Question

Imagine that we could use brain simulator implants to achieve control over patients experiencing emotional difficulties. For example, we could treat depression, bipolar, schizophrenia, etc. without needing medication or counseling. What about the idea of implanting electrodes in the pleasure centers of newly born infants? If these electrodes could be used to soothe a crying baby, treat a mental disorder or to treat drug addictions in teenagers and adults, would there be any disadvantages? If so, what may they be? Would the disadvantage outweigh the advantages? Would you be willing to volunteer your own child or yourself for implantation?​

Answer 1

In my opinion, careful and ethical use of such electrodes would not lead to any disadvantages, especially if they are being used for soothing a crying baby or for the treatment of mental disorders and drug addictions. If we were analyse the effects of an electrode closely at the neural level, it would stimulate the neurons in a manner similar to which outside stimuli produce their effects. In fact, human consciousness and experiences are, at the core, the result of neurons firing in our brains. In that case, having an electrode do the same, especially to achieve a good end would be completely acceptable according to me. The disadvantages can result if the electrode has not been sufficiently developed as a reliable means of technology or is being used for any other reason that does not involve the benefit of the individual and society. If these issues were hypothetically taken care of, I would be willing to volunteer myself or my future child for such a program.