Question

In: Finance

Modigiani and Miller theory states that, in a perfect market, although both debt and equity become...

Modigiani and Miller theory states that, in a perfect market, although both debt and equity become riskier due to an increase in the firm’s leverage, both the firm’s value and risk remain exactly the same. Conceptually, what would it take for the firm to become worth more and/or be safer even when both debt and equity become riskier due to an increase in the firm’s leverage?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The tradeoff theory assumes that there are benefits to leverage within a capital structure up until the optimal capital structure is reached. The theory recognizes the tax benefit from interest payments - that is, because interest paid on debt is tax deductible, issuing bonds effectively reduces a company's tax liability. Paying dividends on equity, however, does not. Thought of another way, the actual rate of interest companies pay on the bonds they issue is less than the nominal rate of interest because of the tax savings. Studies suggest, however, that most companies have less leverage than this theory would suggest is optimal.

In comparing the two theories, the main difference between them is the potential benefit from debt in a capital structure, which comes from the tax benefit of the interest payments. Since the MM capital-structure irrelevance theory assumes no taxes, this benefit is not recognized, unlike the tradeoff theory of leverage, where taxes, and thus the tax benefit of interest payments, are recognized.

In summary, the MM I theory without corporate taxes says that a firm's relative proportions of debt and equity don't matter; MM I with corporate taxes says that the firm with the greater proportion of debt is more valuable because of the interest tax shield.



Related Solutions

Using the Modigliani-Miller (MM) theory in a perfect market, you want to evaluate a project and...
Using the Modigliani-Miller (MM) theory in a perfect market, you want to evaluate a project and how to finance it. The project has free cash flows in one year (year 1) of $90 in a weak economy or $120 in a strong economy. There is 75% chance that the economy is strong.  The initial investment required for the project is $80, and the project's cost of capital is 10%.  The risk free interest rate is 5%. Suppose that to raise the funds...
According to Modigliani-Miller propositions, a firm’s cost of equity in a perfect financial market is determined...
According to Modigliani-Miller propositions, a firm’s cost of equity in a perfect financial market is determined by all of the followings EXCEPT ____. Group of answer choices A. risk-free interest rate B. reward to the total business risk C. reward to the nondiversifiable portion of the business risk D. reward to additional risk added by financial leverage
By Definition, the pecking order Theory states that firms prefer to issue debt rather than equity...
By Definition, the pecking order Theory states that firms prefer to issue debt rather than equity if internal finance is insufficient, e.g. due to assymetric information and related (mis)Interpretation by Investors. What does "assymetric Information and Investor misinterpretation actually mean in this context?" I would be very greatful for a thoroughly explained answer.
Assume perfect capital markets. Since the debt claim is senior to the equity claim, debt is...
Assume perfect capital markets. Since the debt claim is senior to the equity claim, debt is cheaper than equity. Therefore, a simple strategy to reduce the cost of capital would be to take on as much debt as possible. DISCUSS this claim concisely.
Modigliani and miller demonstrated that "capital structure does not matter" in a perfect capital market. However,...
Modigliani and miller demonstrated that "capital structure does not matter" in a perfect capital market. However, this statement is at odds due to market imperfections. Explain how market imperfections reshape firm's choice of capital structure.
In the absence of taxes and perfect capital market assumptions what conclusions did Modigliani and Miller...
In the absence of taxes and perfect capital market assumptions what conclusions did Modigliani and Miller make about the relevance of the capital structure decision? Use numerical examples to support your answer.
CASE 15‐12 Debt versus Equity The entity theory of equity implies that there should be no...
CASE 15‐12 Debt versus Equity The entity theory of equity implies that there should be no need for financial statements to distinguish between debt and equity. Alternatively, proprietary theory implies that such a distinction is necessary and yields information vital to owners and potential stockholders. Required: Discuss the entity theory rationale for making no distinction between debt and equity. Is entity theory or proprietary theory consistent with modern theories of finance—that is, does the firm’s capital structure make a difference?...
A company has a market value of equity of $465,710, and a market value of debt...
A company has a market value of equity of $465,710, and a market value of debt of $391,540. The company's levered cash flow (i.e. cash flow after paying all interest) is $75,795 and is distributed annually as dividends in full. The interest rate on the debt is 9.22%. You own $59,230 worth of the market value of the company's equity. Assume that the cash flow is constant in perpetuity, there are no taxes, and you can borrow at the same...
A company has a market value of equity of $465,710, and a market value of debt...
A company has a market value of equity of $465,710, and a market value of debt of $391,540. The company's levered cash flow (i.e. cash flow after paying all interest) is $75,795 and is distributed annually as dividends in full. The interest rate on the debt is 9.22%. You own $59,230 worth of the market value of the company's equity. Assume that the cash flow is constant in perpetuity, there are no taxes, and you can borrow at the same...
A firm has a debt-equity ratio of 4. The market value of the firm’s debt and...
A firm has a debt-equity ratio of 4. The market value of the firm’s debt and equity is £5m. What is the value of the firm’s debt? A: £4.0m B: £3.8m C: £4.5m D: £2.6m A firm has a debt-equity ratio of 4. The cost of debt capital is 8% and the cost of equity capital is 12%. What is the weighted average cost of capital for the firm (WACC)? A: 10.1% B: 8.8% C: 9.5% D: 9.2% Suppose Modigliani-Miller...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT