Question

In: Nursing

Mickey Mantle, Baseball Hall of Fame center fielder for the New York Yankees, received a liver...

Mickey Mantle, Baseball Hall of Fame center fielder for the New York Yankees, received a liver transplant in 1995 after a six-hour operation. It took only two days for the Baylor Medical Center’s transplant team to find an organ donor for the 63-year-old baseball hero when his own liver was failing due to cirrhosis and hepatitis. Mantle was a recovering alcoholic who also had a small cancerous growth that was not believed to be spreading or life-threatening.

There is usually a waiting period of about 130 days for a liver transplant in the United States. A spokesperson for the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) located in Richmond, Virginia, stated that there had been no favoritism in this case. She based her statement on the results of an audit conducted after the transplant took place. However, veteran transplant professionals were surprised at how quickly the transplant liver became available. Doctors estimated that due to Mantle’s medical problems, he had only a 60 percent chance for a three-year survival. Ordinarily, liver transplant patients have about a 78 percent three-year survival rate. There are only about 4,000 livers available each year, with 40,000 people waiting for a transplant of this organ. According to the director of the Southwest Organ Bank, Mantle was moved ahead of the others on the list due to a deteriorating medical condition. The surgery was uneventful, and Mantle’s liver and kidneys began functioning almost immediately. His recovery from the surgery was fast.

As in the case of the liver transplant for Mickey Mantle, should the system make allowances for “real heroes”? Why or why not?
Some ethicists argue that patients with alcohol-related end-stage liver disease (ARESLD) should not be considered for a liver transplant due to the poor results and limited long-term survival. Others argue that since alcoholism is a disease, these patients should be considered for a transplant. What is your opinion, and why

Solutions

Expert Solution

According to me, the system should make allowances for “real heroes”. This is because people love them, people admire them, people are emotionaly connected with their favorite heroes. One cannot deny the fact that every human life is equally important and no one hold the right to live on someone's death. But at the same time, it is also true that the life of a big celebrity or a national hero like Mickey Mantle who has done a lot for the people and for the country will be considered more important than the life of a homeless beggar.

Some ethicists argue that patients with alcohol-related end-stage liver disease (ARESLD) should not be considered for a liver transplant due to the poor results and limited long-term survival. Others argue that since alcoholism is a disease, these patients should be considered for a transplant. In my opinion, every human on the earth has the right to live. However, those people who actually care about the importance of life must be given preference when compared to those who take it lightly. In other words, a person with a problem of alcoholism knows that alcohol is bad for their health but still chooses it and gets trapped in ARESLD and then regrets. They could have easily avoided the situation if they had a little more value of life. On the other hand there are so many people in the world who don't have such bad habits and value their life more. They must be given preference during organ transplant decision making.


Related Solutions

Suppose the Baseball Hall of Fame in? uptown, New? York, has approached Stars Cardz Stars Cardz...
Suppose the Baseball Hall of Fame in? uptown, New? York, has approached Stars Cardz Stars Cardz with a special order. The Hall of Fame wishes to purchase 50,000 baseball card packs for a special promotional campaign and offers $0.44 per? pack, a total of $22,000. Star?Cardz?'s total production cost is $0.64 per? pack, as? follows Variable costs: Direct materials $0.15 Direct labor 0.05 Variable overhead 0.14 Fixed overhead 0.30 Total cost $0.64 Stars has enough excess capacity to handle the...
as in the case of the liver transplant for mickey mantle, should the system make allowance...
as in the case of the liver transplant for mickey mantle, should the system make allowance for "real heroes"? Why or why not
In the 1996 regular baseball season, the World Series Champion New York Yankees played 80 games...
In the 1996 regular baseball season, the World Series Champion New York Yankees played 80 games at home and 82 games away. They won 49 of their home games and 43 of the games played away. We can consider these games as samples from potentially large populations of games played at home and away. a. Combining all of the games played, what proportion did the Yankees win? b. Find the standard error needed for testing that the probability of winning...
25 New York Yankees players from the Major League Baseball, 2016 season, were asked about their...
25 New York Yankees players from the Major League Baseball, 2016 season, were asked about their salaries. They were further classified into pitchers and non-pitchers and the following data on their wages were obtained: 14 pitchers with sample mean = 8,592,211 and sample standard deviation = 8,869,873 11 non-pitchers with sample mean = 8,335,158 and sample standard deviation = 8,969,283 Assume that the population deviations are the same. to. Considering a significance level of 0.01, can it be concluded that...
Suppose that in New York, 55% of Yankees fans are Democrats, 29% are Independents, and 16%...
Suppose that in New York, 55% of Yankees fans are Democrats, 29% are Independents, and 16% are Republicans whereas 35% of non-Yankees fans are Democrats, 18% are Independents, and 46% are Republicans. 50% of New Yorkers are Yankees fans. What is the probability that a voter is an Independent, given that they are a Yankees fan?
Are the New York Yankees correct when they claim that revenue sharing simply rewards teams that...
Are the New York Yankees correct when they claim that revenue sharing simply rewards teams that do not try to win? (econ of sports)
Listed below are the 25 players on the opening-day roster of the 2016 New York Yankees...
Listed below are the 25 players on the opening-day roster of the 2016 New York Yankees Major League Baseball team, their salaries, and fielding positions. Player Position Salary (US$) C.C. Sabathia Starting Pitcher $ 25,000,000 Mark Teixeira First Base $ 23,125,000 Masahiro Tanaka Starting Pitcher $ 22,000,000 Jacoby Ellsbury Center Field $ 21,142,857 Alex Rodriguez Designated Hitter $ 21,000,000 Brian McCann Catcher $ 17,000,000 Carlos Beltran Right Field $ 15,000,000 Brett Gardner Left Field $ 13,500,000 Chase Headley Third Base...
Listed below are the 25 players on the opening-day roster of the 2016 New York Yankees...
Listed below are the 25 players on the opening-day roster of the 2016 New York Yankees Major League Baseball team, their salaries, and fielding positions. Player Position Salary (US$) C.C. Sabathia Starting Pitcher $ 25,000,000 Mark Teixeira First Base $ 23,125,000 Masahiro Tanaka Starting Pitcher $ 22,000,000 Jacoby Ellsbury Center Field $ 21,142,857 Alex Rodriguez Designated Hitter $ 21,000,000 Brian McCann Catcher $ 17,000,000 Carlos Beltran Right Field $ 15,000,000 Brett Gardner Left Field $ 13,500,000 Chase Headley Third Base...
What Can The Late George Steinbrenner and the New York Yankees Teach Us About Economies and...
What Can The Late George Steinbrenner and the New York Yankees Teach Us About Economies and Diseconomies of Scale? From 1972-1976 the Oakland A's and Cincinnati Reds won all five of baseball's World Series Championships. Despite this amazing success, only 5 of those players went on to the baseball Hall of Fame. These teams dominated baseball. That is a total of 660+ possible players with less than 1% of them making it to the Hall of Fame as part of...
(4) The main hall of Grand Central Station in New York City is approximately 210,000 square...
(4) The main hall of Grand Central Station in New York City is approximately 210,000 square feet. (a) Estimate how many people could stand with enough room to turn around in the main hall of the station if there were an emergency which required that the station be used to shelter people. (b) Explain how you came up with your estimate. (c) If there are 4 million people in Manhattan, NY, on a typical workday, estimate the percentage of them...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT