Question

In: Accounting

PTL Club –The Harbinger of Things to Come? The PTL scandal is a picture-perfect, suitable-for-framing example...

PTL Club –The Harbinger of Things to Come? The PTL scandal is a picture-perfect, suitable-for-framing example of how auditors with a modicum of skepticism and alertness could have been heroes instead of goats. PTL was an accident waiting to happen even before Tammy got the notion that heading to the mall was the perfect cure for her blues. Auditors who were concerned with doing more than the absolute bare minimum required by GAAS and GAAP could have exposed this fraud much earlier, saving innocent and gullible viewers tens of millions of dallors. Art Harris, "The Good Life at PTL: A Litany of Excess," The Wahsington Post, May 22, 1987, P.A1 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. Although audit reports should provide assurance to investors and creditors that financial information presented is free of material misstatements and in accordance with GAAP, should audit reports be used to solicit investments, credit, or sales in a manner similar to Jim Bakker’s? How can a CPA firm prevent such behaviour?

2 During the trial, Mary K. Cline, senior auditor for Deloitte, Haskins and Sells stated: “Well, we made a lot of judgments during the audit, and we were auditing the balance sheet as of May 31, and there was no reason in my judgment to look at this number after May 31.”6 a. Should the oversale of lifetime partnerships be classified as a subsequent event? b. Should Deloitte have evaluated the sales occurring after the balance sheet date of May 31, 1984? c. Should L&H have been aware of the sales limits on lifetime memberships? If so, what should they have done about it?

3. Why do you think audit firms are willing to accept high-risk clients?

4. What analytical and audit procedures could have led Deloitte and L&H to have more easily detected and reported PTL Club’s financial problems?

5. Why would a staff auditor want to be “part of the client’s team” and consent to questionable practices rather than being an “independent watchdog” and contest such practices?

6. How could the auditors have known and understood the PTL business better in order to audit more efficiently and effectively?

7. Is it the auditors’ responsibility to verify that the client meets tax-exempt status?

8. Did the preparation of checks violate the auditors’ Code of Ethics?

Please google the PTL club fraurd case. I can't load all the info here. total are 8 questions. please answer them all.

thank you so much.

Solutions

Expert Solution

ques 1:
Using the audit report on the financial statements is not restrained as long as the information given by it is not misleading. When they use the audit report in their financial statements and show it to their investors this makes them feel better of actually investing in the company because they see that the information is real and not misleading.

The way that a CPA firm can prevent behavior like this is by talking to the client and having a good relation with them, they should be informed not to misuse the auditing report. They can also prevent this by stating it in their engagement letter and saying that the report cannot be used for those purposes.

ques 2:
a.
Yes, the over sale of a lifetime partnership should be qualified as a subsequent because the audit report had the dates of Aug. 31, 1984 and Oct.24 1985.
b.
Yes, Deloitte should have evaluated the sales occurring after the balance sheet date because they admitted that over sale had occurred after the end of the year so it is their responsibility to report the subsequent events that happened.
c.
Yes, it is L&H responsibility to be aware of the sales limits on life time memberships, they should have effectively audited the company.

ques 3:
I think that audit firms are willing to accept high-risk when they know that the outcome will exceed the risk. When they know that they will be getting a good outcome they will go and take the risk.

ques 4:
They can use many analytical procedures but the best analytical procedure that they can use can be a vertical common size financial statement. The audit procedures that would have helped him detect red flags would be clear audit procedures.

ques 5:
A staff auditor would want to stay as the staff because they would not like to question their coworkers past audits. They would not want to be a watch dog because If they do find something they would not want to be the cause of conflict between the firm and the client.

ques 6:
PTL was a very unique business therefore the auditor in the engagement had to have knowledge in not-for-profit accounting. The auditor can spend more time with PTL and he can also hire a specialist that can help him understand the business.

ques 7:
The only tax tax issues that auditors should be responsible for would be tax expense, tax payable, and deferred taxes if they appear on the financial statements. In any other event tax issues can be treated in a different engagement.

ques 8:
Yes, there was a violation in the preparation of checks. Not signing the checks was a clear violation of ethics. The auditors should not have been acting as an employee of the organization and should not have been involved in activities like this.

Note:you can exp;and on answers on answers wherever you feel like


Related Solutions

20, This picture is an example of ____________ Elastic Collision Inelastic collision 21, This picture is...
20, This picture is an example of ____________ Elastic Collision Inelastic collision 21, This picture is an example of ____________ Elastic Collision Inelastic collision 22, The law of conservation of momentum states that the total momentum of all objects interacting with each other will ________________________ no matter of the nature of the forces between the object. increase decrease remain constant fluctuate 23, This is an example of what kind of collision? Elastic Inelastic 24, What is Newton's Law of Conservation...
What’s an example of a perfect positive and a perfect negative correlation.
What’s an example of a perfect positive and a perfect negative correlation.
Hardeep is considering the expansion of her picture-framing camera business to include the printing of oversize pictures from CDs
Hardeep is considering the expansion of her picture-framing camera business to include the printing of oversize pictures from CDs. She would need to lease equipment, at a cost of $249 per month. To process the pictures, she estimates that she would have supplies expenses of $7 per picture.Hardeep estimates that she can sell 60 pictures per month.(a) What price should she charge to break even?(b) Compute the break-even point in sales dollars.The picture frames should be sold for $nothing to...
All things radiate light as a blackbody, though some things are closer to being "perfect" blackbodies...
All things radiate light as a blackbody, though some things are closer to being "perfect" blackbodies than others. It turns out that light emission and light absorption depend on the same microscopic interactions, so the difference between a perfect blackbody and an imperfect blackbody has to do with light absorption. A perfect blackbody perfectly absorbs all light that falls on it (so it would appear pitch black). A piece of charcoal, for example, is very close to a perfect blackbody....
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of...
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of how each might impact an investment decision. 2. If markets are efficient, how is it possible that market bubbles and crashes occur?
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of...
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of how each might impact an investment decision. 2. If markets are efficient, how is it possible that market bubbles and crashes occur?
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of...
1. Describe three of the biases or types of framing and make up an example of how each might impact an investment decision. 2. If markets are efficient, how is it possible that market bubbles and crashes occur?
Suitable Example of Law of Variable Proportions in Economics.
What do you understand by Law of Variable Proportions in Economics? Explain with suitable example.
What is cost of production? Explain with suitable example.
What is cost of production? Explain with suitable example.
The Picture Perfect Camera Shop had the following transactions for the month of August 2019. Aug....
The Picture Perfect Camera Shop had the following transactions for the month of August 2019. Aug. 1 Purchased cameras for $3,700 plus a freight charge of $180 from the Mason Company, Invoice 532, dated July 29, net payable in 60 days. 6 Purchased color film for $485 from Digital Products, Invoice 989, dated August 4, net payable in 30 days. 10 Purchased camera cases for $935 from Raven Leathers, Invoice 668, dated August 8; terms are 2/10, n/30. 15 Returned...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT