Question

In: Economics

In the "Tragedy of the Commons" one side of the argument says that the problem is...

In the "Tragedy of the Commons" one side of the argument says that the problem is that self-interest causes the competition for the resource to become predatory. Why?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:-

A commons is a resource—that is to say, it is something that has economic value to human beings; it has intrinsic properties that, in relationship to human needs and human understandings of the resource have value. But a commons is a resource that is unowned. As unowned, no one can claim exclusive use to the resource. No one can stop anyone from using the resource if they so choose; that´s the unowned part of it.

The "tragedy of the commons" argument predicts the overexploitation of resources held in common. There is a great deal of evidence to the contrary. The descriptive accuracy and predictive validity of six categories of assumptions of the argument are examined. These include individual motivations, characteristics of individuals, nature of institutional arrangements, interactions among users, the ability of users to create new arrangements, and the behavior of regulatory authorities. The tragedy of the commons argument is seriously incomplete. It needs to be replaced by a richer and more accurate framework.


Related Solutions

Tragedy of Commons and the Housing Bubble crash in 2008. Using the Tragedy of Commons as...
Tragedy of Commons and the Housing Bubble crash in 2008. Using the Tragedy of Commons as your reference, provide a brief and simplified 400-500 word description of what happened with the housing market and the Subprime mortgage fiasco.
In one paragraph, provide an explanation of this paper of “tragedy of the commons” for someone...
In one paragraph, provide an explanation of this paper of “tragedy of the commons” for someone who has never read it.
What is the “tragedy of the ecosystem commons (or services)”?
What is the “tragedy of the ecosystem commons (or services)”?
What is the tragedy of the commons? Give an example.
What is the tragedy of the commons? Give an example.
What is the tragedy of the commons? Give an example that is not in the book....
What is the tragedy of the commons? Give an example that is not in the book. Please include resources with your posting.
Overfishing is caused by the “Tragedy of the Commons.” Explain why.
Overfishing is caused by the “Tragedy of the Commons.” Explain why.
What is the tragedy-of-the-commons? Explain why (how) this occurs? How can this problem be remedied?
What is the tragedy-of-the-commons? Explain why (how) this occurs? How can this problem be remedied?
Choose a human-made, renewable resource which is subject to the Tragedy of the Commons.  Has the problem...
Choose a human-made, renewable resource which is subject to the Tragedy of the Commons.  Has the problem been solved?  If so, how?  If not, why not?  
Consider the article Tragedy of the Commons. Professor Hardin argues in favor of mutally agreed upon mutual coercion to avoid a tragedy of the commons.
Consider the article Tragedy of the Commons. Professor Hardin argues in favor of mutally agreed upon mutual coercion to avoid a tragedy of the commons. Americans are notoriously resistant to being coerced to do anything. Why does he think coercion is the way forward with respect to the commons? What does it have to do with bank robbers and taxes? How does it relate to private property and our inheritance laws?
Please explain the difference between "free-rider problem” and "tragedy of commons". Give an example for each...
Please explain the difference between "free-rider problem” and "tragedy of commons". Give an example for each one of them.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT