Question

In: Physics

This thought experiment is originally due to Sir Isaac Newton. We have a sphere of water...

This thought experiment is originally due to Sir Isaac Newton. We have a sphere of water floating freely in an opaque box in intergalactic space, held together by surface tension and not rotating with respect to the distant galaxies. Now we set the box and water to rotate about some axis and we notice that the sphere flattens into an oblate spheroid.

How does the water know it

Solutions

Expert Solution

Dear Nigel, Newton had to postulate an absolute space. In fact, he used his physics insights to support the idea of a "spirit" that is filling the space - a paradigm this greatest scientist and a devoted Christian was as passionate about as about physics itself. The absolute space determined geometry everywhere except that it didn't know about any preferred velocity; it only knew about preferred accelerations.

Inertial systems in classical physics

Newton's laws of physics were valid in inertial frames only. If the laws have the usual forms in one frame, one can show that they also have the same form in all frames that are moving by a constant speed in the same direction. But one can also show that the form of the laws changes if we switch to a different system that is accelerating or spinning because this system is not inertial.

The difference between inertial and non-inertial frames is surely a basic postulate of classical mechanics and it is one that is extremely well established by the experiments, too. Newton's bucket is one of the simple ways to show that rotating frames and non-rotating frames simply differ, so the hypothesis (assumed in between lines of your question) that there is a "complete democracy" between all frames, regardless of their rotation, is instantly falsified.

Special relativity

Similar "absolute structures" filling space and time survived in relativity as well, despite Einstein's original fascination with the so-called Mach's principle that de facto wanted to deny that the rotating bucket behaves differently than the non-rotating one. General relativity ultimately rejected Mach's principle even though one may see some individual effects - memories - predicted by general relativity that are similar to those discussed by Mach.

In special relativity, there exists a "metric tensor" in the whole spacetime that tells all the buckets - and all other objects - whether they're rotating (and accelerating) or not. If they're not rotating, the metric will be given by I chose the sign convention randomly. However, if one transforms this metric to a frame that is inertial - it is spinning or accelerating - the metric tensor will be transformed into a different one, namely a set of 10 non-constant functions.

General relativity

The very same thing is true in general relativity where the metric tensor becomes dynamical and may be curved by the presence of heavy objects. It is still true that the metric in non-rotating frames will be given by which is just a different way of writing the metric a few lines above. However, if one transforms this metric tensor to a spinning frame, one gets a different metric tensor. The deviation from the flat space metric may be interpreted as a "gravitational field". The equivalence principle guarantees that the effect of gravitational fields is indistinguishable from the effect of inertial forces resulting from spin or acceleration.

So the extra corrections in the metric tensor will know all about the centrifugal, centripetal, and Coriolis forces that are responsible for the modified shape of the water surface, among many other effects.

To summarize, the bucket - and all other objects - know how to behave and whether they're spinning because they interact with the metric tensor that fills the whole spacetime and that allows one to distinguish straight lines (or world lines) from the curved lines (or world lines) at any point. It's important to realize that the metric tensor, while it allows to distinguish accelerating (curved) lines from the non-accelerating (straight) lines, can't distinguish "moving objects" from "objects at rest". This is the principle of relativity underlying both Einstein's famous theories but in this general form, it was true already in Newton's mechanics - and realized by Galileo himself.


Related Solutions

In this assignment , we will explore the life of Isaac Newton, please listen to the...
In this assignment , we will explore the life of Isaac Newton, please listen to the radio show from the BBC and do a little research about Isaac Newton. Listen the first episode (Age of Ingenuity) of the following podcast show: Seven Ages of Science BBC Radio. (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0380wf8/episodes/downloads) You can also find this series from iTunes or any other podcast apps. This first episode (The Age of ingenuity) describes the age of Isaac Newton. (I highly recommend you listen to...
Thought Experiment: We have studied the open-closed resonator in air. Let’s turn our focus to other...
Thought Experiment: We have studied the open-closed resonator in air. Let’s turn our focus to other gases: helium (He) and sulfur hexafluoride (SF6). Helium is lighter than air. SF6 on the other hand is heavy, almost 5 time heavier than air. How would each gases speed of sound compare to that of air? Higher? Lower? The same? How do you expect the resonator to react in each gas?
Many have thought that if we don't have free will, then punishment and reward would not...
Many have thought that if we don't have free will, then punishment and reward would not make sense. Do you agree with this? Why or why not? Would be good to do away with punishment? Why or why not? (Consider: Punishment can be used for retribution, i.e., as giving a person their just deserts, but it can also be used as a deterrent. Reward can be used to recognize a person's accomplishment because they deserve it, but it can also...
We have all had supervisors that we thought could do a better job at managing their...
We have all had supervisors that we thought could do a better job at managing their staff and we also hope to be better managers than what we have experienced at certain places of employment. Discuss the following with your classmates and instructors. How should employees relate to supervisors who are inaccessible and who hoard information? What can employees do about this type of supervisor? What characteristics are present in an individual with leadership potential?
1. We have a hollow metallic sphere with charge -5.0 uC and radius 5.0 cm. We...
1. We have a hollow metallic sphere with charge -5.0 uC and radius 5.0 cm. We insert a +10uC charge at the center of the sphere through a hole in the surface. What charge now rests on the outer surface of the sphere? +5 uC +10 uC +15 uC -5 uC A free electron is in an electric field. With respect to the field, it experiences a force acting: Parallel Anti-parallel Perpendicular Along a constant potential line A parallel plate...
If we have two vectors v1 and v2, lie in x-y plane of the Bloch sphere,...
If we have two vectors v1 and v2, lie in x-y plane of the Bloch sphere, then what the angles of phi1 and phi2 should be? and please explain why, thanks.
1) In this experiment, we purified cyclohexene by distillation. Could we have used recrystallization instead to...
1) In this experiment, we purified cyclohexene by distillation. Could we have used recrystallization instead to purify? Explain. 2) At the end we stopped the distillation with some material left in the vial. Why is it considered unsafe to distill until dryness? please help!
In this experiment, we have claimed to measure the speed of sound in air. To do...
In this experiment, we have claimed to measure the speed of sound in air. To do this, we have used an audible frequency sweep. Why can we claim that the speed of sound will be the same over the bandwidth of the sweep? Is this assertion justified based on your results from experiment 2? Hint: Consider how sound (longitudinal pressure waves) propagate in a medium. (5 pts)
We have a project related with Peltier. We are trying to heat water by using almost...
We have a project related with Peltier. We are trying to heat water by using almost 10 peltiers. However, we have problems about driving the Peltier. What should we do to drive the Peltier? What is needed?
So I went through a lab experiment last week, basically, We have a mixture and we...
So I went through a lab experiment last week, basically, We have a mixture and we remove iron with a magnet, we than seperate naphthalene by sublimation (by heating a flask). Than we have urea which is the only component that can dissolve in water which is obtained by crystallization after seperation from the polypropylene which floats on the water and the sand which sinks. 1) Describe the prinicpal diffuclties you encountered in obtaining a clean seperation and in collecting...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT