There are some politicians in the U.S. Congress that believe the Federal Reserve should be less...

There are some politicians in the U.S. Congress that believe the Federal Reserve should be less independent from the U.S. government. Some say this would be a disaster for the U.S. economy. Do you agree or not with those who seek to reduce central bank independence? Why? Explain your answer in a comprehensive way, providing any data available and making reference to studies available on this issue.

Expert Solution

Federal Reserve has been created to meet the mandates of stable inflation and high growth rate. Decisions of Fed are not affected by the political pressures. Fed works independently for meeting mandated objectives.
Scholars have noted that political influence over the working of Federal Reserve would have dire consequences for US economy. Political actions are incentivized and motivated by the popular measures. Political parties always seek to execute such policies that would help them to get reelected for congress.
Federal Reserve aims at stabilizing economy in long run while political representatives are concerned about short term objectives. There is strong incongruence between these two entities.
Fiscal deficit of government is rising over the years due to high expenditure on health and insurance. Government debt is rising and further, it may be possible that government starts pressuring Fed to issue new currency to fund the increasing debt of government. Thus, independence of Fed Reserve is precondition for stable economic system and sustained growth rate.

References:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/why-the-federal-reserve-needs-to-be-independent/

https://www.forbes.com/2009/12/01/grayson-paul-fed-independence-opinions-columnists-thomas-f-cooley.html#7b197b7227e4

Rahul Sunny answered 1 year ago

Do you believe that the Federal Reserve should be controlled by Congress?

Should the Federal Reserve Be Independent? While fiscal policy is voted on by Congress and can...

Should the Federal Reserve Be Independent? While fiscal policy is voted on by Congress and can easily get caught up in partisan political infighting, monetary policy is supposed to be immune to this type of politics. In fact, it is said that the Federal Reserve is independent. 1) Is the Federal Reserve independent? 2) Can it truly be? 3) Should it be? 4) Why is important or not important for the Fed and monetary policy to be independent? 5) Do...

The Federal Reserve is not responsible to the Public, the Congress or the President. They are...

The Federal Reserve is not responsible to the Public, the Congress or the President. They are not directly elected. How is that a legitimate control in a Democratic Republic, such as the USA?

The Federal Reserve was established in 1913 and is, therefore, a “creature of Congress.” The President...

The Federal Reserve was established in 1913 and is, therefore, a “creature of Congress.” The President of the United States nominates members of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, subject to confirmation by the Senate. However, the Federal Reserve is basically free to pursue monetary policy independent of Congress or the President. Should the Federal Reserve remain independent of the President and Congress or should the President and Congress control monetary policy? Why? (200 word minimum).

Some observers argue that the mandate of the Federal Reserve should be changed to prioritize the...

Some observers argue that the mandate of the Federal Reserve should be changed to prioritize the control of inflation over other goals. Research and discuss the arguments for and against inflation targeting like this. Look into the policies of a different central bank when it comes to balancing inflation control versus other goals and share with the group what you found out.

The Federal Reserve is on the path of increasing interest rates whereas the congress is passing...

The Federal Reserve is on the path of increasing interest rates whereas the congress is passing a tax cut bill. Using the IS-LM model for a large open economy, show the impact of these policies on output, interest rate, exchange rate and net exports. Does it matter whether the economy is at the full employment level or not?

Suppose that officials in Congress and the Federal Reserve become convinced that an economic recovery is...

Suppose that officials in Congress and the Federal Reserve become convinced that an economic recovery is occurring, in fact, there are fears that a strong recovery could lead to inflation. What can government do to prevent inflation? What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of these options? What policy would you recommend?

At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance...

At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the federal budget. Some politicians believe this is the fiscally responsible approach while others think it is better to allow the federal government the leeway to determine the budget based on the state of the economy. Some politicians worry about running a deficit as this will add to the federal debt. Most states in the US have balanced budgets. What are the arguments for...

Question: At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to...

Question: At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the... At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the federal budget. Some politicians believe this is the fiscally responsible approach while others think it is better to allow the federal government the leeway to determine the budget based on the state of the economy. Some politicians worry about running a deficit as this will...

Some people believe that U.S. companies should be given the choice of using either U.S. GAAP...

Some people believe that U.S. companies should be given the choice of using either U.S. GAAP or IFRS instead of mandating IFRS. Your thoughts!

Question