Question

In: Statistics and Probability

The Kalamazoo Michigan Symphony once advertised a "Mozart for Minors" program with this statement: "Question: Which...

The Kalamazoo Michigan Symphony once advertised a "Mozart for Minors" program with this statement: "Question: Which students scored 51 points higher in verbal skills and 30 points higher in math? Answer: Students who had experience in music."

a) Is the following statement true or false: Does this mean that studying music causes a student to score higher in verbal skills and math? Please explain your answer. Your answer needs to include what possible causation is possible.

b) Draw a diagram that explains your answer. (Possible diagrams are causation, common response, or confounding). Be sure to label all variables in the diagram.

Solutions

Expert Solution

a)

The question was which student scored 51 points higher in verbal and 30 points higher in math and the given answer was students who had experience in music . This doesn't mean that studying music cause a student to score higher in verbal skill and math . There may be some relation between them but it doesn't say that studying music cause the other one there may be a third factor which influence or fluctuate both of the events . This is called lurking variable. This can be quality of school or economical status anything .So this can be said as Common response.

b)

This is a type of common response with association between the music study and higher score in verbal skill and math . Let ,

X = student to score higher in verbal skills and math.

Y = student that studying music .

Z = lurking variable

So there will be association between X and Y. Then causation between Z and Y , also between Z and X.

So diagram will be ,


Related Solutions

In this discussion question you will utilize financial statement analysis to interpret financial data. Once you...
In this discussion question you will utilize financial statement analysis to interpret financial data. Once you used the various financial statement analysis tools how would you analyze the results? What could you use as a benchmark to interpret your results? What benchmarks would be the most reliable and relevant? Why? If you wanted more information about your company, beyond the financial statements/annual reports themselves, where could you look outside of the company itself? What information would you want to know?...
Q1: Which of these is an accurate statement about the Phoenix Program in Vietnam? Group of...
Q1: Which of these is an accurate statement about the Phoenix Program in Vietnam? Group of answer choices It improved the security of strategic hamlets, though the cost in human lives was high It was compromised because the South Vietnamese commander in charge of it was a double agent It was fairly effective at targeting large numbers of enemy sympathizers, but had little strategic impact on the war It was carried out successfully by Dr. Manhattan Q2: What is historically...
In regards to this question about Digestion which statement would be true? Which of the following...
In regards to this question about Digestion which statement would be true? Which of the following statements is true regarding the digestion of a precipitate in its mother liquor? 1. A lengthy digestion is inadvisable because more impurities can become entrapped in the growing crystals. 2. An elevated temperature, during digestion, is used to impede the coagulation of a colloidal precipitate through increased kinetic energy of the solution. 3. Digestion promotes recrystallization of a precipitate, thereby increasing particle size and...
QUESTION 11 Which of the following is a statement of the principle of Hess's law? If...
QUESTION 11 Which of the following is a statement of the principle of Hess's law? If a reaction is carried out in a series of steps, the ΔH for the reaction will equal the product of the enthalpy changes for the individual steps - that is the multiplication of the enthalpy changes for the individual reactions you have manipulated. The ΔH for a process in the forward direction is equal to the ΔH for the process in the reverse direction....
QUESTION 1 Which of the following statement is CORRECT about normalisation? A database that is not...
QUESTION 1 Which of the following statement is CORRECT about normalisation? A database that is not in at least third normal form cannot be implemented with MySQL. A database that is only in first normal form would breach the CAP theorem. Normalisation ensures consistent formatting, for example, that all the phone numbers would have the same number of digits. All of the above. None of the above. 0.5 points    QUESTION 2 Complete the four blanks in the following SQL...
This exercise requires designing a program which solves the problem described in the problem statement below....
This exercise requires designing a program which solves the problem described in the problem statement below. Provide comments in your pseudo-code and Java program as necessary. Your solution must include these components: UML Class diagram Flowchart Pseudo-code Program Coded Program Output Problem Statement Design a class named Pet, which should have the following fields: name: The name field holds the name of a pet. type: The type field hold the type of animal that a pet is (for example, “dog”,...
With C code Write a switch statement (not a complete program) which prints an appropriate message...
With C code Write a switch statement (not a complete program) which prints an appropriate message for a letter code entered. Use the following messages: If L is entered, output the message "Lakers" If C is entered, output the message "Clippers" If W is entered, output the message "Warriors" If any other character is entered, output the message "invalid code" Make sure to handle the case where the user enters in a small letter. That is, a capital or small...
Question 4 Which of the following is an accurate statement about the effect of close substitutes?...
Question 4 Which of the following is an accurate statement about the effect of close substitutes? a. Goods with few close substitutes will usually have perfectly inelastic demands. b. Goods with few close substitutes will usually have perfectly elastic demands. c. Goods with many close substitutes will usually have elastic demands. d. Goods with many close substitutes will usually have inelastic demands.
Question 1. which of the of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?         (a) Volatile memory loses...
Question 1. which of the of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?         (a) Volatile memory loses all data when power is removed, but is easy to write to.         (b) DRAM needs to be accessed every few microseconds to refresh the charges, otherwise the information is lost.         (c) The storage of program usually requires nonvolatile memory.         (d) Each memory cell cost more in SRAM than DRAM.         (e) EPROM is electrically programmable but EEPROM is not electrically programmable....
Which of the following statements is not considered a "false" statement in economics? Question 8 options:...
Which of the following statements is not considered a "false" statement in economics? Question 8 options: When other things remain equal, buyers are expected to stock up (demand more) from the normal product that they expect its market prices will decline significantly in the soon future. Other things remain unchanged, the market demand curve for a particular product is expected to shift leftwards when the price of that product declines. Other things being equal, a shortage from Pepsi Cola is...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT