Question

In: Nursing

Hilltop Memorial Hospital George Long went to the outpatient department of Hilltop Memorial Hospital (HMH), which...

Hilltop Memorial Hospital

George Long went to the outpatient department of Hilltop Memorial Hospital (HMH), which is an acute care general hospital in Windsor County for diagnosis and treatment of back pain. HMH is the safety-net hospital for uninsured, underinsured, and Medicaid patients in its region, and it relies heavily on its insured patients to subsidize its indigent care and its losses on Medicaid patients.

Long had been treated at HMH many times for his back pain and mental health conditions. As indicated by his medical record at HMH, Long had a history of mental health problems, including episodes of delusion.

On that particular day, Long was escorted to an examining room in HMH’s outpatient department and was instructed to wait for the nurse. A few minutes later, the nurse arrived to find Long running around the examining room in an agitated manner. The nurse was unable to calm him and immediately called for the doctor. The doctor and nurse held Long’s arms for about one minute until he became calm. After Long assured them that he could remain calm, the doctor completed examination of his back and instructed him to return in two weeks if he was still in pain.

One week later, Long went to the office of a private, nonprofit advocacy organization called Patient Rights of Windsor County (PRWC) to discuss his recent experience at HMH. Long told the president of PRWC that during his visit to HMH on April 6, 2013, the doctor and nurse at HMH had slapped him in the face and hit him in the stomach.

With the help of the president of PRWC, Long called the local newspaper and gave this same account to a reporter. The reporter took detailed notes of the conversation with Long and then called the CEO of HMH to hear her side of the story. However, the CEO replied that,

because of privacy laws, she could not comment or provide any information about any individual patient at HMH. The local newspaper published a story about Long’s allegations, including the details of his statement and the fact that HMH’s CEO had no comment. Long has not filed a complaint with the police or with any government agency about this alleged incident, nor has he filed any legal action against HMH or the individual healthcare professionals.

During the next few weeks, members of PRWC participated in a series of demonstrations on the public sidewalk in front of HMH. Many of the PRWC members carried signs which stated “Stop HMH from beating patients.” The local newspaper published three stories about those demonstrations, in which the newspaper repeated Long’s allegations and HMH’s refusal to comment.

In the three months since the first newspaper report about Long’s allegations, HMH has experienced a severe drop in visits by patients who have coverage through commercial health insurance or employer-based health plans. HMH has determined that it will be unable to pay all of its operating expenses if this situation continues for another six months. Meanwhile, Long has refused to discuss any type of settlement and refused to consent to the release of his medical record.

The board of trustees of HMH (“the board”) held an emergency meeting to discuss the situation and consider its options. After receiving an update from the management of HMH, members of the board suggested various alternatives. Board member A argued that HMH must continue its current position of refusing to make any comment or provide any information about an individual patient. In contrast, board member B took the position that Long gave up his privacy by giving the mass media information—albeit false information—about his treatment at HMH. Therefore, Long would have no right to complain if HMH were to set the record straight

by releasing medical record, which would show that he has a long history of delusional episodes. Board member C stated that only a stupid law would prevent HMH from defending itself and its staff under these circumstances, and disclosing a small amount of information about Long’s medical history would be a technical violation at most. Finally, board member D argued that ethical considerations require disclosing Long’s history of delusional episodes, because the potential harm to Long from his loss of privacy is vastly outweighed by the greater good of preserving the community’s safety net hospital, which is at serious risk of insolvency.

Discuss each of the Board Member’s options and whether each option would be appropriate. In your response, please be sure to state why or why not? Your response should be based on the topics/areas of law discussed in the lecture. There is no need to recite the facts or give history regarding any applicable law in your response. Be sure to cite the relevant law and apply the law to the facts of this particular case in your response. Your opinion is only relevant as it relates to the outcome of each Board Member’s proposed option.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer has been attached with the following document :-


Related Solutions

magine you are the director of Medical Imaging department in Northwest Memorial hospital and are tasked...
magine you are the director of Medical Imaging department in Northwest Memorial hospital and are tasked with presenting to the C-Suite about your department's operating budget. You need to describe the department priorities and capital investments priorities. Be sure to include the following in your presentation: 1. Explain how you would prioritize the capital investments. 2. What was your methodology in producing the budget and why? 3. What was your role as the director in producing the budget? The PowerPoint...
Long Memorial Hospital is deciding between purchasing one of two ventilator machines for its ICU. Machine...
Long Memorial Hospital is deciding between purchasing one of two ventilator machines for its ICU. Machine A costs $65,000. Its annual maintenance and repairs will amount to $5,000 for each of the first five years and $7,000 for each of the next ten years. After 15 years, the machine will be scrapped. Machine B costs $45,000, has the life expectancy of 10 years and will cost $5000 per year to maintain and repair. Using 8% discount rate on its investments,...
In the month of January, Memorial Hospital provided $270,000 in services. If the hospital has a...
In the month of January, Memorial Hospital provided $270,000 in services. If the hospital has a pattern of debt collections of 20% collected in the first month, 30% collected in the second month, 25% collected in the third month, 15% collected in the fourth month, 5% collected in the fifth month, and 5% written off as bad debt in the sixth month, at the end of March (3 months out), how much money will Memorial Hospital have collected?
How would you develop a S.M.A.R.T goals for a hospital which is memorial Sloane Kettering that...
How would you develop a S.M.A.R.T goals for a hospital which is memorial Sloane Kettering that wants to redesign their approach on transportation, for patients and families to and from the hospital, by May 2019? S.M.A.R.T stands for specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and time- bound. They want to make transportation free and accessible for their patients which includes flights, trains, hotel, trains and buses. How can the smart technique be used to redesign the approach?
For D.W. McMillan Memorial Hospital, a 49-bed community hospital located in Brewton, Alabama, implementing an EHR...
For D.W. McMillan Memorial Hospital, a 49-bed community hospital located in Brewton, Alabama, implementing an EHR was not without its hurdles. However, the organization successfully on boarded a new system and is attesting for MU stage 2 during this fiscal year. Following are several key strategies that contributed to the hospital’s successful EHR implementation. D.W. McMillan was an early adopter of EHR technology among smaller rural and critical access hospitals, starting implementation in October 2012. The hospital began the journey...
Imagine that you have been appointed the director of health at the Kaluyu Memorial Hospital in...
Imagine that you have been appointed the director of health at the Kaluyu Memorial Hospital in Nairobi, Kenya—a for-profit hospital. The facility is also a referral hospital and receives severe cases of accidents and chronicle and communicable diseases, and it houses an HIV/AIDS ward. As you settle into your position, you realize that the employees always act scared as they approach their superiors. Some of the employees deliver files and leave your office in a hurry. As you make your...
a. The medical records of infants delivered at Kaiser Memorial Hospital show that the infants' lengths...
a. The medical records of infants delivered at Kaiser Memorial Hospital show that the infants' lengths at birth (in inches) are normally distributed with a mean of 22 and a standard deviation of 2.2. Find the probability that an infant selected at random from among those delivered at the hospital measures the following. (Round your answers to four decimal places.) (a) more than 25 in. (b) less than 19 in. (c) between 20 and 24 in. (b) TKK Products manufactures...
Assignment for Unit 2 - Tulsa Memorial Hospital (SoonerCare) This is a group activity of three...
Assignment for Unit 2 - Tulsa Memorial Hospital (SoonerCare) This is a group activity of three or four students in a group. The group acts as members of the consulting firm advising DrWilson. The following case study contains the instructions and requirements for the deliverable. The group will work on the assignment together to create one collaborative deliverable, then each member will post the (same) assignment to their own dropbox with the same title indicating the group project. Tulsa Memorial...
Outpatient clinics are hospital clinics that have appointments for patients who visit the hospital without being...
Outpatient clinics are hospital clinics that have appointments for patients who visit the hospital without being admitted. At one particular clinic, it is known that the distribution of appointment times (in hours), X, is described by the cumulative distribution function FX(x) = k − e −x 2, x ≥ 0. (a) (Original phrasing) One particular patient must complete a 30 minute exercise program during their appointment. Show that the probability this patient’s appointment will then exceed one hour in total...
Outpatient clinics are hospital clinics that have appointments for patients who visit the hospital without being...
Outpatient clinics are hospital clinics that have appointments for patients who visit the hospital without being admitted. At one particular clinic, it is known that the distribution of appointment times (in hours), X, is described by the cumulative distribution function: ??(?) = k?2 (?2 + 1), 0 ≤ ? ≤ 2. a-   Find k such that FX(x) is a valid cdf b-   What is the probability, Pr(? > 1) c-   What is the probability, Pr (1/ 2 < X <...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT