Question

In: Economics

Looking at a the case study, "2010 Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill", one of the largest environmental...

Looking at a the case study, "2010 Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill", one of the largest environmental disasters in history, scrutinize and discuss any aspect of the case, including the technical, legal, environmental, or ethical details. However, include some explicit discussion of the decision of the engineers overseeing operations on the Deepwater Horizon. To what were these decisions an engineering failure? What aspects of the engineer’s code of ethics did they violate? What might they have done different to prevent such a disaster?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Ans:-

The numerous technical and operational breakdowns that contributed to the Deepwater Horizon oil rig explosion and spill from the Macondo well in the Gulf of Mexico suggest the lack of a suitable approach for managing the inherent risks, uncertainties, and dangers associated with deepwater drilling operations and a failure to learn from previous "near misses,".

Also Insufficient checks and balances for critical decisions impacting the schedule for "abandoning" the exploratory well -- or sealing it in transition to production -- and for considering well safety.It may not be possible to definitively establish which mechanisms caused the blowout and explosion, given the deaths of 11 witnesses on board, the loss of the oil rig and important records, and the difficulty in obtaining reliable forensics information from the Macondo well.

The numerous decisions that apparently contributed to the accident,beginning with continuing abandonment operations at the Macondo site despite several tests that indicated that the cement put in place after the installation of a long-string production casing was not an effective barrier to prevent gases from entering the well. The decision to accept the test results as satisfactory without review by adequately trained shore-based engineering or management personnel suggests a lack of discipline and clearly defined responsibilities. In addition, several clear failures in monitoring of the well appear to have contributed to its blowout; available data show hydrocarbons entered the well undetected for almost an hour before the first explosion. Timely and aggressive action to control the well was not taken, and for unknown reasons, hydrocarbons were funneled through equipment that vented them directly above the rig floor rather than overboard. These conditions made ignition "most likely," the report says. Finally, the blowout preventer did not seal the well once activated.

Of particular concern is the lack of a systems approach to integrate the multiple factors impacting well safety, to monitor the overall margins of safety, and to assess various decisions from a well integrity and safety perspective.previous loss of hydrocarbon circulation in the Macondo well more than a month before the accident presented an opportunity to take actions to mitigate future risks.

Several questionable decisions also were made about the cementing process prior to the accident, including attempting to cement across multiple hydrocarbon and brine zones in the deepest part of the well in a single operational step, making a hydraulic fracture in a low-pressure zone more likely; using a long-string production casing instead of a liner over the uncased section of the well; and deciding that only six centralizers were needed to ensure an even spacing between the formation rock and the casing, even though modeling results suggested that more centralizers would have been necessary. The type and volume of cement used to prepare for well abandonment and the time provided for the cement to cure may also have impacted the well's integrity.Data on maintenance, testing, operating procedures, and reliability of alarms and other safety systems on the Deepwater Horizon rig will also be examined; testimony at other hearings indicate that various alarms and safety systems failed to operate as intended.


Related Solutions

The Deepwater Horizon oil spill (also referred to as the BP oil disaster) is an industrial...
The Deepwater Horizon oil spill (also referred to as the BP oil disaster) is an industrial disaster that began on 20 April 2010, in the Gulf of Mexico on the BP-operated Macondo Prospect, considered to be the largest marine oil spill in the history of the petroleum industry. The U.S. government estimated the total discharge at 4.9 million barrels. How do you expect BP to account for this disaster in its 2010 financial statements?
Shortly after the major oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico that occurred in April 2010...
Shortly after the major oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico that occurred in April 2010 due to an explosion on an oil rig, a Rasmussan Poll found that 23% of respondents were against offshore drilling for oil. In an effect to confirm these results, and environment group randomly selected 200 adults and asked them their opinions about offshore drilling. A. What is the probability that 40 or more people from this sample are against offshore drilling oil? B. What...
Case Study-1 LUKOIL is the largest oil company in Russia. The company is also the second...
Case Study-1 LUKOIL is the largest oil company in Russia. The company is also the second biggest owner of proven resources in the globe. The company was found in Moscow, Russia, the year 1991. As of 2019, LUKOIL produced 102.65 tons of oil. Currently, LUKOIL accounts for more than 19% of the total production of crude oil in Russia with its profits being USD 192 billion as of 2019. This report is aimed at discussing the trade strategies of LUKOIL...
A historically devastating environmental event occurred in 2010. System failures in a British Petroleum (BP) oil...
A historically devastating environmental event occurred in 2010. System failures in a British Petroleum (BP) oil platform in the Gulf of Mexico led to the release of significant amounts of oil into the Gulf of Mexico. The explosion of the Deepwater Horizon platform seems to be caused by faulty engineering. The spill was one of the worst environmental disasters in North American history. Eleven people were killed and it took almost three months to stop the oil flow. Discuss how...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic fluctuations in the U.S. economy since 1970 have originated in the oil fields of the Middle East. Crude oil is a key input into the production of many goods and services, and much of the world’s oil comes from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and other Middle Eastern countries. When some event (usually political in origin) reduces the supply of crude oil flowing from this region,...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic fluctuations in the U.S. economy since 1970 have originated in the oil fields of the Middle East. Crude oil is a key input into the production of many goods and services, and much of the world’s oil comes from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and other Middle Eastern countries. When some event (usually political in origin) reduces the supply of crude oil flowing from this region,...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic fluctuations in the U.S. economy since 1970 have originated in the oil fields of the Middle East. Crude oil is a key input into the production of many goods and services, and much of the world’s oil comes from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and other Middle Eastern countries. When some event (usually political in origin) reduces the supply of crude oil flowing from this region,...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic...
Using the Case Study below, answer the following questions Case Study Some of the largest economic fluctuations in the U.S. economy since 1970 have originated in the oil fields of the Middle East. Crude oil is a key input into the production of many goods and services, and much of the world’s oil comes from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and other Middle Eastern countries. When some event (usually political in origin) reduces the supply of crude oil flowing from this region,...
the employee in this case who originally cleaned the culture spill reported having diarrhea for one...
the employee in this case who originally cleaned the culture spill reported having diarrhea for one day but taking no time off from work. What is the importance of this facr?
Case Study on Managing an Investment Portfolio As a recently hired CFA financial analyst for Horizon...
Case Study on Managing an Investment Portfolio As a recently hired CFA financial analyst for Horizon Investments you have been asked to make portfolio recommendation and setup an investment policy statement for three clients of the firm. 1) John Lambert has recently received his MBA and currently works for Oracle. He is 26 and recently married. He and hid wife have saved nearly $100,000 for a down payment on a home. He contributes 10% of his salary to a 401K...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT