on specific fiduciary, common law and statutory duties and responsibilities when they are appointed, and their status is registered at Companies House. If you are not officially a director, but provide advice and guidance to the board which is regularly acted upon, you could be viewed as a ‘shadow director.’ To establish that a defendant is a shadow director Millett J said it is necessary to allege and prove: who are the directors of the company, whether de facto or “de jure” [ie validly appointed]; that the defendant directed those directors how to act in relation to the company.

B. Trading whilst insolvent refers to when a company continues to trade despite the fact directors know the company has no future and has become insolvent. There are two ways of defining insolvency, either when a company can no longer keep up with day to day payments, or if liabilities on the balance sheet outweigh assets. The liquidator can prove this by verifying the below deatils of the directors

  • Taking money out of the company in order to fund personal luxuries such as cars or holidays.
  • Collecting an unreasonably high salary when the company cannot afford it.
  • Transferring assets from the insolvent company for free or for significantly less than valued in an attempt to exclude it from any future insolvency proceedings.
  • Paying creditors in preference to others.
  • Collecting deposits from clients, knowing that works won’t be completed.

Related Solutions

Q2. A liquidator was appointed after Rock Bottom Pty Ltd was declared insolvent on 1 July...
Q2. A liquidator was appointed after Rock Bottom Pty Ltd was declared insolvent on 1 July 2018. The company’s assets realised $14,250,000. This came from the sale of the secured land and buildings for $7,500,000 and other assets which were sold for $6,750,000. The creditors totalled $16,350,000, and were made up of the following amounts: Secured creditor $9,000,000, receiver’s costs when realising secured asset $150,000, liquidator’s expenses $600,000, unsecured trade payables $2,400,000, tax payable $1,050,000, local government rates $300,000, staff...
Advise Linkitin Pty Ltd on sources of finance Linkitin Pty Ltd is a new company with...
Advise Linkitin Pty Ltd on sources of finance Linkitin Pty Ltd is a new company with an interesting new service that shows great potential. However, the company needs more long-term finance to grow. Its founder, Chodar, is an expert in his area but he knows very little about business. He is currently the only shareholder of the company and has no family or friends that could provide further financing. You have been asked to explain sources of long-term financing. You...
Gold Pty Ltd is an Australian resident private company. All the shares in Gold Pty Ltd...
Gold Pty Ltd is an Australian resident private company. All the shares in Gold Pty Ltd are owned by Johnny Gold. During the year ended 30 June 2019 the following events occurred in relation to Gold Pty Ltd: 1 July 2018​Opening balance of franking account​$200,000 2 July 2018​Payment of dividend franked to 70%​$1,600,000 28 October 2018​Payment of income tax for Gold Pty Ltd​$600,000 26 November 2018​Receipt of dividend from another company ​franked to 80%​​$450,000 31 December 2018​Refund of income tax...
DumDum Pty Ltd is a successful IT company. You are the IT Manager of DumDum Pty...
DumDum Pty Ltd is a successful IT company. You are the IT Manager of DumDum Pty Ltd. How is your company addressing cybersecurity policies and procedures in such a scenario? Will you make it a part of your Integrated Safety Management (ISM) and Quality Assurance (QA) System? Describe what your cybersecurity response plan includes e.g. Initial action, Response, Media crisis, support vendors in such a case scenario. Cite your sources.
Neil is a director of HRM Pty Ltd (the ‘Company’), a concreting company. The company had...
Neil is a director of HRM Pty Ltd (the ‘Company’), a concreting company. The company had the following transactions during the year ended 30 June 2019. How are the transactions treated for income tax purposes by HRM Pty Ltd? You can assume in this question that the numbers exclude GST, unless otherwise stated. 1. HRM Pty Ltd borrowed $500,000 from the Bank on 15 April 2019. 30% of the funds were used for personal purposes by Neil and the balance...
Travel Australia Pty Ltd is a company that provides elite travel experiences in Australia.  Top 4wd Pty...
Travel Australia Pty Ltd is a company that provides elite travel experiences in Australia.  Top 4wd Pty Ltd has three directors: John, Chris and Michelle.  John has been appointed the managing director.  Michelle is appointed as an independent non-executive director.  Chris is a qualified chartered accountant, and the board refers to him for his accountancy skills.  The company maintained a good profit for the first three years of operation but has recently experienced an increase in cost, causing some financial strains on the company. Despite...
Bowens Pty Ltd is a building materials supplier in Victoria. Bowens Pty Ltd has an annual...
Bowens Pty Ltd is a building materials supplier in Victoria. Bowens Pty Ltd has an annual turnover of $24 million, and works under the accrual method of accounting. Bowens Pty Ltd purchases concrete mixer for $660 each from Builder’s Choice Pty Ltd, a company in Geelong with an annual turnover of around $21 million, and works under the accrual method of accounting. Bowens Pty Ltd plans to sell the concrete mixers at a 200% mark-up to its customers. In October...
Bowens Pty Ltd is a building materials supplier in Victoria. Bowens Pty Ltd has an annual...
Bowens Pty Ltd is a building materials supplier in Victoria. Bowens Pty Ltd has an annual turnover of $24 million, and works under the accrual method of accounting. Bowens Pty Ltd purchases concrete mixer for $660 each from Builder’s Choice Pty Ltd, a company in Geelong with an annual turnover of around $21 million, and works under the accrual method of accounting. Bowens Pty Ltd plans to sell the concrete mixers at a 200% mark-up to its customers. In October...
Alex is an employee at Big Country Producer Pty Ltd. He has negotiated the following remuneration...
Alex is an employee at Big Country Producer Pty Ltd. He has negotiated the following remuneration package: •        Cash salary of $200,000. •        On July 1, 2018 Alex was given a loan of $15,000 which he used to pay for an overseas holiday for her family. The loan is expected to be repaid over 3 years with an instalment of $5,000 due on June 30, 2019, 2020, and 2021. There is no interest charged on the loan. •        Payment of his health club...
CarSales Pty Ltd is a resident company that owns and operates a car dealership
CarSales Pty Ltd is a resident company that owns and operates a car dealership. During the year, the company has provided the use of a car to each of the following:a) Damon, a salesperson, receives the use of a Lexus;b) Damon’s wife Kylie, who does not work at the dealership, receives the use of a Citroen;c) Nigel, who the company will employ as an accountant as soon as he finishes his professional exams, is given the use of a Honda;d)...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT