In: Physics
uncertainties in millikan's experiment to determine planck's constant
In 1915, Millikan experimentally verified Einstein's
all-important photoelectric equation, and made the first direct
photoelectric determination of Planck's constant h. Einstein’s 1905
paper proposed the simple description of ‘light quanta,’ or
photons, and showed how they explained the photoelectric effect. By
assuming that light actually consisted of discrete energy packets,
Einstein proposed a linear relationship between the maximum energy
of electrons ejected from a surface, and the frequency of the
incident light. The slope of the line was Planck’s constant,
introduced 5 years earlier by Planck. Millikan was convinced that
the equation had to be wrong, because of the vast body of evidence
that had already shown that light was a wave. If Einstein was
correct, his equation for the photoelectric effect suggested a
completely different way to measure Planck's constant.
Millikan undertook a decade-long experimental program to test
Einstein's theory by careful measurement of the photoelectric
effect, and even devised techniques for scraping clean the metal
surfaces inside the vacuum tube needed for an uncontaminated
experiment.
“For all his efforts Millikan found what to him were disappointing
results: he confirmed Einstein's predictions in every detail,
measuring Planck's constant to within 0.5% by his method. But
Millikan was not convinced of Einstein's radical interpretation,
and as late as 1916 he wrote, ‘Einstein's photoelectric equation
cannot in my judgment be looked upon at present as resting upon any
sort of a satisfactory theoretical foundation,’ even though ‘it
actually represents very accurately the behavior’ of the
photoelectric effect. He received the Nobel Prize in part for this
discovery nonetheless