‘Mr & Mrs Jones operate a popular Hardware store in Katherine through a company called ‘Jones...

‘Mr & Mrs Jones operate a popular Hardware store in Katherine through a company called ‘Jones Hardware Pty Ltd’. Mrs Jones is a director of the company and Mr Jones is also a director and secretary of the company. Mrs Jones attends BNZ Bank which has been the company’s bank for the last 15 years. Mrs Jones completed a loan application to borrow $300,000 which states purpose the funds will be used for. In the application Mrs Jones advises that the funds will be used to expand their business into Western Australia and establish a new company. The shareholders and directors of the new company will be Mrs Jones and her friend. The relevant bank manager knows Mr & Mrs Jones well and has always met with them both. The bank manager is concerned with the loan applications however makes no further enquiries. The banker manager agrees with Mrs Jones to lend the money on the basis that the bank can take security over the company’s major asset being a building from which the company operates. Mrs Jones lends the monies to a new company in which she is a director and shareholder in with her best friend. Mrs Jones intention is to establish the new company with her best friend and then leave her husband. Mrs Jones obtains the loan and mortgage documents from the bank. She affixes the common seal of the company and her best friend signs as secretary. The bank advances the money. Mrs Jones lends the monies to the new company. The new company establishes a business in Western Australia and then commences the process of approaching the largest clients of Jones Hardware Pty Ltd. REQUIRED:

• Explain whether BNZ bank can enforce its mortgage over the building. Consider whether it can rely of the assumptions in s129 of the Corporations Act. and whether an exception to the assumption by way of s128(4) is applicable. Refer to case law to explain your conclusion. (Words 1,000

Briefly discuss whether Mrs Jones has breached any director duties in establishing the new company and approaching clients. (Words 500 (7.5 marks)

Solutions

Expert Solution

Question:

Explain whether BNZ bank can enforce its mortgage over the building. Consider whether it can rely of the assumptions in s129 of the Corporations Act. and whether an exception to the assumption by way of s128(4) is applicable. Refer to case law to explain your conclusion.

Any legal cases can be enumerated in 5 parts.

1. Facts of the Case: Mrs Jones completed a loan application to borrow $300,000 which states purpose the funds will be used for. In the application Mrs Jones advises that the funds will be used to expand their business into Western Australia and establish a new company. The shareholders and directors of the new company will be Mrs Jones and her friend. The relevant bank manager knows Mr & Mrs Jones well and has always met with them both. The bank manager is concerned with the loan applications however makes no further enquiries. The banker manager agrees with Mrs Jones to lend the money on the basis that the bank can take security over the company’s major asset being a building from which the company operates. Mrs Jones lends the monies to a new company in which she is a director and shareholder in with her best friend. Mrs Jones intention is to establish the new company with her best friend and then leave her husband. Mrs Jones obtains the loan and mortgage documents from the bank. She affixes the common seal of the company and her best friend signs as secretary. The bank advances the money. Mrs Jones lends the monies to the new company. The new company establishes a business in Western Australia and then commences the process of approaching the largest clients of Jones Hardware Pty Ltd.

2. Question Arise: In the aforesaid case , a legal question has arised, whether BNZ bank can enforce its mortgage over the building? Whether Bank Manager can go further for execution of mortgage agreement, based on the evidences available with the managers.

3. Relevant Laws: Each Country has its own law. In Australia Corporation Act has been enacted to deal with such type of situations.

Provisions of Section 128 of Corporation Act 2001

Proper performance of duties

128 (4) provides therein that "A person may assume that the officers and agents of the company properly perform their duties to the company.:

The Bank wants to take the plea that they can take assumption that Director of the Company has properly performed their duties to the Company and hence mortgage documents are to be enforced at once.

4. Relevant Case Laws: Purported dealings under s128(1) Soyfer v Earlmaze Pty Ltd (Hodgson CJ in Eq) “if it can be assumed (and cannot be denied by the company) that a company has duly executed a document, I do not think there is any separate question as to whether this was duly authorised.”

Further in other cases, law has established practice to decide in favour of Bankers and against the corporations.

5. Conclusion or Decision: Based on the evidences and law of the country, Bank can go for enforcing the mortgage documents and Company denial is not acceptable on any of the grounds.

Question: Briefly discuss whether Mrs Jones has breached any director duties in establishing the new company and approaching clients.

Ans.: The Directors of the company are in fiduciary reliationship with the company. They are supposed to work with honestly, reliability and competency for the development and growth of the company. There actions should only be in the best interest of the company. Any activities done by the directors which if affects the interest of the company or against the company, or the activities is causing financial losses to the company or affecting the performances of the company or are detrimental to the financial position or performance of the company, than these are unethical, illegal also. Mrs Jones has breached clearly the duties as director while establishing a new company, advancing the loan to that company and by approaching with the clients of existing company through new company for getting orders in new company. Its a clear case of breach of duties are punishable under the laws of the country. Owners believe on directors and based on such faith, directors manages their investment. its a case of breach of trust. She will be punished for all such offences.

ekkarill92 answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Mrs. Jones is seeking a divorce from Mr. Jones. Under the terms of her prenuptial agreement,...

Mrs. Jones is seeking a divorce from Mr. Jones. Under the terms of her prenuptial agreement, her settlement will be $100,000 if she can prove that Mr. Jones has had an affair, but $50,000 otherwise. Her lawyer, acting as her agent, can prove the affair only if he hires a private detective for $10,000, which will come out of the lawyer's fee. Mrs. Jones has the option of paying her lawyer a flat fee of $20,000 regardless of the outcome...

the Jones family household includes Mr. and Mrs. Jones, 4 children, 2 cats, and 3 dogs....

the Jones family household includes Mr. and Mrs. Jones, 4 children, 2 cats, and 3 dogs. Every dat at 6 P.M. there is a Jones family stroll. The rules for a Jones family stroll are: Exactly 5 things (people + dogs + cats) go on each stroll. Each stroll must include at least one parent and at least one pet. There can never be a dog and a cat on the same stroll unless both parents go. (a) How many...

This exercise begins with a visit to the hardware store. Browse through the racks of nails,...

This exercise begins with a visit to the hardware store. Browse through the racks of nails, screws, etc., and select at least thirty different objects. Try for variety and diversity in your selection. Go wild — they only cost a few pennies each, and you only need one of each. These objects represent members of at least thirty different species in the Kingdom Hardware--each object representing a different species. Your task is to organize your species into genera, families, etc.,...

with PHP Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent an...

with PHP Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent an invoice for an item sold at the store. An Invoice should include four pieces of information as instance variables — a part number (type String), a part description (type String), a quantity of the item being purchased (type int) and a price per item (double). Your class should have a constructor that initializes the four instance variables. Provide a set and a get method...

Mr. and Mrs. Jones, both over age 65, elect joint return status. They must file a...

Mr. and Mrs. Jones, both over age 65, elect joint return status. They must file a return for 2019 if their combined gross income equals or exceeds A. $1 B. $24,400 C. $25,700 D. $27,000

Invoice Class - Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent...

Invoice Class - Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent an invoice for an item sold at the store. An Invoice should include four pieces of information as instance variables—a part number (type String), a part description (type String), a quantity of the item being purchased (type int) and a price per item (double). Your class should have a constructor that initializes the four instance variables. If the quantity passed to the constructor is...

Invoice Class - Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent...

The Shell Hunter is a take-out food store at a popular beach resort. Samantha Jones, owner...

The Shell Hunter is a take-out food store at a popular beach resort. Samantha Jones, owner of the Shell Hunter, is deciding how much refrigerator space to devote to four different drinks. Pertinent data on these four drinks are as follows: Natural Cola Lemonade Punch Orange Juice Selling price per case $18.50 $20.75 $28.10 $39.30 Variable cost per case $14.75 $16.30 $20.50 $30.40 Cases sold per foot of shelf space per day 7 12 13 14 has a maximum front...

3.12 (Invoice Class) Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent...

3.12 (Invoice Class) Create a class called Invoice that a hardware store might use to represent an invoice for an item sold at the store. An Invoice should include four pieces of information as instance variables-a part number (type String), a part description (type String), a quantity of the item being purchased (type int) and a price per item (double). Your class should have a constructor that initializes the four instance variables. Provide a set and a get method for...

Bob and Carol Packer operate a successful outdoor wear store in Vermont called Northwoods Backpackers. They...

Bob and Carol Packer operate a successful outdoor wear store in Vermont called Northwoods Backpackers. They stock mostly cold-weather outdoor items such as hiking and backpacking clothes, gear, and accessories. They established an excellent reputation throughout New England for quality products and service. Eventually, Bob and Carol noticed that more and more of their sales were from customers who did not live in the immediate vicinity but were calling in orders on the telephone. As a result, the Packers decided...

Subjects